NYCmetsfan
Banned
vader is a sith
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Star Wars Rogue One - rumored plot synopsis? Comparisons to Oppenheimer...
- Thread starter Shaanyboi
- Start date
- Status
vader is a sith
Do you feel it too?
What did he mean by this?
Member
Death Star II is so funny. Like why wouldnt the Emeperor just build another one?
Of course in the trilogy it's lame tho
Of course in the trilogy it's lame tho
Well that sounds freaking great
1-It explains the Death Star construction time discrepancy, as the Geonosian Prototype had to be perfected, thus giving us the 20 years of construction vs the 2 years (?) for the second one
2-The empire guy trying to atone for the horror he created sounds very damn interesting.
I´m in.
1-It explains the Death Star construction time discrepancy, as the Geonosian Prototype had to be perfected, thus giving us the 20 years of construction vs the 2 years (?) for the second one
2-The empire guy trying to atone for the horror he created sounds very damn interesting.
I´m in.
If Mads dies in like the first 20 minutes, I swear to god....
KoruptData
Member
Shouldn't there be a good chance Vader makes an appearance in this movie?
I don't know...........does Disney like money?
I think ANH to Jedi is 4 years, but your totally right.
friskykillface
Banned
I'll take a Dash Rendar cameo , let him exist Disney
Pls
I'll be on the look out for this, it'll be interesting , that's for sure
Pls
I'll be on the look out for this, it'll be interesting , that's for sure
watch Monsters
Doctor Decimate
Member
But what will happen to the Clone Wars canon of "Tarkin really liked the design of this prison he was in one time"?
KoruptData
Member
Put him in the trailers or try to keep it a surprise? How do you write Vader into a movie and his character just not take over the whole story?
You mistyped Kyle Katarn.
The fact that someone solved some design flaws doesn't override the fact that Tarkin was into that kind of aesthetic.
Have my doubts with this movie because the director made a really giant tease of a film that falls apart on the second viewing and his other, Monsters, I haven't watched.
I honestly have no idea if this will be good, bad, or mediocre. Force Awakens, I immensely enjoyed but I can't stomach any more fan service to the originals (which it will because it takes place in that era). Also, the idea of telling a story that I already know how the ending, it'll be a bit more difficult to craft a really engaging and interesting story.
Rebels manages to do a good job... he could be hunting down Jedi's, chasing rumors of his son... etc. Emperor brings him in, but he's pulled out because of something more important. He could have a really short cameo.
I honestly have no idea if this will be good, bad, or mediocre. Force Awakens, I immensely enjoyed but I can't stomach any more fan service to the originals (which it will because it takes place in that era). Also, the idea of telling a story that I already know how the ending, it'll be a bit more difficult to craft a really engaging and interesting story.
Rebels manages to do a good job... he could be hunting down Jedi's, chasing rumors of his son... etc. Emperor brings him in, but he's pulled out because of something more important. He could have a really short cameo.
It took them 20 years to build the first one. The second Death Star is destroyed a few years after the first one and was fully operational. No way they started work on it after the first one blew up. That shit was being constructed already while the first one was being finished.
Will do!
DrForester
Kills Photobucket
Oh, so the story of the many dead Bothans getting the Death Star II intel isn't one that needs to be told? Bothans don't matter?
Bobby Roberts
Banned
He's fucking WORSE with actors there than he is on Godzilla.
Monsters is fucking terrible.
Anyway, weird choice of story. This will be the second straight Star Wars movie that features a defection as its plot catalyst if this is true.
It's also sorta weird in that if the guy who improved the plans for the Death Star was directly related to someone in the rebellion, and defected with the help of his Rebel daughter, it's not really a case of espionage, is it? Nobody infiltrated the empire and stole anything.
Tatsumaki Senpuukyaku!
Member
How many death stars does one need?
Fourth... ROTS had some jedi turn, I forget his name. AOTC had Dooku turning on the Jedi Council though it happens before the events of the movie so I'm not sure we can count it or not.
Doctor Decimate
Member
Monsters is even worse if you hate what he was trying to do with Godzilla.
On the other hand, this is probably way different than those two so who knows? Both those movies had some nice things going on visually to say the least.
How many star destroyers does one need? They had the resources and they wanted to expand their reach as far as possible. Seems like overkill to me too but whatever.
Well the fucking rebel scum keep blowing them up for no good reason.
Mr. Pointy
Member
What if Galen survives, and is Max Von Sydow in VII?
In a GALAXY? I'd say at least eleventyfive
LegalEagleMike
Member
Not going to happen if these early rumors are true. According to the visual art books Sydow's character has been a Jedi worshipper and an explorer for most of his life.
Tatsumaki Senpuukyaku!
Member
The Death Star's only function is to blow up planets. In space combat, it's pretty much useless. It just kinda sits there. It can't fire it's beam at spaceships (or at least has never demonstrated the ability to) and besides that only has defensive weapons. It obviously costs a fortune and takes tens (hundreds?) of thousands of people just to maintain. Unless in the very unlikely scenario you need to blow up more than one planet at the exact same time, I don't see why you'd need two. The empire has never been smart when it comes to making super weapons though.
There's also whatever the braintrust at Lucas Arts is responsible for. I mean the Kevin Fiege effect is working at full effect over at Marvel to churn out good movies.
Scientist Supreme!
Banned
I'm so excited for this film!
Someone forgot Return of the Jedi.
ryutaro's mama
Member
Missed opportunity. Good grief.
You insert Tekka, give weight to why he
matters in 7 and has such an important role, as well as knowing Leia back when "she was royalty"
You can also show why he is bad ass at acquiring the unfindable.
Oh well...whatevs.
Well do you want to see a female Bothan?
A Fish Aficionado
I am going to make it through this year if it kills me
Bobby Roberts
Banned
Lucas Arts hasn't been a thing for a very long time now, and even if they were, they do video games, not movies.
Neither of those are really "defections" either.
I hate the idea of something as big and stupid and fantastical as the Death Star being treated as a serious analogy for nuclear weapons.
Because Lucasfilm was not under orders to make a Star Wars film every year.
Tatsumaki Senpuukyaku!
Member
Oh shit you're right. I forgot about that part. I still maintain that it's not a very effective offensive weapon when it's not taking out planets. Rewatching the battle, it looks like it can only take out bigger ships and not X-Wings.
BigJonsson
Member
Yeah, you were right though haha.
Cow Mengde
Banned
I'll take it! I look forward to seeing what Edward can do.
Meant LucasFilm. Kathleen Kennedy is, I guess, to Star Wars what Kevin Fiege is to Marvel.
hipsterpants
Member
Don't give Disney any ideas. One film a year is already too many.
- Status