• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Arrow S5 |OT| You thought you were out, but Manu Bennett pulls you back in.

morningbus

Serious Sam is a wicked gahbidge series for chowdaheads.
Chase may not be involved with this, actually. This could be Helix trying to tie up the team Arrow loose end.
 

morningbus

Serious Sam is a wicked gahbidge series for chowdaheads.
First dud of the season imo.

If this is a season's miss, I'll take it.

Good character work with some genuine moments and brief, but well staged action.

Who would have thought at the beginning of this season that Wild Dog would be the emotional core of the show?
 

ZeroX03

Banned
I mean this might be the weakest episode of the season or at least in the bottom three (weak action, not much related to the main plot) but it was still fine. We know next week is going to be rough too, but the last three episodes are pure fire. It's insane how consistent this run has been. Maybe like 18.5/19? The Wild Dog stuff was fun, even if it was very clear they shot it all within like two hours on the one set. I think this and next week are budget saving episodes lol.
 

ShadyK54

Member
That was an amazing episode. Damn Arrow is so good now.

Same here.

An episode like this I would've normally been bored by. This season of Arrow has done a crazy job of getting me invested in this story. Hell, I really liked the Oliver and Felicity scenes. Great moments between those two characters.
 

Magwik

Banned
The only downside to the episode was no actual pay off as to who the dude was or why he was so dangerous. Reeks a lot of what they tried to do with Dahrk at the end of S3.
 
That's a little much. How is her behavior here like her behavior in S3 and 4?

Attitude.
It legitimately bothers me more than it honestly should.
She said something at one point and my mind was instantly "im not watching this next season if she is still around"

Then im thinking "wait this season has been incredible and this is the first problem with her all season"

I guess I start flashing back to the atom suit and wheelchair walk and it triggers me.
 

jb1234

Member
I don't know. I liked the episode overall but I don't feel the writers did the necessary work needed to justify Felicity vs. Arrow team. Her motivations are clear (STOP CHASE) but I just don't understand why she's willing to alienate everyone else to get the job done. It's all very murky. That said, it was certainly exciting and the whole climatic action scene was a nailbiter (even if not excitingly directed).

Also loved the Chesthair/Dog subplot. Those two make a good pairing. On the other hand, Curtis feels like he should be on The Flash instead (or at least a less dour version of that show). His quips are forced.
 
The only downside to the episode was no actual pay off as to who the dude was or why he was so dangerous. Reeks a lot of what they tried to do with Dahrk at the end of S3.

I like the set up more truth be told .
Since we have seen what Helix can do and how far they willing to go .
Yeah there is no pay off but it's fun seeing the big bad set up for next season .

Attitude.
It legitimately bothers me more than it honestly should.
She said something at one point and my mind was instantly "im not watching this next season if she is still around"

Then im thinking "wait this season has been incredible and this is the first problem with her all season"

I guess I start flashing back to the atom suit and wheelchair walk and it triggers me.

She has the same attitude since season 1.
Truth is this storyline make sense for her after what has happen in the last 4 seasons .
 

morningbus

Serious Sam is a wicked gahbidge series for chowdaheads.
Attitude.
It legitimately bothers me more than it honestly should.
She said something at one point and my mind was instantly "im not watching this next season if she is still around"

Then im thinking "wait this season has been incredible and this is the first problem with her all season"

I guess I start flashing back to the atom suit and wheelchair walk and it triggers me.

Oh, so:

jKAqmi4.png


She's going to be a major cast member on the show for the foreseeable future and you're going to have to get used to it, man.
 

Magwik

Banned
My favorite part was Felicity helping a terrorist organization break their leader from a maximum security government black site, and the episode ends with Ollie apologizing to her.
 
My favorite part was Felicity helping a terrorist organization break their leader from a maximum security government black site, and the episode ends with Ollie apologizing to her.

Was he?

She didn't even let him speak lol

Ended up blowing up in her face anyways....pun intended.
 

Htown

STOP SHITTING ON MY MOTHER'S HEADSTONE
My favorite part was Felicity helping a terrorist organization break their leader from a maximum security government black site, and the episode ends with Ollie apologizing to her.

yeah that's totally behavior that's completely unlike anything Oliver has ever done

what an unjustifiable way for a member of this vigilante team to act
 
yeah that's totally behavior that's completely unlike anything Oliver has ever done

what an unjustifiable way for a member of this vigilante team to act


Why are we comparing moralities here?

Felicity doing it against the wishes of one of her own allies and CLOSE FRIENDS is definitely crossing a line. Its the reason Diggle was pissed at Oliver in S3.
 

