That is a ridiculous amount of titles. I need some filter man!
That program was/is supposed to do that:
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=57495778&postcount=364
Currently you can check for average ratings by us (GAF) and see which might be worth checking out with impressions listed. Next thing I'll implement is an overall ratings average list and a "per monthly thread" list, so that it could possible help choosing games to play for each month. I want to include these functions at some point in June.
The final step was to have the program give you customized recommendations based on your ratings, but we'll need more data for that, because otherwise I cant test. For that we need more participants voting on games in the program!
(Definitely check out Reus, Gunpoint, Dust:An Elysian Tail, The Swapper, Fibrillation, Rogue Legacy. And then just squeeze in how much time you got left, most of the free and demo games are rather short)