• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Mr. Grey will see you now...

Status
Not open for further replies.
... for a rousing game of Magic The Gathering

Has this ever happened in fiction before? You have this smart, rich and well dressed male character who appears to be a total dreamboat. Maybe he's a wall street banker or something equally as high profile or white collar. A female character falls absolutely in love with him or the other way around where the male character seduces her instead. After the initial meet up however it turns out the rich upper class male has some esoteric hobbies which in this case is Magic The Gathering.

The female character could be repulsed by this or intrigued or even confused as to why such a man would indulge himself with such "nerdy" or "geeky" stuff. Or lets be fair and say the woman is not a complete air-head and makes an attempt to appreciate the hobby since her love interest loves it so much. Or even the woman is indeed repulsed and leaves the man who goes onto date another woman (this one perhaps more homely in appearance but likes to play MTG or similar card games too). The first woman then feels stupid and foolish for having left the otherwise "perfect" man for something so petty.

Any examples? Have such "geeky" hobbies ever been portrayed in a positive or even neutral light? Or is stuff like PnP RPG's, card games (on motorcycles?) and anime/manga the realm of bottom feeders as far as Hollywood is concerned?
Mind you the Wall Street banker may not tell everyone of his hobby, just family and close friends who wouldn't look down upon him for it. Or forget MTG, maybe he plays video games.

aB31A3D_460s.jpg

What about musical tastes? Maybe he listens to grunge metal or k-pop or something equally "unconventional"?
 

dan2026

Member
Its like the bizarre stigma comic books still get.

Even when 95% of them are aimed at young adults or older.
 

Watch Da Birdie

I buy cakes for myself on my birthday it's not weird lots of people do it I bet
Yeah, I always worry about being open with my nerdier hobbies when I put myself out on dating sites. It's pretty much a disaster to openly admit you enjoy the "A-Word".

Anime
 
Its like the bizarre stigma comic books still get.

Even when 95% of them are aimed at young adults or older.

Especially in the last 5 years when they have pretty much conquered the box office.
I mean forget superheroes, stuff like Road To Perdition was originally a comic book series

Yeah, I always worry about being open with my nerdier hobbies when I put myself out on dating sites. It's pretty much a disaster to openly admit you enjoy the "A-Word".

Anime

Would a woman who looks down upon you for liking anime be worth the effort? But then, Anime or SPORTS! shouldn't be the first thing they notice
Thankfully in India many are somewhat ignorant of such things, so you end up with blank slates who may even turn out to be total otaku's
 

ryseing

Member
Didn't this happen to some girl who wrote for Gawker? She went on a date with this successful guy and found out he was a MTG champion.

Didn't know you were looking for fictional examples. My bad. Point still stands.
 

Disgusting. The woman should be ashamed.

You know what, this is the perfect litmus test for a potential spouse. Have a "nerdy" hobby, if that causes them to break off the relationship then you just saved yourself from divorce fees in the future


Excellent example. He's equally vicious and smart in the virtual and the real world.
Judging by the second video, he uses his hobby as an icebreaker and as a way to say, "Hey! I'm just a regular dude like you"
 

Zoe

Member
Ben? Ben is a nerd lol.

I didn't start watching until a while after he and Chris were introduced, but were they always up front about him being a nerd? It seemed like he was any other government type until Leslie became interested in him.
 

Watch Da Birdie

I buy cakes for myself on my birthday it's not weird lots of people do it I bet
kUoL76z.jpg


Great jobs, attractive and intelligent girlfriends who ultimately put up with their hobbies and social idiosyncrasies, and decent apartments.

Why can't I have that life?
 

Weiss

Banned
I wanted to look up that comic that had them entering a room filled with My Little Pony stuff, but I'm afraid to google "50 Shades of Grey My Little Pony."
 

Opiate

Member
Especially in the last 5 years when they have pretty much conquered the box office.
I mean forget superheroes, stuff like Road To Perdition was originally a comic book series

From the outside looking in, it looks like comic books did it to themselves. Their fanbase is viewed as hostile to change and particularly uninviting.
 

Brakke

Banned
Not exactly the same but I like that Frank Underwood in House of Cards plays video games and also paints lil war miniatures and makes lil hobby trees and scenes. Everyone rolls eyes at him but he will fucking murder them so whatever.
 
From the outside looking in, it looks like comic books did it to themselves. Their fanbase is viewed as hostile to change and particularly uninviting.

Point taken and unfortunately true. In recent month's the gaming community has also looked particularly hostile
With comic books though I always imagined the fans making fun of the writers for treating them like little kids as opposed to being grossly resistant to change.
That is to say CB fans would love better storytelling but the writers keep trotting out the old tropes.

We should also promote the non-superhero properties. Even stuff like Uber I find more interesting.
 

UrbanRats

Member
From the outside looking in, it looks like comic books did it to themselves. Their fanbase is viewed as hostile to change and particularly uninviting.

What is so hostile about the non-superhero comicbook scene? Especially on a world-wide perspective?
 

BennyBlanco

aka IMurRIVAL69
Brennan Williams has full body pillows, and a pokemon gold cart attached to his chain. His twitter is basically all over the top weeb stuff. Guy is a legend.

How+do+you+feel_8d8a20_4952995.png
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom