• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Harry Potter [Mafia] |OT| “Yer a werewolf, ‘Arry”

D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Christina Mackenzie said:
How many Death Eaters are left?

1. Poisoner
2. Role blocker
3. Swapper ? (Crab mentions he was swapped but can't confirm with anyone)

Then there's LoC's claim of a 2nd killer.
Click to expand...

? w??ld g??ss 4 l?ft - th?r? ?r? 28 pl?y?rs ?t?g?th?r, sc?m ?s n?rm?lly 20% t? 25%. M?yb? 5 l?ft ?s k?ngk?tty w?s n?t f?ll sc?m. C??ld b? s?m? n??tr?ls l?ft, b?t s??ms ?nl?k?ly.
 
K

Kalor

Member
Blargonaut said:
Please stop ignoring me.
Click to expand...

I've read your argument against Crab and honesty I'm not really feeling it. I meant to comment on it earlier but I've been busy. We can go back to it tomorrow but right now I believe BSP and think we have a clear mafia, which you suggested in your reading of article 4. Surely the real Rita would counterclaim if she was lying.
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Kalor said:
I've read your argument against Crab and honesty I'm not really feeling it. I meant to comment on it earlier but I've been busy. We can go back to it tomorrow but right now I believe BSP and think we have a clear mafia, which you suggested in your reading of article 4. Surely the real Rita would counterclaim if she was lying.
Click to expand...

Sh? ?s th? r??l R?t?, sh?s j?st n/t t?wn-?l?gn?d. Pl??s? d?n't f?ll ?nt? th?s tr?p. Th?r? ?s n? w?y t?wn h?v? th?s m?ny ?nv?st?g?t??n r?l?s.
 
B

Bananaspaceprincess

Neo Member
Christina Mackenzie said:
I see you've yet to mention your alignment.
Click to expand...

Sorry, I thought my alignment is obvious. My win condition is depending on snooping and writing interaction. I can write what I want in the articles but I chose to at least hint what I found out at night.
I doubt that now that I am outed that I will be able to perform some more action. I guess I will either be blocked or else tonight. Obviously I tried to avoid big attention in this game for that reason.

Since I am standing behind my word I will cast my vote on the one I am 100% sure of being scum. (Crab is maybe 90% or so ^^)

Vote: flatearthpandas
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Pl??s?, ? b?g ?ny?n? w?th l?t?r?lly ?ny tr?st ?n m? t? v?t? BSP. I ?m c?rt??n ?n my b?n?s th?s ?s r?ght.

SH? N?V?R ?V?N V?T?D P?ND? B?F?R?!!!!!!!!!!!
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
Bananaspaceprincess said:
Sorry, I thought my alignment is obvious. My win condition is depending on snooping and writing interaction. I can write what I want in the articles but I chose to at least hint what I found out at night.
I doubt that now that I am outed that I will be able to perform some more action. I guess I will either be blocked or else tonight. Obviously I tried to avoid big attention in this game for that reason.

Since I am standing behind my word I will cast my vote on the one I am 100% sure of being scum. (Crab is maybe 90% or so ^^)

Vote: flatearthpandas
Click to expand...

That interaction being? Having snooped on every remaining player in game or what?
 
T

TheExodu5

Banned
Something doesn't quite add up.

BSP is a neutral but is also a town investigator? And she can write anything in her articles but they're incredibly cryptic? Why not just spell it out?
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
As far as neutrals playing with town, I have doubts concerning how much we can depend on Gorlak. His role block can't really be used to further his own win condition and a town victory. Any person he punishes he has an inherent incentive to keep alive. We want him to ideally be punishing scum. So a pretty direct conflict of interest. Something to keep in mind as we move into the later phase of game.
 
K

Kalor

Member
Crab said:
Sh? ?s th? r??l R?t?, sh?s j?st n/t t?wn-?l?gn?d. Pl??s? d?n't f?ll ?nt? th?s tr?p. Th?r? ?s n? w?y t?wn h?v? th?s m?ny ?nv?st?g?t??n r?l?s.
Click to expand...

How many do we have at this point anyway?

Blagonaut
Christina
Crab
Kawl
BSP

Two of which are likely for horcrux hunting so three true investigators doesn't seem that much. Especially because of an element of one of them.
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Kalor said:
How many do we have at this point anyway?

Blagonaut
Christina
Crab
Kawl
BSP

Two of which are likely for horcrux hunting so three true investigators doesn't seem that much. Especially because of an element of one of them.
Click to expand...

S?wn??ks r?l? r?v??l?d sc?m b?c??s? h?r ?ct??n f??l?d ?n sc?m. B?rb?t?ng c??ld r??d sc?m f?r?m. Y?? f?rg?t Ryn?m.

Pl??s? tr?st m? ?n th?s.
 
M

Matt Attack

Member
VOTE:bananaspaceprincess

It's been said but it's still true, it would be really weird if there was another investigator. If she's telling the truth, then I'm sorry if you get lynched but at least we can trust you about pandas and get him tomorrow.

TheExodu5 said:
Something doesn't quite add up.

BSP is a neutral but is also a town investigator? And she can write anything in her articles but they're incredibly cryptic? Why not just spell it out?
Click to expand...

Also a good point. Honestly the role as presented to us sounds really odd.

Blargonaut said:
Oh, and another thing; Matt Attack has been a complete non-entity this entire game and it's irritating me. His posts are basically the bare minimum it requires to acknowledge that he's still playing.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I've done badly, even by my standards. I'm really sorry to both you guys and ninpot, I know that I haven't done the game justice.
 
L

Lone_Prodigy

Member
Actually I'd rather hit scum and even though I went after Possum who wasn't around to defend himself I feel a little better about this one.

Vote: flatearthpandas
 
T

TheExodu5

Banned
I'm currently listening to the book 4 audiobook, so Rita's character is pretty fresh in my mind. Rita writes slander and innocent people get hurt for it. I'm really, really skeptical that she's a legitimate town investigator.
 
T

TheExodu5

Banned
Sorry, BSP, I don't buy the town helpful neutral, especially from Rita's character. I think something more nefarious is at play here.

Vote: bananaspaceprincess
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
4 BSP (m?, C_M, k?wl, M?tt_?tt?ck)
4 F?P (K?l?r, M?gn?m, BSP, L_P)

F?P ?sn't ?v?n h?r? t? d?f?nd h?ms?lf, ?t's pr?tty l?w p?ck?ng ?n s?m??n? ?n ? d?ff?r?nt t?m?z?n?.
 
B

Blargonaut

Banned
This is the height of incompetence. Your collective random shitvote-flinging in the face of a presented case with multiple points of incriminating evidence is astounding.

Fuck this. I'm tired, haven't finished writing these Article write-ups and probably never will, I've made my case against Crab and there'll probably be one or two more major posts in me, maybe the Overworld post at least, before the Day ends. There's no hope left in this school.
 
T

TheExodu5

Banned
Here's the summary from the HP Wiki about Rita:

Rita Skeeter (b. 1951[1]) was a witch journalist who specialised in writing poison-pen stories which tended to be based on false information and misreported interviews while she worked for the Daily Prophet, as well authoring a few tell-all biographies. Albus Dumbledore described her writing as "enchantingly nasty" after she wrote an unfavourable article about him.

Notable stories Rita covered include the trials of various Death Eaters after the First Wizarding War, the Triwizard Tournament, and, albeit reluctantly, Harry Potter's account of Lord Voldemort's return to power in 1995 for The Quibbler. She also wrote biographies of Armando Dippet, Albus Dumbledore, Severus Snape, and Harry Potter. Rita's writing tended to be sensationalist, and sometimes outright dishonest. Her ability to acquire information was assisted by her status as an unregistered beetle Animagus.
Click to expand...
 
B

Bananaspaceprincess

Neo Member
TheExodu5 said:
Sorry, BSP, I don't buy the town helpful neutral, especially from Rita's character. I think something more nefarious is at play here.

Vote: bananaspaceprincess
Click to expand...

My role is neutral. My articles are also mostly fluff. But as I said, the moment I hit scum I made sure I hinted it the most obvious way.

I am telling you. Pandas is Scum! If he isn't you can do what you want with me tmr. But please don't let him get away so easy.
 
F

flatearthpandas

Member
Bananaspaceprincess said:
Because I am smart enough not to snoop on the most obvious targets. I need the snoop to go through in order to write the article so I chose players that seemed a little off the hook. (And I took names that I felt could be turned into something ;))
Click to expand...

