cireza
Member
OPs intention was to post the best tunes from each console. You are the only one here trying to prove something. Who should start a new thread again ?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
SNES vs Genesis Sound
- Thread starter Beerman462
- Start date
cireza
Member
This is a cover by someone isn't it ? As far as I know, the game is available on Mega-CD and Saturn, but not on MegaDrive.
pramod
Banned
Yeah it's a cover using something called the XGM driver (and lots of memory!), this dude maro has created some pretty mindblowing stuff with it.
Last edited:
Journey
Banned
SNES vs Genesis Sound
VS definition: Used to say that one team or person is competing against another. In this case SNES competing against Genesis Sound.
If it makes you uncomfortable when I say that the SNES has a better overall sound chip for videogames, then just ignore my post. What kind of vs thread doesn't allow a vs reply? pitting Donkey Kong 2 soundtrack from SNES vs Genesis makes perfect sense, you're just salty with the results that I posted, because I'm pretty confident that if it were the Genesis taking the win in those comparisons, you wouldn't see an issue.
cireza
Member
OP is actually the first post of the thread. I don't care about you comparisons, I actually haven't listened to a single of your videos, maybe if your tone was different, you would actually achieve something.
Added you to my ignore list as suggested.
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
Gênesis
Snes
Genesis wins by a landslide!
Snes
Genesis wins by a landslide!
Last edited:
Sakura Doritos
Member
Journey
Banned
The joke is on youJourney . Music is subjective and there are plenty of worthy sound tracks on both systems. We all win. If we all win, was there ever a war to be had?
Music is subjective, yes. The console's capabilities to reproduce sound is not. If you were to create Donkey Kong Country 2 for the PC or Arcade, then translate to consoles, Genesis would fail miserably at trying to replicate those ambiance sounds, it's all I was saying, not that the Genesis can't create some nice tunes.
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
That bass!
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
Oh yeah!
Sakura Doritos
Member
But you are setting up a false dichotomy. There may exist a tune that the Super Nintendo cannot do as effectively.
Both systems and the NeoGeo AES are really special as the ingenious musicians and programmers fit some of the wildest tunes on really small spaces.
D.Final
Banned
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
So there is magic? How possible? Oh yeah Technosoft baby!
Journey
Banned
But there hasn't been, every single tune that the Genesis has mustered has been reproduced with the SPC-700, yet you see what happens when they tried to replicate those Donkey Kong Country 2 stages on the Genesis chip, it had to be completely changed and the environment sounds were lost, I mean how can you reproduce Wind, Rain and frog/cricket sounds using a synthesizer?
The Genesis can produce clearer music and tunes, but sound effects, voices, environment sounds, etc. are lacking and that's part of a console's sound, not just music.
cireza
Member
E
EPSYLON EAGLE
Great contributions !
Here is some Hitoshi Sakimoto, with the game Devilish, great tracks :
Absolutely stunning.
Here is some Hitoshi Sakimoto, with the game Devilish, great tracks :
Absolutely stunning.
Last edited:
Kokoloko85
Member
Probably does have the superior sound chip but really I just see them as awesome games with awesome soundtracks and both systems had many.
In terms of old school Snes/ Megadrive and Saturn / N64 to Dreamcast - Capcom games had my favourite soundtracks followed by Sega games. Sega to me had the better music than Nintendo altogther but its all taste and I still love Nintendo soundtracks. Probably my joint 3rd with Square or Konami
In terms of old school Snes/ Megadrive and Saturn / N64 to Dreamcast - Capcom games had my favourite soundtracks followed by Sega games. Sega to me had the better music than Nintendo altogther but its all taste and I still love Nintendo soundtracks. Probably my joint 3rd with Square or Konami
EightBit Man
Member
D.Final
Banned
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
One more FM materpiece!
D.Final
Banned
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
Some european FM wizardry
D.Final
Banned
EverythingsOverrated
Member
I think the Genesis had a wider spectrum. You had games that sounded like absolute utter sphincter, but then you had games like Streets of Rage 2, or Sonic 2/3/Knuckles with incredible soundtracks.
Overall I go with SNES because FF6, Chrono Trigger, Mario RPG, Super Metroid, Mario World, Actraiser, DKC1 and 2, and so many more still sound damn good today.
Overall I go with SNES because FF6, Chrono Trigger, Mario RPG, Super Metroid, Mario World, Actraiser, DKC1 and 2, and so many more still sound damn good today.
cireza
Member
I have been listening to Jesper Kyd works recently on the console (Red Zone particularly), great unique soundtracks. Really love his style. There are also Sub Terrania and Batman & Robin to check.
His tracks are also pretty long, often 6 minutes or even more. Progressive music.
Last edited:
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
Some japanese glorious tune!
Last edited:
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
I saw somewhere that Jesper Kid acquired his sound driver from Olof Gustafson, a prominent Amiga composer, he also made the Ultracore music.
There is a certain similarity...
There is a certain similarity...
Last edited:
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
Some tropical sensation in saturday night
Last edited: