bionic77 said:
One of the few? I thought everyone loved the aesthetic and feel of the 4?
They can obviously improve on the technical stuff (higher res, bigger screen, fix resolution, etc.), but the form factor is perfect.
8 times out of 10, to me, Apple comes out with a new design iteration in a product line, and the design blows me away with how it instantly makes the previous model, which the day before was so awesome, seem like an ancient relic. I really don't know how they do it. Even when the alterations are minor, such as the various iPod designs, they seem like a good step forward.
There's a few times that I think they could've done better, though. My thoughts over the years:
iMac: I wasn't paying much attention to this back in the day, other than they were 'weird' computers. The plastic LCD iMac was a revolutionary all-in-one design, but I didn't like it all that much, but when they moved to the aluminium, my jaw just dropped.
iBook->MacBook: So modern looking. Not enamoured by the now defunct-unibody plastic MacBook though.
PowerBook->MacBook Pro. Unibody is just amazing from an engineering and design stand point. I do have a soft spot for the most recent non-unibodies, however - they are a bit more timeless.
MacBook Air: Amazing.
iPod Shuffle: I liked all the designs, but thought the clip ones with the click-wheel, while better functionally, to be a bit boring, if clever.
iPod: Each iteration kept up with the times in design and materials. The line became really nice looking devices.
iPod Nano: The iPod nano fat was an oddity. I actually kinda liked it, but it wasn't a leap forward in design. The touchscreen one is weird, but nicely designed.
iPod Touch: I actually prefer the 1st gen, where it was more flat overall.
iPhone: I actually don't like the iPhone 3G that much. It did seem more modern at the time, but the design has aged poorly.
I would otherwise say I like the iPhone 4 design (industrial design-wise, it's amazing), but without having seen what an iPhone 5 redesign is like, I don't want to comment on whether I prefer to keep the iPhone 4 design.