Bananaspaceprincess said:
Ok fineyyyy.

I snoop. I write. If I write a certain amount of times I leave the game as a winner.
Click to expand...

Bananaspaceprincess said:
OMG I am already naked
yes it's 6, same number as worthy
Click to expand...
It is 340am. Ugh.

I find it strange that Miracle joined the game 2 but got "investigated" night 1. Personally.

I also find it strange that you aren't required to post your results, only to write. Supposedly you have to succesfully snoop, but you can write anything? Sounds too easy. I believe you are Skeeter, I don't believe your win condition. I know you didn't investigate me yesterday. Whether you flip neutral or scum, you are actively hurting the town right now.

Vote: Bananaspaceprincess
 
G

Gorlak

Banned
Looks like we are in for a wild ride? :)

Bananaspaceprincess, do you belong to the MoM?

If nobody believes there is a scum switcher I'll go block Crab tonight, if the majority wants that to happen.
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
Blargonaut said:
This is the height of incompetence. Your collective random shitvote-flinging in the face of a presented case with multiple points of incriminating evidence is astounding.

Fuck this. I'm tired, haven't finished writing these Article write-ups and probably never will, I've made my case against Crab and there'll probably be one or two more major posts in me, maybe the Overworld post at least, before the Day ends. There's no hope left in this school.
Click to expand...

Just because you have made a case doesn't mean that everyone has to find it legitimate and moving. I'm sorry. I read your posts, I considered the points you made, and I wasn't convinced. That's all there is to it.
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Bananaspaceprincess said:
My role is neutral. My articles are also mostly fluff. But as I said, the moment I hit scum I made sure I hinted it the most obvious way.

I am telling you. Pandas is Scum! If he isn't you can do what you want with me tmr. But please don't let him get away so easy.
Click to expand...

Y?? w??t?d t? ??t t? ? t?m? wh?n F?P w?s n?t h?r? ?nd c??ld n?t d?f?nd h?ms?lf. ? g?v? y?? th? ch?nc? t? cl??m ?rl??r. Y?? d?d n?t; b?c??s? y?? ?r? ly?ng.
 
B

Blargonaut

Banned
Hey guys, remember back when I said I was surrounded by incompetence? That was fun.

Well, it turns out that I posted that before reading anything of what BSP has said lately.

It's good that there's a choice between flatearthpandas (apparently, if you all choose to trust BSP) and Crab, but honestly, you all need to fuck Crab up as a priority. He's shown that he can run mad mental interference and shove us all away from the KNOWN FACT SINCE D3 that scum knew who Umbridge was before his Role-claim was deployed.

Don't allow him to poison the Daily conversation any longer, and avenge Swamped.
 
C

Christina Mackenzie

Member
flatearthpandas said:
It is 340am. Ugh.

I find it strange that Miracle joined the game 2 but got "investigated" night 1. Personally.

I also find it strange that you aren't required to post your results, only to write. Supposedly you have to succesfully snoop, but you can write anything? Sounds too easy. I believe you are Skeeter, I don't believe your win condition. I know you didn't investigate me yesterday. Whether you flip neutral or scum, you are actively hurting the town right now.

Vote: Bananaspaceprincess
Click to expand...

2:40 AM, I know that feeling.
 
N

nin1000

Banned
Day 5 votes

lone_prodigy (1)
theexodu5 3041 (3392)
christina mackenzie 3063 (3343)
blargonaut 3172 (3185)
blargonaut 3185 (3197)
theawesomepossum 3189 (3198)
flame_ac 3204
gorlak 3216 (3332)
bananaspaceprincess 3218 (3356)
lord of castamere 3222 (3280)
gorlak 3358 (3517)

blargonaut (0)
kawl_usc 3086 (3512)
crab 3304 (3545)
gorlak 3332 (3358)

do we actually have to vote for players, or am i being slightly too inventive? (0)
crab 3099 (3275)

theawesomepossum (0)
blargonaut 3143 (3166)
lone_prodigy 3165 (3199)

lord of castamere (0)
blargonaut 3197 (3208)
blargonaut 3208 (3353)
roytheone 3217 (3555)
kalor 3243 (3470)
magnumboy20xx 3464 (3650)

