-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Xenoblade Chronicles 3D: reviews thread
- Thread starter Aostia
- Start date
There's 0 punch to the battle, you know. The swords don't collide with anything and the numbers goes up. Kinda like a MMO, but worse than some I've played (like Ragnarok Online, for example).
A turn based battle system would be better, IMO.
The rest looks pretty good. The world, the music...
Purple Cheeto
Member
I'm not even sure it was a top 10 one let alone the best. Maybe being portable will mask some of its deficiencies.
The battle system is the biggest flaw in Xenoblade. It's fun to control and you have lots of options. The 'player side' is pretty much fine. The problem is that the enemies don't develop any kind of AI or special abilities to test your skills. For 98% of the game, you can be shulk, run to the back on an enemy, backslash, use other skills, and get by that way. The game only ever asks you to actually think about what you're doing a handful of times across the entire game, making the majority of battles sheer busywork once you know what you're doing. It's more fun busywork than the average JRPG because you're actually controlling your character, but it feels like busywork rather than anything challenging or tactical all the same.
Reyn time? lol
Ah reviews out now, cool.
So I'm getting the impression people think the Wii version is the more superior, was sorta expecting this though I suppose, though with the n3DS version, I may actually be able to complete it and master the gameplay more, which I never feel I truly got on the Wii.
That said, its daunting to think of everything I'll have to do again, ha ha. I must have done every side quest all the way to the start of the "Mechonis area"
So I'm getting the impression people think the Wii version is the more superior, was sorta expecting this though I suppose, though with the n3DS version, I may actually be able to complete it and master the gameplay more, which I never feel I truly got on the Wii.
That said, its daunting to think of everything I'll have to do again, ha ha. I must have done every side quest all the way to the start of the "Mechonis area"
OmegaSmash
Member
Any mention on the audio being compressed? That's one of my biggest worries.
shark sandwich
tenuously links anime, pedophile and incels
I'm disappointed in the uncreative use of the Shulk Amiibo, as well as the lack of new features. Still excited for this regardless as it was the best JRPG of the last decade IMO. I'm glad more gamers will finally get the chance to experience it.
pinkurocket
Member
You can't have a reynbow without reyn baby.
MaximumSpider
Banned
I need this in my 3DS nowwww
Chû Totoro
Member
I don't have 70 hours to spend on a game...
...but this seems to be such an awesome adventure :'(
I may buy it even if I play a few dozen hours. How long does the game takes to be interesting?
Don't say after "Screen Title" lol (even if this screen has sort of hypnotized me making want to play it more)
...but this seems to be such an awesome adventure :'(
I may buy it even if I play a few dozen hours. How long does the game takes to be interesting?
Don't say after "Screen Title" lol (even if this screen has sort of hypnotized me making want to play it more)
It's only one of the most critically acclaimed rpgs in the last decade after all, so I can see why you are not sure
shark sandwich
tenuously links anime, pedophile and incels
Chû Totoro;157414564 said:
After the first hour or two I was hooked. As soon as you get the opportunity to explore the huge environments you won't want to stop.
Purple Cheeto
Member
Because the acclaim of the games enthusiast press carries so much weight. You'll forgive me if I dont blindly follow paid fanboys and develop my own opinions.
Crimsonclaw111
Member
I would love an eShop release of the original on the Wii U, I just don't see this one selling a lot.
I never had a Wii, so I was never able to check this game out, but I have to say, the 3DS port just looks awful. I mean, there's only so much they could do, considering how underpowered the system is, not to mention the abysmal resolution of Nintendo's handheld.
I don't have a N3DS, but even if I did, I wouldn't pick this up. Compared to some screenshots I've seen of the game running on Dolphin, I don't think I'd be able to put up with these frankly horrible visuals.
I don't have a N3DS, but even if I did, I wouldn't pick this up. Compared to some screenshots I've seen of the game running on Dolphin, I don't think I'd be able to put up with these frankly horrible visuals.
Chû Totoro
Member
I used to play J-RPG but my favourites are on Snes, Playstation or Dreamcast... I'm not into MMOs and I don't like Monster Hunter.
I'm not sure what I'm saying helps but do you think I could enjoy it?
note : I'm trying hard to find a justification but I know I'm going to buy this since I have to try one of the best games of last gen... (I'm so weak)
Edit :
And we're done... pre ordered (EU version here). I've said it, I'm weak
but can I live without at least having tried this game? 
how do you know that it is mediocre? do you have the game?
All the reviews are saying that the port isn't great. I own the original and I'm not compelled to get this version based on what's being said.
TheSlySoul
Member
Oh, so I wasn't crazy when I dropped the game because I was not liking the battle system? Cool. Willing to give it another shot on 3DS.
