Why is it the least of things we should worry about? Is the gaming side of GAF full of more pressing issues at the moment? Imagine if you went into threads about a game being unoptimized on PC with the attitude of "if you entitled brats don't like it you don't have to buy it there's more important things to worry about!"
Yes it's true all we have to go off of is a teaser pic and it's very possible rdr2 could have more diverse cast and story than anybody is expecting. My problem isn't that. It's that people are shutting down conversations about better representation and diversity full stop, and it's not the first time it's happened here. People trying to dismiss it as not being a real issue, because it might force them to be somewhat critical of some of their favorite developers or games, are displaying such a pathetic and small minded view of the world. Representation does matter. It matters in movies and it tv and yes, now even in video games, and if you guys really are so overprotective of your hobby, you should be all for it because it will do nothing but expand the audience that might buy a game.
I honestly don't see that many people shutting down the diversity convo, I just see some people agreeing and some disagreeing that it is important to this particular game. Clearly you think it is important which it is okay but that doesn't invalidate the other opinions.
I think representation is super important in all mediums, and in particular videogames since it has the least amount of minority representation. I just feel it is important to be able to have a nuanced discussion based on each particular piece of art and seeing if the narrative fits or not. For example, a show like Girls is a personal story about a Jewish girl's experience. I hated the fact that they added Donald Glover in it just to make people feel better. It felt forced and sort of passive aggressive. I didn't think him being black added anything to the story line whatsoever. Also it is realistic that some white only know white people. On the other hand, there are other shows in which I've questioned why the seemed to only have white people when the story and setting called for a more diverse cast in my eyes. I think these things should be evaluated on a case by case basis.
I want more Shonda Rimes in Hollywood and in videogames than I do Viola Davis' if that makes sense. The more Shonda Rimes we get, the more stories we can get with a diverse cast and diverse storytelling.
Right now, my two favorite shows are Insecure and Atlanta. Both showrunners are black and the dialogue,characters and stories show this. I don't think those shows would be as good if the showrunners were white.