Net_Wrecker
Member
I don't think the hostility comes from fully disagreeing with what OP is trying to say, more with the manner in which he is trying to get his point across; by creating a video with cherry-picked moments from several playthroughs in which he was apparently actively trying to make the A.I. look as stupid as possible as to support his point, and claiming that it is representative of regular gameplay on the highest difficulty.
I don't think anyone here is legitimately arguing that the A.I. hasn't been downgraded from the E3 demo, nor that this downgrade was disappointing or that the A.I. doesn't have its problems. It's just that the OP has chosen to massively exaggerate the problem and pass it off as regular gameplay, in a thread with a pretty inflammatory thread title (The Last of Us was a disappointing game as opposed to the much more accurately describing the contents of this thread The Last of Us A.I. was disappointing).
He said he went into it looking forward more to the enemy encounters than anything else. If he managed to break them and be disappointed with how they played out vs what we were shown in previews, I think that's a valid reason to call TLoU disappointing.
If it's the way he's argued them or him getting something wrong, I can understand debating it, but a lot of the posts are flat out dismissal just because it's TLoU, or due to some offhand comment about Bioshock/DmC.