It being portable is a big appeal to me because I got nothing to do when I go to my parent's home. That is when I tend to play my RPGs.Chû Totoro;157414564 said:
Kadin
Member
So it seems like, from what I'm gathering, is that this version doesn't really warrant a purchase if you already have the Wii version. I mostly play my 3DS at home so I'm guessing it's worth passing for the time being. I was just hoping for some improvements to entice me to double dip.
Weltall Zero
Member
This is an accurate assessment.
I wish they actually had more competition, but still.
but they are not saying that it is mediocre......
TheSlySoul
Member
This is sad that it is true. Blue Dragon was the last JRPG I enjoyed.
Seems FFXV is shaping up well though. Had a blast with the demo, even if I got lost.
patrickthehedgehog
Member
So, the 3D is faked in this one? No thanks. The nerve of them to include it in the name if it isn't true 3D.
It was the only redeeming feature of this version. I can't stand when devs do that in 3DS games like EOIV and now even moreso that the N3DS has better 3D with the tracking.
It was the only redeeming feature of this version. I can't stand when devs do that in 3DS games like EOIV and now even moreso that the N3DS has better 3D with the tracking.
shark sandwich
tenuously links anime, pedophile and incels
Chû Totoro;157415827 said:
I think so. It's nothing like Monster Hunter. The battle system is a little MMO-ish. You have all these skills with their own cooldown timers. You only control one character at a time while AI controls the rest. Managing aggro and using your teammates synergistically are both super important (e.g. some characters have moves that do massive damage from the rear or sides, or have status effects that can be built upon e.g. some moves can inflict "daze" status, other moves can inflict "topple" on a dazed enemy, other moves can inflict "stun" on a toppled enemy, etc.).
Also, weapons and armor show up on your characters and they are unique to each character (e.g. if you equip the same armor on all 3 party members they will still look completely different). It's an awesome touch that I wish more JRPGs would do.
Kadin
Member
Yeah I was just watching GameXplain's review video and they said the feature should just be turned off. I like to use the feature finally since it works better on the N3DS and to have this part work so poor (or virtually non-existent) is disappointing.
StriKeVillain
Banned
Very excited to check this out. Never got to play the initial release on Wii.
eighty(one)
Member
I have the Wii version, have never played it; I've always meant to, just never have.
This seems like the prefect experience for me, as I play on handhelds more than console.
I'd like to know (love 3D, love it even more on N3DS): how is the 3D effect in this game?
Mammoth Jones
Member
To be fair, Xenoblade is one of those rare games where it was not only highly regarded by the press, but even more highly regarded by fans.
Yeah, but Persona 4 Golden released on stronger Hardware no weaker Hardware. So its clear that there were only going to be improvements.
I think this could be a good experience for you.
The 3D effect (I disagree with other reviews on this) is not very strong, but stable on the N3ds, and help a little bit in reading the space around you (more depth in reading locations and enemy/player positioning)
Astral Dog
Member
what? Xenoblade was critically acclaimed and well recieved, among the hardcore niche that bought it at least, it also has a positive thread every now and then.
MaverickHunterAsh
Member
Hey guys, Ash from GameXplain here! I reviewed Xenoblade Chronicles 3D and came to post a link, but it looks like you all long since beat me to it.
That said, I also have a written review published on Game On/Examiner that's slightly longer than my GameXplain one and hasn't been added to the OP yet, so here's the link for that. I gave it 4 out of 5 stars (numerical scores are required there):
http://www.examiner.com/review/xeno...view-still-feeling-it-but-maybe-a-little-less
Not quite faked - there is an incredibly subtle 3D effect with the slider engaged - but yeah, it's so slight and shallow that it almost might as well not even be there. It certainly doesn't add anything. That's not too surprising based on what Nintendo's been saying about how difficult the porting process was, but it's still kind of a shame.
That said, I also have a written review published on Game On/Examiner that's slightly longer than my GameXplain one and hasn't been added to the OP yet, so here's the link for that. I gave it 4 out of 5 stars (numerical scores are required there):
http://www.examiner.com/review/xeno...view-still-feeling-it-but-maybe-a-little-less
Not quite faked - there is an incredibly subtle 3D effect with the slider engaged - but yeah, it's so slight and shallow that it almost might as well not even be there. It certainly doesn't add anything. That's not too surprising based on what Nintendo's been saying about how difficult the porting process was, but it's still kind of a shame.
Chû Totoro
Member
Thanks all for your answers, I think I'll enjoy the game.
Being a completely new adventure for me will also add a lot I guess. And since I'm looking at Xenoblade X too I think it may be a good indicator whether I'm still into J-RPGs and more importantly if I can still be motivate to start such big games.
Being a completely new adventure for me will also add a lot I guess. And since I'm looking at Xenoblade X too I think it may be a good indicator whether I'm still into J-RPGs and more importantly if I can still be motivate to start such big games.