ZeroX03

Banned
Oliver just tried to make a deal with the Bratva and it blew up in his face lol. He even admitted it was a moral fuck up. I think he understands where Felicity is coming from more than the rest, but she just saw how bad of an idea these kind of shenanigans are.

Diggle is right, as usual. Two extremes and neither are great.

Her motivations are clear (STOP CHASE) but I just don't understand why she's willing to alienate everyone else to get the job done. It's all very murky.

Felicity is still grieving over Billy, which is why she's going to such extremes. I don't think the episode even name checked him, they're trying to be a bit more subtle about these things.
 

Skux

Member
First dud of the season imo.

Felicity and Mr terrific were so annoying.

Yeah this was the weakest episode of the season. Chasing Chase took a very hard detour into this very loosely related sidequest which didn't do enough to convince us that Felicity has a valid viewpoint, which meant we'd always be on Oliver's side and Felicity would just come off as annoying again. Cayden was not established as a credible enough lead that could find Chase - he wasn't even given a face the whole episode. You could see the writers were keeping him faceless to try to give it thematic resonance with the "ends justifies the means" arguments (shown in the dialogue between Diggle and Lila), but it was at odds with the main storyline. We needed to know who Cayden was and why he was important in order to be on board with Felicity, and we never got that.

And then her getting into heels and makeup for a heist was just silly.
 

Sir Doom

Member
Oh great we have a character whose purpose are quips. MR Terrible
We're trying to protect someone but he's not here. Psyched 💩
Writers: we need to create commercial break drama

Huh the prison is a container. Very sophisticated

Hoss scenes were my favorite. Still better premier than Flash
 
Why are we comparing moralities here?

Felicity doing it against the wishes of one of her own allies and CLOSE FRIENDS is definitely crossing a line. What Oliver has done doesn't matter.

What Oliver has done is the reason why she did it .
Of course it blows up in her face but i guess Oliver was not the only person that need a lesson this season .

Yeah this was the weakest episode of the season. Chasing Chase took a very hard detour into this very loosely related sidequest which didn't do enough to convince us that Felicity has a valid viewpoint, which meant we'd always be on Oliver's side and Felicity would just come off as annoying again. Cayden was not established as a credible enough lead that could find Chase - he wasn't even given a face the whole episode.

And then her getting into heels and makeup for a heist was just silly.

Felicity view point was clear and even Oliver knew why she was doing it .
Still just like when Oliver made the deal with the Bratva it did not work out .
As Zero said Dig stays winning.
 

Effect

Member
"We're safe."

LOL they just dumped her. You got played Felicity. Well, at least she maybe did get something.

I was really happy to see that. Would have been better if she had gone back to the lair only to find out she either couldn't get in or none of the computer accepted her login.
 
Yeah this was the weakest episode of the season. Chasing Chase took a very hard detour into this very loosely related sidequest which didn't do enough to convince us that Felicity has a valid viewpoint, which meant we'd always be on Oliver's side and Felicity would just come off as annoying again. Cayden was not established as a credible enough lead that could find Chase - he wasn't even given a face the whole episode. You could see the writers were keeping him faceless to try to give it thematic resonance with the "ends justifies the means" arguments (shown in the dialogue between Diggle and Lila), but it was at odds with the main storyline. We needed to know who Cayden was and why he was important in order to be on board with Felicity, and we never got that.

And then her getting into heels and makeup for a heist was just silly.

yet ;)
 

jb1234

Member
Felicity is still grieving over Billy, which is why she's going to such extremes. I don't think the episode even name checked him, they're trying to be a bit more subtle about these things.

I'm not convinced that her grief (which has barely been shown recently) is enough motivation to drive her on a course that puts her out on the field against Team Arrow.
 
Yeah Billy hasn't been mentioned in like what, 10 episodes? Felicity is way over him by now.

They don't need to mention him for you to know that she still wants revenge\cared for him .
Timeline wise it's been about 3 to 5 months since that happen .

EDIT The current bad guy making your former fiancée kill your current BF would take a while to get over .
Still they should have done a better job storyline wise.
 

Zen Aku

Member
If this is a season's miss, I'll take it.

Good character work with some genuine moments and brief, but well staged action.

Who would have thought at the beginning of this season that Wild Dog would be the emotional core of the show?
Honestly if this episode is our "urghh FelicityXOliver drama moment" then I'll take it. It's nowhere near as bad as Season 3 or 4.

It was actually pretty good seeing how Felicity called out Oliver on his willingness to do anything and Oliver hesitant knowing that maybe "doing whatever it takes" haven't worked out well for him so far.
 
Top Bottom