-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
American Idol Season 11 |OT| Sponsored By X-Factor USA
- Thread starter Dead Prince
- Start date
- Status
SecretMoblin
Member
I agree. I didn't like anyone up through the Angel of Mine guy. Breath support, people. Support those damn notes.
krypt0nian
Banned
aw i forgot to watch
but i guess i didn't miss anything since all i see in the thread is shade
Ashley Robins was fantastic. Don't always go by jaded GAF.
Ashley and Frat guy were the standouts this episode for me.
Jane Carrey. Her dad is Jim Carrey? I was like lolwut. That was kinda surprising but i knew she did look kind of familiar. Jane also kinda looks like Kelly Clarkson. Her singing was okay.... she definitely has potential though.
Also, about the lack of stupid and bad auditions. They were funny but they were getting old and weren't needed so i'm glad they aren't showing much of those.
Jane Carrey. Her dad is Jim Carrey? I was like lolwut. That was kinda surprising but i knew she did look kind of familiar. Jane also kinda looks like Kelly Clarkson. Her singing was okay.... she definitely has potential though.
Also, about the lack of stupid and bad auditions. They were funny but they were getting old and weren't needed so i'm glad they aren't showing much of those.
My sentiments exactly. Kill the show already.
krypt0nian
Banned
Just don't watch it. I cannot stand when people wish for shows to be canceled.
Apeopleman
Member
I believe in the first episode of the 11th season, Colton Dixon got to re audition.
I remember last year to get into the live show, it was between him, JC Bordeaux, and Bret Loewenstern. I was dissapointed that he didn't make it, especially after Bret performed poorly with Come on baby light my fire.........
I think its great they put him through and I consider him an early favorite. If there's an American Idol gaf pool for whoever wins American Idol, put me in for Colton Dixon
He's a great candidate. Clean cut, nice voice, has experience, and definitely will easily win over the female fanbase, and the southern fanbase being from the south
I remember last year to get into the live show, it was between him, JC Bordeaux, and Bret Loewenstern. I was dissapointed that he didn't make it, especially after Bret performed poorly with Come on baby light my fire.........
I think its great they put him through and I consider him an early favorite. If there's an American Idol gaf pool for whoever wins American Idol, put me in for Colton Dixon
He's a great candidate. Clean cut, nice voice, has experience, and definitely will easily win over the female fanbase, and the southern fanbase being from the south
Well, I watched an episode after not watching one for over 3 years. I merely commented on how I felt after watching an episode after so long. If it makes you feel any better, I don't intend to watch anymore.
This is a message board, right?
krypt0nian
Banned
Sure it is. It's also douchey to want something canceled just because you don't like it.
Ashley Robins was fantastic. Don't always go by jaded GAF.
*re-listens*
Her head voice was pretty. Too few women on this show use head voice in auditions (or men using falsetto, for that matter). I didn't like her belting as much, but I guess it was more because of the comparison to Whitney's (which she inadvertently encouraged by copying her almost inflection-for-inflection) than on its own terms.
So maybe she has potential if she picks songs that are more in her wheelhouse. I somehow doubt she will.
krypt0nian
Banned
Yeah the karaoke thing bugged me but I can hear that she has natural talent and the bad habits are easily corrected. For a lot of the others put through, it was obviously to have a huge number to report and to cull the drek. She did have nice control, and decent use of dynamics IMO.
I definitely don't put you in Jaded GAF. You always know your stuff, Mumei.
Heh. I think of myself as a bit jaded when it comes to these shows and vocals. There's not more than a handful of singers I've really loved on these shows over the years.
AngmarsKing701
Member
Auditions have been decidedly on the positive side. I don't know whether that makes the show good or bad, but I do kind of miss the "OMFG he/she's SOOOO awful" parts.
SecretMoblin
Member
How bad it must feel to be shot down by Ryan Seacrest.
SecretMoblin
Member
Um, this girl.
She's good! And she's awkward and weird and likes Chaka Khan! Finally!
She's good! And she's awkward and weird and likes Chaka Khan! Finally!
AngmarsKing701
Member
rofl @ at the cow.
AngmarsKing701
Member
Avalanche. Fucking hilarious.
AngmarsKing701
Member
Steven Tyler was looking at Magic Cyclops as though he was staring back in time at what could have been his own audition had there been an AI 50 years ago.
Crumpet Trumpet
Banned
It's nice to hope.
Indeed it is. ;_;
Hey, hey. Kelly came from Texas. It could happen again.
Right?
Never again :/
Crumpet Trumpet
Banned
"Texas-sized auditions" *cue shot of overweight hopefuls*
OH.
If only
OH.
Hey, hey. Kelly came from Texas. It could happen again.
Right?
If only
Leona Lewis
Banned
LOL Antonella flashback
That girl had it going onnnn
That girl had it going onnnn
Crumpet Trumpet
Banned
It's got nothing on the Xfactor cattiness tbh!
- Status