flame_ac (1)
crab 3275 (3304)
theawesomepossum 3322

enker (0)
lord of castamere 3280 (3459)

flatearthpandas (4)
blargonaut 3353 (3529)
lone_prodigy 3460 (3461)
lone_prodigy 3625 (3637)
kalor 3641
magnumboy20xx 3650
bananaspaceprincess 3654
lone_prodigy 3668

gorlak (0)
flatearthpandas 3458 (3687)
crab 3566 (3593)
theexodu5 3573 (3672)

magnumboy20xx (1)
lord of castamere 3459
kalor 3470 (3602)

roythescum (1)
gorlak 3517

crab (2)
blargonaut 3529 (3529)
blargonaut 3529 (3529)
blargonaut 3529 (3529)
blargonaut 3529 (3529)
blargonaut 3529 (3529)
blargonaut 3529
bananaspaceprincess 3541 (3654)
roytheone 3555
theexodu5 3559 (3573)

bananaspaceprincess (6)
crab 3545 (3566)
crab 3593
kalor 3602 (3641)
christina mackenzie 3603
kawl_usc 3607
lone_prodigy 3637 (3668)
matt attack 3663
theexodu5 3672
flatearthpandas 3687
 
G

Gorlak

Banned
Hey Kawl buddy, who should I block tonight? You're the most trustworthy around here, do you want me to go for somebody specific or do you trust in my ability to choose on my own?
 
B

Bananaspaceprincess

Neo Member
flatearthpandas said:
It is 340am. Ugh.

I find it strange that Miracle joined the game 2 but got "investigated" night 1. Personally.

I also find it strange that you aren't required to post your results, only to write. Supposedly you have to succesfully snoop, but you can write anything? Sounds too easy. I believe you are Skeeter, I don't believe your win condition. I know you didn't investigate me yesterday. Whether you flip neutral or scum, you are actively hurting the town right now.

Vote: Bananaspaceprincess
Click to expand...

I investigated Zippedpinhead because he did that silly "I am so ordinary it's so boring" thing on D1. But I forgive you for not knowing that. Because you were a replacement yourself as was Miracle. ;)
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
I would go for an average activity poster. I'm trying to think of a target that could fit your goals and town goals but like I posted up above its a little hard to do that. I personally think role blocks lose useful ness when revealed publicly. If you happen to hit scum then that person will be sure not to send in the kill if you say it publicly before hand.
 
G

Gorlak

Banned
Kawl_USC said:
I would go for an average activity poster. I'm trying to think of a target that could fit your goals and town goals but like I posted up above its a little hard to do that. I personally think role blocks lose useful ness when revealed publicly. If you happen to hit scum then that person will be sure not to send in the kill if you say it publicly before hand.
Click to expand...

Nah, I'll survive till the end and win, don't worry. It's more important to prove my intention to help town right now. I'll see what I can do. The claimed town roles will not be touched by me. Maybe I'll block Crab? Or will I not? Only time will tell.

Oh yeah a vote:

vote: flatearthpandas
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Why d? w? ?nly h?v? 15 ?ct/v? v?t?s. Wh?ch 2 ?r? m?ss?ng.
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
Gorlak said:
Nah, I'll survive till the end and win, don't worry. It's more important to prove my intention to help town right now. I'll see what I can do. The claimed town roles will not be touched by me. Maybe I'll block Crab? Or will I not? Only time will tell.

Oh yeah a vote:

vote: flatearthpandas
Click to expand...

Flame AC
Matt Attack
FEP if they aren't lynched

I think any of those in addition to crab seem like viable options. (Can't remember who you have already punished thus far)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Games Done Quick, isn't accepting speedruns of ANY Harry Potter game currently without explanation.
2 3
135
16K
Goalus replied
Harry Potter: Quidditch Champions announced
News
30
3K
HotSauceEnema replied
Hogwarts Legacy is the biggest Harry Potter game launch of all time | UK Boxed Charts
2 3 4 5
225
16K
cornonthecrobb replied
Latest No Man’s Sky update adds ship customisation, new Guild system, space station overhaul, and more
Trailer Hype
37
2K
Guilty_AI replied
Hogwarts Legacy | Review Thread
News Review Hype 40 41 42 43 44
2K
188K
Jayjayhd34 replied
Top Bottom