Personally, I don't think its bad for Clem to be in season 2.
But I am inclined to think that actually playing as Clem is going to cheapen the experience. I definitely won't feel as in control of the character's decisions as I did in season 1. Every decision will feel more like "What would Clem do here..." rather than making a decision for myself.
Part of that is just because, we've all played season 1, and our relationship with Clementine is established and we view her in a certain way. It's hard to transition from that into controlling the character and choosing her dialogue options.
But I am inclined to think that actually playing as Clem is going to cheapen the experience. I definitely won't feel as in control of the character's decisions as I did in season 1. Every decision will feel more like "What would Clem do here..." rather than making a decision for myself.
Part of that is just because, we've all played season 1, and our relationship with Clementine is established and we view her in a certain way. It's hard to transition from that into controlling the character and choosing her dialogue options.