First one also got a 10.
Because people love to bitch about lists here's their top 10 games of the generation:
10 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
9 LittleBigPlanet
8 Bayonetta
7 Super Street Fighter IV
6 Red Dead Redemption
5 Grand Theft Auto V
4 Portal
3 The Last of Us
2 Super Mario Galaxy
1 Dark Souls
This is true but they are historically harsher with sequels are they not? GOTY perhaps? What else is there to compete?
Assassins Creed? Dragon Age Inquisition? Shadow of Mordor? Not sure any of them will be as good, although Bayo 2 could be too niche.