There are many lines of conversation crossing here.
Some of this thread is reaction to the first detailed info on the content breakdown in the PS+ version, some of it is comparing the initial descriptions of the PS+ version with the current description, some people are very happy to see so much on offer, others expected more relative to the full game, and still others are wondering whether this will count as the PS4's PS+ game for that month, or there will be another title as well.
I'm not sure which argument you think I'm mangling though.
Nor am I upset. I'd love to see posters able to ask why there seems to be a difference between the initial PS+ description and the new one and get a decent response. Instead, posters who bring it up are being jumped on and dismissed as entitled or dupes - now THAT bugs me - because its exactly that which turns these threads into full on arguments and mud slinging, not the raising of the question in the first place.