You right to. Its not a bad game, but folks out here are lying about a perfect score or even a 9 and by no means is it any GOTY. This is a title you want to play with headphones on and sitting back and enjoying how it looks, setting, detail (story maybe) and thats about it, don't go into it thinking it will feel as good as GTAV and you'll be ok. Its a solid playthrough, but you are correct to wait.
Ogbert
Agreed. I like the game and even I agree with folks that feel its boring and the controls are bad. Just cause I REALLY like westerns doesn't mean I'm going to let everything slide, the game ignores all the free agency that made GTA and even the first Red Dead so good. How on earth do you have a game about robbing banks, NOT letting you rob the banks in the open world freely? Put a mask on your face (looks like they can see thru that mask and apparently minority reported your face, name, date of birth, blood type etc to the police all with their minds in real time...)