Agreed. Uncharted has excellent villain characters. There's not one I don't love playing as in multiplayer. All fun and full of personality.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - Review Thread
- Thread starter Kenzodielocke
- Start date
Agreed. Uncharted has excellent villain characters. There's not one I don't love playing as in multiplayer. All fun and full of personality.
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
Gotta say ND is by far the biggest disappointment for this gen. They are making only 2 games instead of 4 (no I don't consider a DLC game as another, it's cool if other people do). On top of that, they make new IPs every generation, this gen we're stuck with Uncharted and TLOU. Don't get me wrong, Uncharted is one of my favorite franchises, U4 is one of the best games this gen, and TLOU is one of the best and one of my favorite games of all time. But two fucking games and no new IPs is a huge bummer.Still buying the DLC this month and finishing it, esp since my girl Chloe is back. But yeah, I'm pretty underwhelmed. Rockstar is another that focuses halfway through this gen on a last gen game still, but that's a whole other story.
Didn't know where else to rant about this, but yeah :\
I would've agreed with you a year ago, but in four days we are getting an 6-8 hour campaign which is in line with U1 and U3. you are jumping through hoops to dismiss this campaign as a DLC game even though it has a physical release.
I would've loved to have them do a Sci-Fi game, but i didnt realize how much i wanted TLOU Part II until i saw that trailer. i am not a fan of U4 but there is no denying how talented Neil druckmann is and how invested i am in joel and elle's characters. it will also have a gen leap which means new mechanics, new ideas and will let them do anything they couldnt do due to hardware limitations of the PS3.
It could be the Uncharted 2 of the last of us.
Gotta say ND is by far the biggest disappointment for this gen. They are making only 2 games instead of 4 (no I don't consider a DLC game as another, it's cool if other people do). On top of that, they make new IPs every generation, this gen we're stuck with Uncharted and TLOU. Don't get me wrong, Uncharted is one of my favorite franchises, U4 is one of the best games this gen, and TLOU is one of the best and one of my favorite games of all time. But two fucking games and no new IPs is a huge bummer.
Didn't know where else to rant about this, but yeah :\
I feel you, but they did work on two new IPs last gen, and both just turn out to be very successful. I understand why they had to make another Uncharted and I obviously understand why they are working on a new TLOU. Anyway, these projects are getting bigger and bigger so it's difficult to pump them out at the same rate.
I would've loved a new IP by now, but I'm sure they will work on the new next, at least.
Lost Legacy counts as a game and if U4 didn't have to get reworked heavily after Amy left we possibly could have gotten 4 from them this gen. Combine that with the huge expectations on ND for quality, your own post being a perfect example of that, and slowing down a bit isn't a huge surprise. Hell, even among Sony first party they're putting out more than the other studios aside from Guerrilla.Gotta say ND is by far the biggest disappointment for this gen. They are making only 2 games instead of 4 (no I don't consider a DLC game as another, it's cool if other people do). On top of that, they make new IPs every generation, this gen we're stuck with Uncharted and TLOU. Don't get me wrong, Uncharted is one of my favorite franchises, U4 is one of the best games this gen, and TLOU is one of the best and one of my favorite games of all time. But two fucking games and no new IPs is a huge bummer.
Didn't know where else to rant about this, but yeah :
SnowFlakeCake
Member
As much as I do not like UC4 and how it came out so long after PS4 released, you cannot fault ND for their output this generation. The simple reason for UC4 taking years was what happened with Hennig, we do not know the full story but it is quite clear a lot of the game had to be done again. Now, they have made a pretty long experience in a little over a year so that is impressive in terms of output.
The technology is in place and the whole studio should be on TLOU2 now, so very excited to hear ND starting to give details about the game. A demo at PSX seems like a huge stretch but fuck it, hoping we get something!
In terms off shit output for first party, it is safe to say none of Sonys studios except for GG have been good regarding input. MM, PD, SSM, Bend have released fuck all after 4 years, Sucker Punch went to sleep, Quantic made it sound like Detroit has still got a ways to go etc. It has not been a great generation for me because I got the PS4 for first party and in all honesty, 3rd party games are pretty shit with most chasing GAAS money.
The technology is in place and the whole studio should be on TLOU2 now, so very excited to hear ND starting to give details about the game. A demo at PSX seems like a huge stretch but fuck it, hoping we get something!
In terms off shit output for first party, it is safe to say none of Sonys studios except for GG have been good regarding input. MM, PD, SSM, Bend have released fuck all after 4 years, Sucker Punch went to sleep, Quantic made it sound like Detroit has still got a ways to go etc. It has not been a great generation for me because I got the PS4 for first party and in all honesty, 3rd party games are pretty shit with most chasing GAAS money.
As I've said a few pages back, I'd definitely rank it above 1 and 4. It has a great mix of all the typical Uncharted elements and there aren't chapters or segments that feel padded out. Also there is little to no crate/gimme a boost! bs aside from the opening. It has a cool intro, but it's not long before you're in the West Ghats. Pacing is pretty brisk.
This game has the perfect length at 7-8 hours. I'm currently replaying it, so I think that says enough. I never felt like replaying Uncharted 4.
DriftingSpirit
Member
To be fair, SSM had a cancelled new IP and Bend had some cancelled projects as well. Sucker Punch is working on a new IP.
Ninja Scooter
Member
Gotta say ND is by far the biggest disappointment for this gen. They are making only 2 games instead of 4 (no I don't consider a DLC game as another, it's cool if other people do). On top of that, they make new IPs every generation, this gen we're stuck with Uncharted and TLOU. Don't get me wrong, Uncharted is one of my favorite franchises, U4 is one of the best games this gen, and TLOU is one of the best and one of my favorite games of all time. But two fucking games and no new IPs is a huge bummer.
Didn't know where else to rant about this, but yeah :
Wtf Is Lost Legacy if not a game? Why do people feel like you can have differing opinions or viewpoints on something like this? It's a game. That is factual. Man some people are weird af with this stuff.
Gotta say ND is by far the biggest disappointment for this gen. They are making only 2 games instead of 4 (no I don't consider a DLC game as another, it's cool if other people do). On top of that, they make new IPs every generation, this gen we're stuck with Uncharted and TLOU. Don't get me wrong, Uncharted is one of my favorite franchises, U4 is one of the best games this gen, and TLOU is one of the best and one of my favorite games of all time. But two fucking games and no new IPs is a huge bummer.
Didn't know where else to rant about this, but yeah :\
I think you are being 1) a bit harsh by saying this is DLC and not a game from all accounts of what it seems to be and 2) a bit unrealistic.
Regarding #2, I think you are being unrealistic because games take more time to develop and they had some unforseen delays with UC4. Also, with the sales of TLOU, there was zero chance that Sony wasn't going to have them do a sequel. Look for a new IP next gen and enjoy the awesome ride/games from ND this gen.
I'm happy that a lot of reviewers liked the game. The ACG review really excited me. I'm just going to get my copy Tuesday and enjoy it. It's a Naughty Dog game, best girl Chloe is back, Indian culture is very interesting, and LL is possibly the last ever ND Uncharted game or Uncharted period.
I really just want to be positive and enjoy my hobby with a series I've loved for the past decade.
I really just want to be positive and enjoy my hobby with a series I've loved for the past decade.
Duchess O'Death
Member
Just listened to the Game Informer podcast and they're loving it!
shortsoptional
Member
Obviously it will depend on when the generation ends, but I still think you might get 4 this gen if you consider LL a game (which I think a lot do).
Uncharted 4
Lost Legacy
The Last of Us: Part II
Then maybe....maybe, when Bruce Straley comes back, he'll direct something new to put in at the end of the generation just like they did with TLoU? Obviously that is wishful thinking, but I don' t think it's crazy either.
And I echo what others have said. The first Uncharted was over a decade ago and games didn't cost as much or take as much time as they do now.
Uncharted 4
Lost Legacy
The Last of Us: Part II
Then maybe....maybe, when Bruce Straley comes back, he'll direct something new to put in at the end of the generation just like they did with TLoU? Obviously that is wishful thinking, but I don' t think it's crazy either.
And I echo what others have said. The first Uncharted was over a decade ago and games didn't cost as much or take as much time as they do now.
ronaldthump
Member
Just finished
UC2 > TLL > 4 > 3 >1
That was fucking amazing. It's now my 2nd favourite uncharted. Basically possibly what uncharted 4 should have been - its quite clear they listened to the feedback about 4.
Perfectly packed. There's a whole lot of combat in this so don't listen to the people saying there isn't. What a wonderful game.
Before TLL I'd say I'm done with the franchise but you know what? Bring on a sequel!
UC2 > TLL > 4 > 3 >1
That was fucking amazing. It's now my 2nd favourite uncharted. Basically possibly what uncharted 4 should have been - its quite clear they listened to the feedback about 4.
Perfectly packed. There's a whole lot of combat in this so don't listen to the people saying there isn't. What a wonderful game.
Before TLL I'd say I'm done with the franchise but you know what? Bring on a sequel!
9/10
TLOU:II is a 2019 title at the earliest, and by then I would expect we'll be near PS5 getting announced. I think that will be it for this gen for ND.
Nightengale
Member
ND as a studio didn't exactly enter this gen all roses and sunshine.
It seems like forever ago, but for all intents and purpose, ND went through a big upheaval of its own this gen with the 'cancellation' of the original Uncharted 4, and the studio basically had to scramble, reboot and start from scratch (ish) on a retooled Uncharted 4.
In slightly less than two years.
Anecdotally, observing from Twitter, the period of Uncharted 4's development was one where I see ND devs crunching for MONTHS AND MONTHS on end.
The fact that ND is able to pull off TLL in basically a year's time, give or take, shows that ND still got it in terms of how efficient they are. But they started off this gen poorly, which impacted their initial output and lineup for this gen.
It seems like forever ago, but for all intents and purpose, ND went through a big upheaval of its own this gen with the 'cancellation' of the original Uncharted 4, and the studio basically had to scramble, reboot and start from scratch (ish) on a retooled Uncharted 4.
In slightly less than two years.
Anecdotally, observing from Twitter, the period of Uncharted 4's development was one where I see ND devs crunching for MONTHS AND MONTHS on end.
The fact that ND is able to pull off TLL in basically a year's time, give or take, shows that ND still got it in terms of how efficient they are. But they started off this gen poorly, which impacted their initial output and lineup for this gen.
D
Deleted member 471617
Unconfirmed Member
I have been satisfied with Naughty Dog thus far and the generation isn't even four years old yet. To get TLOUR in July 2014 which was a year after it originally came out for PS3 was a surprise. While Uncharted 4 is the lowest rated in the series for me personally, I still gave it an 8.5/10 which is between great and excellent. I'm fully expecting TLL to hit my 9/10 scale and be the second best in the series after U2 for me personally.
I don't think that Uncharted is done yet either. I can easily see Naughty Dog releasing another standalone game for $40 after TLOU2. Speaking of TLOU2, I can easily see that franchise being a trilogy with TLOU2 possibly being a cross gen game for PS4/PS5.
The quality is what matters most. Last gen, Naughty Dog gave us four games. This generation, it will be three plus the TLOU re-master. As a PlayStation and Naughty Dog fan, I can't complain in regards to their quality as it's top notch.
Back to TLL, im hyped and pumped for Tuesday. Can't wait!!!
I don't think that Uncharted is done yet either. I can easily see Naughty Dog releasing another standalone game for $40 after TLOU2. Speaking of TLOU2, I can easily see that franchise being a trilogy with TLOU2 possibly being a cross gen game for PS4/PS5.
The quality is what matters most. Last gen, Naughty Dog gave us four games. This generation, it will be three plus the TLOU re-master. As a PlayStation and Naughty Dog fan, I can't complain in regards to their quality as it's top notch.
Back to TLL, im hyped and pumped for Tuesday. Can't wait!!!
blastprocessor
The Amiga Brotherhood
What is that movie?
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
Yeah, the Amy Henning and Justin Richmond departure probably cost them at least a year or more. I loved Amy's original pitch for the game where Drake's brother is bitter and angry at Drake for leaving him in jail, and would've probably been the villain of the game. going up against your brother would've been a lot more personal than previous games and would've created a much more interesting dynamic. I really didnt like how Sam was Drake-lite and had a pretty easy going relationship with Drake for most of the game. And just when you find out he essentially lied to Drake, they take him away so you dont really get a confrontation and some nice meaty scenes.
I have no idea why it's taking everyone so long to make video games all of a sudden. Cancelled IPs from big name studios like Sony Santa Monica is bizarre. PD releasing a game without a real campaign after FOUR years of dev time is bizarre. Dreams being in development hell after 6 years of dev time is bizarre. It's quickly approaching TLG status. Why havent we seen the Sucker Punch new IP after 3 and a half years of dev time? It used to take them 2 years to release a new game, now they have nothing to show after nearly 4 years of dev time?
Exactly. People simply wanted to see a next gen Uncharted. We might not have gotten a lot of incredible setpieces but ND blew us away with the graphics so they delivered on that at least. I do hope they give Uncharted a break and come back late next gen with a new take on the franchise.
Acquiescence
Member
Monty Python and The Holy Grail.
DriftingSpirit
Member
I think PS5 is 2020 and TLoU:II will be announced for fall 2018 but delayed to summer 2019. They won't be able to get another game out before fall of the following year. Not another mainline entry anyway. Maybe they could do a Lost Legacy type thing with TLoU: II.
They're showing quite a bit here. People wanting to remain 100% spoilerfree probably shouldn't watch this
ronaldthump
Member
what sort of weird statement is this? TLOU is GOTG for many and Left behind isn't H+S above the main game.
The Dark Shape
Neo Member
It takes longer as hardware gets more and more complicated. Also, at these resolutions, assets take considerably more time to create now than they used to. The difference between a texture created for PS3 to be displayed at 720p and a texture created for PS4 to be displayed somewhere between 1080p-4K is insane.
joe_zazen
Member
It was for me. The characters, gameplay, and story all supported each other: it was seamless and felt almost real.
If they didn't have to make the main game 90% stealth action shooter, it would have been better. Story and characters had to be shoehorned into the bits between murder-festing, which always takes me right out of the story and makes the characters feel hollow. I'd rather play a game without those pretentions,like Lego Dimensions or Doom (2016); than ones with, like Bioshock Infinite and TLOU.
Ymmv of course, as people have different tolerances for these things.
D
Deleted member 471617
Unconfirmed Member
TLOU was one of four games I gave a 9.5/10 last gen but the Left Behind DLC was at best a 7/10 and that's being generous simply because outside of the end with the awesome battle, it was simply boring.
ronaldthump
Member
LB would not have had the emotional impact that you think it had; had TLOU not been as good as it is.
DriftingSpirit
Member
Agreed.
Left Behind is the best DLC I've bought and that is in part because of how well it ties into the main game.
joe_zazen
Member
Also, they usually have to produce a bunch of content that requires musicians, composers, actors, directors, script writers, editors etc. That takes a lot time.
joe_zazen
Member
The writing of TLOU? most definitely. The gameplay? not so much.
Edit: again, this is only my subjective perspective/experience.
Fuck it I'm back in.
Yautja_Warrior
Member
Left Behind was fantastic, outstanding even, as a mini prequel story but I wouldn't say it was head and shoulders above the main game, only because that was fantastic too and had much more story to tell. I'd say they compliment each other very well though and together make it an essential gaming experience.
The Lost Legacy is more of Uncharted 4 in a way but with some tweaks, so maybe not as special as an Uncharted 5 would have been but that's hardly a bad thing and the game is still excellent overall.
Lol, they are actually showing bits the NDA said reviewers couldn't talk about.
kraspkibble
Permabanned.
lol Left Behind wasn't better than the main game.
Suburban Thug
Member
Just preordered from GameStop for the Jak and Daxter bonus, how do I redeem it? Is the code on the receipt or will I get it when I pick up my copy of Uncharted on Tuesday?
It's either in the case with the game or on the receipt when you pick up.
Suburban Thug
Member
Cool, thanks for the quick response!
Lol what?
Left Behind was in no way better than the main game. It was good, but super short.
DriftingSpirit
Member
86 meta with 62 reviews.
ASilentProtagonist
Member
I agree. I think with Neil Druckmann directing, it will get delayed once or twice, guaranteed.
Impulsegamer 4.5/5
Attack of the Fanboy 4.5/5
https://aotf.com/reviews/uncharted-the-lost-legacy-review/
Hardcore Gamer 4.5/5
http://www.hardcoregamer.com/2017/08/17/review-uncharted-the-lost-legacy/268331/
Game Over Online 90/100
http://www.game-over.com/content/2017/08/uncharted-the-lost-legacy/#sthash.kfwpSJuZ.52twTgtO.dpbs
Shacknews 8/10
http://www.shacknews.com/article/101014/uncharted-the-lost-legacy-review-road-trip
Atomix 92/100
http://atomix.vg/review-uncharted-the-lost-legacy/
http://www.impulsegamer.com/uncharted-lost-legacy-review/
Attack of the Fanboy 4.5/5
https://aotf.com/reviews/uncharted-the-lost-legacy-review/
Hardcore Gamer 4.5/5
http://www.hardcoregamer.com/2017/08/17/review-uncharted-the-lost-legacy/268331/
Game Over Online 90/100
http://www.game-over.com/content/2017/08/uncharted-the-lost-legacy/#sthash.kfwpSJuZ.52twTgtO.dpbs
Shacknews 8/10
http://www.shacknews.com/article/101014/uncharted-the-lost-legacy-review-road-trip
Atomix 92/100
http://atomix.vg/review-uncharted-the-lost-legacy/
DriftingSpirit
Member
Edit - ^Good stuff.
They may avoid that though given Sony's stance on release dates/delays now.
Kenzodielocke
Banned
Uncharted 4 had a lot of problems behind the scenes and that's why it got delayed so much.
MarioLinkSamus
not a fan of Ashley Madison. Digs her website tho
I apologize for my ignorance, but I'm confused. Is this DLC or a stand alone game? I played through Uncharted 4 and watched the Sony presser yet I still not entirely sure. It's priced at $40, sooo it seems like it's in between a stand alone game and DLC add on. Am I getting 20-30 hours, 10 hours or something different? I feel like they could have marketed this better.