ok Gaf I need some input here. My iPhone 4 had about 50% charge on Sunday afternoon when I went to the store. While I'm in the store, I decide to make a phone call. But here's the problem, my phone didn't turn on. No matter what I did the phone didn't turn on. I tried holding down the power button, I pressed the home button several times and nothing. So I head home to try and charge my phone and nothing. So several hours later, I tried again to turn on, press the home button and charge my phone. Still the screen stayed black and my phone didn't respond. So I call Verizon to get a replacement phone and it finally arrived today. But when I pick up my old iPhone to put it in the box to return it, I figured I would try to turn the phone on one more time and it turned on! I was really shocked to see that it turned on but with 10% battery power left. So the question is what should I do? Send back the old one and keep the refurbished one or keep the old one and send back the refurbished one? What would you do?