• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Star Wars: The Last Jedi first poster.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is that Anakin or Kylo? I can't tell.

Exactly.

Kylo.

This is a teaser poster.

Also a "work of art" isn't dictated by how much content is in it.

It's also incredibly reductive to label it as "not art". Just because you don't respond to something creative - even if it's just a bit of marketing - doesn't mean it "isn't art". I don't mean to be a stick in the mud, but that's such a below the belt criticism.

Compared to 9 out of 10 pieces of promotional artwork, this is a pretty impressive poster. Simple, but visually striking with clear themes.
 
People saying it's Rey, lol.

Also, it reminds me of:
latest

Captain Command confirmed for MvsC4

Hey, I would buy a Star Wars vs Capcom fighting game!
 
That poster is going to convince girls everywhere that the most important trait in the entire galaxy is to have zero traces of armpit hair at any time

JK looks neat, I like how they're going with an artsy design.
 
Could someone photoshop the hi-res version to remove "December" and the left/right white borders? Would be nice for a phone wallpaper
 
Thinking about it more, I think the "cheap" feel comes from the execution not being the best. Reading through the thread, thinking the execution could have been better isn't exactly an opinion unique. I have no problem with the other teaser posters since they were better executed, so even though they're simple, they don't feel cheap. It's the difference between a film like "The Raid 2" versus one of those direct-to-DVD action films with bad CGI explosions because they spent all their budget getting a washed-up 90s action star to put on the front poster (You can probably think of a few examples). They both are technically "cheap" (made for a low budget), but The Raid 2 is so well executed that it doesn't look cheap. There's no big problems with the Empire teaser's execution, so it doesn't look cheap, even though it's simple.

I'll leave the curved edges bit to personal taste, but the white frame is an obvious throwback to vintage Star Wars posters in terms of design. You even included one of them in your original post.

I should have specified, but I have no problem with the white background itself. It's the combination with the curved edges that makes the entire thing feel "off" to me. It kind of feels like they're trying to sell me an Apple product.


See. Stuff like that was the first thing that came to mind when I saw the poster.
 
Really cool poster. My first impulse was that Anakin was on the right side, not Kylo Ren.

Also, it looks like Rey is balancing the light and the dark side of the force.
 
I think it looks terrible to be honest.

The concept is nice but the execution is flawed at best.

I'm sure we'll get a better one.
 
Edit: seriously, color is awesome, but the offset faces looks strange. Should have gone for the direct side-by-side.

I agree that they look strange, but I think having them the same size, while more aesthetically pleasing, would have been trite.

When does Rey find the time to shave her pits so smooth?
 
I should have specified, but I have no problem with the white background itself. It's the combination with the curved edges that makes the entire thing feel "off" to me. It kind of feels like they're trying to sell me an Apple product.
"Curved edges? White background? Nothing but an Apple ripoff!"

This is you right now. Just... stop, LOL.
 
It not only evokes the original poster for A New Hope, it also has the rounded edges, white background, and red tint of promotional art done by Ralph McQuarrie from 1975:

1lGghhx.jpg


Bonus fact: That's not Luke. That's a woman. This is from the brief period when Lucas was toying with making the primary protagonist female.
 
"Curved edges? White background? Nothing but an Apple ripoff!"

This is you right now. Just... stop, LOL.

Oh come on, if you're going to use a strawman, try better at least. Nowhere in my post did I say it was an Apple ripoff; I just said that it felt like an Apple ad. It was the first thing I thought of when I saw the poster.
 
It not only evokes the original poster for A New Hope, it also has the rounded edges, white background, and red tint of promotional art done by Ralph McQuarrie from 1975:

1lGghhx.jpg


Bonus fact: That's not Luke. That's a woman. This is from the brief period when Lucas was toying with making the primary protagonist female.

The more I think about it, the more I'm convinced that Chewie/Han must have been a bit of a Speaker to Animals / Chmeee rip off very early on.
 
Oh come on, if you're going to use a strawman, try better at least. Nowhere in my post did I say it was an Apple ripoff; I just said that it felt like an Apple ad. It was the first thing I thought of when I saw the poster.
It doesn't look like an Apple ad at all unless you associate anything with curves with an Apple ad.

The curves in this doesn't even look like it lives up to Jony Ive standards.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom