• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Do women see extremely muscular men the same way men see anorexic women?

Status
Not open for further replies.

kitch9

Banned
Most men would agree on the ideal female body type--slim(other than the chest and buttocks). While they like slim, if it gets taken to an extreme with girls that look sickly thin and anorexic, it becomes very unappealing to most men(contrary to what fashion mags want you to believe).

When it comes to women's taste in men, everybody knows they like a big, strong guy. From what I can tell though, these steroid taking guys on bodybuilding magazines are not attractive to most women. Like with women being slim, there seems to be a point where it becomes "too much of a good thing." So two questions naturally surface:

1: Why do these guys go so overboard with the muscles? Yeah it may be a sport for them, but in the end what they really want is to impress ladies, amirite?

2: What is the ideal build for a man? At what point do the muscles become too much? Perhaps it is not as cut and dry as it is with male preference of female bodies.

Just so you know that ripped greasy competition body builder look for most lasts a week at best. Once the competition is over they go back on the carbs and a more normal look quickly comes back.
 

Ultima_5

Member
sylvester-stallone1.jpg

If I had the time, willpower and money to do it, this is what i'd want.

buuuuuuut I don't so I'll just have to work on making good money and being mildly amusing at best
 
Hmm... I doubt it. I mean, I've met muscled nerdy guys and they weren't all that attractive to me. I mean, I guess if they really REALLY had an attractive personality to me I'd go for it (I'm not quite that shallow), but otherwise I'd much prefer a skinny one.

Oddly enough, I feel like my love of muscles came from a lot of the media I enjoyed as a kid. Capcom fighting games, comic books, and Frank Frazetta artwork all feature ridiculously thick muscular dudes and I grew to like that look.

I'd say Capcom is also responsible for my love of huge muscular thighs on women.
 

Trickster

Member
What influence is that exactly? Voluntary steroid and HGH consumption?

Pretty sure he's been the motivation for a lot of people to start working out. Dude started out as a skinny geek and ended up looking like a god, even before he started doing the riods and hgh.
 

Kozak

Banned
indeed. bad influence.

wat lol. I can see you just dislike Zyzz very much.

I'm guessing you lost a friend or two to the gym craze.


What influence is that exactly? Voluntary steroid and HGH usage?

Zyzz never condoned or urged the use of drugs to achieve ones goals. A lot of his fans would deny his drug usage apart from Australia's favourite pill.
 

Ultima_5

Member
Oddly enough, I feel like my love of muscles came from a lot of the media I enjoyed as a kid. Capcom fighting games, comic books, and Frank Frazetta artwork all feature ridiculously thick muscular dudes and I grew to like that look.

I'd say Capcom is also responsible for my love of huge muscular thighs on women.

Same boat. I've always blamed eidos on my love for polygonal/pyramidal breast
 

Esch

Banned
wat lol. I can see you just dislike Zyzz very much.

I'm guessing you lost a friend or two to the gym craze.

I have no problem with people bodybuilding or even using performance enhancing drugs.

I just always thought that Zyzz and his whole crew just look like douchebags is all. there are better fitness idols out there anyway.
 

Bisnic

Really Really Exciting Member!
Women can have pretty different tastes. I prefer skinny, nerdy guys myself. *shrug* All the guys posted in this thread do pretty much nothing for me.

I wish all women prefered skinny, nerdy guys. THEN i would be popular with girls. *sigh*
 
Yes. Pitt looks to be sub 7%, Bale under 8-9%.

Yeah, most body builders when they compete have sub-6-7% body fat. At that point, their skin tissue has like almost no water in it, thus how thing it appears the body, thus showing off the muscles underneath as well as it does. Folks like Pitt & Bale, they're probably at the 8% body fat levels for a brief period of time (or for just several scenes), then goes back up quickly.
 
Man, if I could live at 9% body fat with good muscle mass like Bale I would be the happiest man on earth. Anything lower than that is just for show.
 

Lissar

Reluctant Member
Oddly enough, I feel like my love of muscles came from a lot of the media I enjoyed as a kid. Capcom fighting games, comic books, and Frank Frazetta artwork all feature ridiculously thick muscular dudes and I grew to like that look.

I'd say Capcom is also responsible for my love of huge muscular thighs on women.

Huh, I never thought about what kind of media might have affected my preference.

Only muscled guy I ever swooned for was Dean Cain as Superman.
 

Az

Member
Brad Pitt just has excellent genes. A majority of people would not look like that with that bodyfat percentage.

But I came to the realization that I will never have the perfect body, I like chocolate and alcohol way too much.
 

JCX

Member
Oddly enough, I feel like my love of muscles came from a lot of the media I enjoyed as a kid. Capcom fighting games, comic books, and Frank Frazetta artwork all feature ridiculously thick muscular dudes and I grew to like that look.

I'd say Capcom is also responsible for my love of huge muscular thighs on women.

I think the docmentary Bigger Faster Stronger talks about the media affecting young males' perception on how muscular they should be.

GI Joe is to boys what Barbie is to girls (Pope, Olivardia, Gruber, & Borowiecki, 1999). Over the past 20 years, these G.I. Joe toys have grown more muscular and currently have sharper muscle definition. The GI Joe Extreme action figure, if extrapolated to a height of 5’10”, would have larger biceps than any bodybuilder in history.

source source 2
 
I'd say that's a very realistically achievable body type. I'm working toward something like that. Not that I wouldn't mind being ripped but dropping to the single percent body fat percentages doesn't seem realistic in my case... going 13-14% or so isn't too crazy a thought though.
 

cloudwalking

300chf ain't shit to me
i'm not especially attracted to muscular men. i prefer slim, tall guys, maybe a bit toned, but muscles are a big eh for me.

my husband's tall, slim, but has really nice long legs and strong arms. to me, he's perfect :p
 
I'd say that's a very realistically achievable body type. I'm working toward something like that. Not that I wouldn't mind being ripped but dropping to the single percent body fat percentages doesn't seem realistic in my case... going 13-14% or so isn't too crazy a thought though.

Why is it out of reach man?
 

way more

Member
More importantly, how do these men view themselves. Unique to America more men suffer body image issues, which I can understand when I see ads promising changes like this.

15-weight-loss-photos-before-and-after-men-raw-food-ripped.png


I'll see a guy in the Before pic on TV talking about how he always works out and eats right and I'll think, "damn right, guys like him and me gotta stay healthy." Then he says, "but I was a fucking fat ass until I used the Xross-Fit Survivor TRaining Core Duo." And then I feel like a fucking fat ass.

Is that guy really so gross in the first pic that he needs to change?
 
More importantly, how do these men view themselves. Unique to America more men suffer body image issues, which I can understand when I see ads promising changes like this.

15-weight-loss-photos-before-and-after-men-raw-food-ripped.png


I'll see a guy in the Before pic on TV talking about how he always works out and eats right and I'll think, "damn right, guys like him and me gotta stay healthy." Then he says, "but I was a fucking fat ass until I used the Xross-Fit Survivor TRaining Core Duo." And then I feel like a fucking fat ass.

Is that guy really so gross in the first pic that he needs to change?

This is a super super clear case of the before pic being taken after the after pic. The dude has the same build in both, it's just in completely different states. The "befure" picture is taken after drinking a bunch of liquid and before doing any exercising, and he's purposefully hunched and sticking out his gut. The "after" picture is probably taken immediately after a work out and with good posture.
 
This is a super super clear case of the before pic being taken after the after pic. The dude has the same build in both, it's just in completely different states. The "befure" picture is taken after drinking a bunch of liquid and before doing any exercising, and he's purposefully hunched and sticking out his gut. The "after" picture is probably taken immediately after a work out and with good posture.

Furious Pete did a video on this.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M957dACQyfU
 
More importantly, how do these men view themselves. Unique to America more men suffer body image issues, which I can understand when I see ads promising changes like this.

15-weight-loss-photos-before-and-after-men-raw-food-ripped.png


I'll see a guy in the Before pic on TV talking about how he always works out and eats right and I'll think, "damn right, guys like him and me gotta stay healthy." Then he says, "but I was a fucking fat ass until I used the Xross-Fit Survivor TRaining Core Duo." And then I feel like a fucking fat ass.

Is that guy really so gross in the first pic that he needs to change?

The only difference between the left pic and right pic there is that he took the right pic first, then drank a shit ton of diet coke, messed his hair up and waited a couple of hours.
 

way more

Member
You are telling me even if I had the chiseled abs of a Greek Demi-God I would have to still stand in the correct pose and avoid water bloat? Well fuck aiming that high, I'll just be satisfied with what I got. Or maybe I'll just blast my quads more.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom