• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Red Dead Redemption 2 (Fall 2017, PS4/XB1, Trailer 10/20 @ 11 AM EST) announced

What will ultimately anger people the most about this game?


Results are only viewable after voting.
Their "masculine" stories are awful and reuse the same satire that was last fresh or edgy in the 1990's. God forbid their fans encourage them to try something different in the hopes of some improvement.

GTA V sales say otherwise, people want their Rockstar out of Rockstar game.
 

kraspkibble

Permabanned.
I'm amazed if delaying PC port until all other possible versions of the GTAV were done wasn't intentional tactic from marketing and sales point of view. Last-gen original, current-gen remaster and PC remaster of remaster. Get them X amount dippers and PC crowd at the end. It made them insane bank so them trying to repeat it here, assuming PC port will ever come, didn't come as surprise.

well it worked on me. i bought GTA V on PS3 then they announced it for PS4 so i bought it again. i ended up building a PC so bought it again.

i'll be getting RDR2 on PS4 and again on PC. i'm not proud of it but i ain't waiting for them to release PC version until i play this. i'll be there day 1.
 
or they focus on PS4/XB1. then work on PS4 Pro/Scorpio/PC versions after release..

no wait that's just crazy nonsense apparently. but..that's just what they did with GTA V. focused on PS3/360 then did PS4/XB1/PC.

Right, but those were separate platforms, not the same with these new hardware iterations. Plus GTAV came out before the PS4 and XB1 existed, or even publicly mentioned.

Sony (rightly) have a mandate for full day and date support of their new machine. And you can bet Microsoft will too with the Scorpio.
 

SgtCobra

Member
Yhis is definitely going to be a 2018 game.

That should pretty much settle it imo. I would have nothing against a female main protagonist but it's their game. Let them make it how they want it.
Exactly.

But hey, I'm pretty sure almost all threads about this game are going to contain this discussion as they feel Rockstar should include a female lead character because it's the right thing to do.
 

ponpo

( ≖‿≖)
Maybe there aren't 7 protagonists, you can just create a character and those are some of the customization choice end results.

ScReEnShOt tHiS
 
Their "masculine" stories are awful and reuse the same satire that was last fresh or edgy in the 1990's. God forbid their fans encourage them to try something different in the hopes of some improvement.

Saying you would like to see them do something new is of course fine. I actually agree with that.

Implying they're not doing the 'right' thing by including characters of a certain gender/race is what I have issue with.
 
I honestly don't give a shit about whether or not the lead character of a western game is not white or female or whatever

But it would be nice to have a major subplot involving a minority and/or female in the story mode. Particularly Mexicans and Native Americans since we're dealing with the wild west
 

Gator86

Member
This racial/feminist thing needs to get out of this thread honestly. I don't why you care, it's just a videogame.. enjoy it for what it is.

Fuck off telling people what to care about. Your comment is some "stick to sports!" level commentary which is usually little more than "I don't agree with the premise of your argument and I find it threatening to my beliefs in some way." If people want to talk about concerns that a game might not features characters with backgrounds they find interesting, they're well within their rights to do so.
 

icespide

Banned
Rockstar are the only devs I give this pass too, and I give it happily.

I will, however, be buying it for Pro or Scorpio pending whichever has the 60fps version and some bells and whistles - then play it in 4K/60fps (my rig hardware will be super good by then no doubt) after the ~1-2 year wait for the PC version :)
really doubt either version will be 60fps
 
Man I hope they include the wilhelm scream like in the last game. Also, hope the euphoria engine is still prominent. Shooting guys off horses looked so damn good.
 

Alucrid

Banned
honestly if they had a female in there. it would ruin it for me, it wouldn't be realistic at all, just a very unlikely scenario.

definitely. in order to be fully immersed in my video games i need them to replicate real life and have zero female interaction
 
Considering how CPU-dependent open world games are it's a pretty sure bet that neither the Pro or the Scorpio will run this above 30fps, even less so considering the mantra for both of these things is 4K gaming.

scorpio is getting zen dude.
 
They need to make them the villains this time around if Marston is back in this and apart of Dutch's Gang

New pro tag or something but don't try this whole morally grey Marston when he's supposed to be at his worse here

Basically...new protagonists pls

There's zero indication you'll be playing as Marston again.
 

haveheart

Banned
RDR2==RDR3=/=RDR2=/=RDR

We should call it RDRed and RDRev.

Great announcement anyway. I'm excited to see if they could achieve a big graphical leap from GTAV.
 

Ascenion

Member
What are you not understanding about the title? It's a sequel to redemption, red dead redemption 2. That doesn't imply it's the second game of the entire red dead franchise at all.

Does the name GTA 4 imply that vice city and San Andreas don't exist?

Yeah so in that case this isn't Red Dead 3, it's literally just Redemption 2. I guess considering how Red Dead works they couldn't use Red Dead R______ if it actually isn't 3.
 
Such a great image now that the characters' faces are visible

Marston is the only one looking away, as if he's almost had it with this way of life
 

UrbanRats

Member
All-male cast with 6 out of 7 being white dudes :/

what the fuck Rockstar
That is actually surprising (and disappointing).
People shit on R* because GTA has crass humor, but RDR had genuinely interesting and well written female characters, for a videogame.
And it seems like it would've been easy to avoid crossfire by inclusing even one female character (this is assuming there will be multiple characters, ofc).

Given the lack of PC version though, i have to infer that R* simply does not give a fuck about people's opinions, and they have the money to afford it, too.
 

jennetics

Member
something something I want to play as a black man in the wild west something something.

Actually, that would be kinda cool. Oh well, we'll see what happens when the game releases.

I've never played the original...Rockstar, do me a favor and remaster RDR while you're at it :)
 

twobear

sputum-flecked apoplexy
So RDR3 is RDR2? That's not confusing.

Kind of lame, but I guess they chose the name for brand recognition.

it's the second redemption game

it would be a bit like calling resident evil revelations 2 "resident evil revelations 22"
 

Kintaro

Worships the porcelain goddess
I guess I shouldn't be surprised at no PC version. RDR didn't make it either. That said, my situation has changed since that games release so that pretty much makes this game a rental or a complete skip by the time it comes out.

Hoping for a pretty trailer though!
 
I should REALLY play the first one on Xbox 360 already. I've had it for at least 3 or 4 years and played it once for an hour but never touched it again.
 

Papacheeks

Banned
That's total bullshit and such a typical response.



A person's gender is irrespective to a well written narrative and Rockstar has some of the best writers in the gaming industry. Gender can provide context, but it isn't dependent on a story. Nothing need change in Redemption if you played as Abigail instead of John.

But they didn't write the game about Abigail. It was John's story. Same will be for whoever is the main protagonist in Red Dead 2.

Also understand that these games are time period and will reflect the majority of male outlaws to smaller female ration during that time.

We probably will meet some women outlaws possibly a band of them. But these games were written about Marston's and possibly their siblings female/ or male.

If your seriously outraged then dont support the game.
 

bombshell

Member
or they focus on PS4/XB1. then work on PS4 Pro/Scorpio/PC versions after release..

no wait that's just crazy nonsense apparently. but..that's just what they did with GTA V. focused on PS3/360 then did PS4/XB1/PC.

PS4 and XBO were not released at that time.

It's a completely different situation when PS4 Pro definitely and Scorpio possibly is already released when the game is released. The support will be day 1.
 

Audioboxer

Member
Yaaaaaas! First game is a masterpiece.

Also for some complaints in here with the budgets that go into Rockstars games for better or worse they aim for target demographics to sell gangbusters. No one comes close to the level of detail and effort Rockstar put into their open world games. Understandably as nearly no one else can afford these ridiculous budgets.

I wish it didn't cost as much as it does but sadly it's where we are with video games. I'm a little more surprised at the white balance if it's how it seems. Males though? Not surprised at all. I bet the demographics for GTA and even RDR are heavily skewed towards males.
 

Cornbread78

Member
Rockstar doesn't give a flying fuck about what anyone thinks.

I know, but this..

Man, I think this is record time for the amount of hate a game is getting.


It's insane; it used to be pages of "hell yeah" "TY" "Sweet, we're getting the game!"

Now it's "WTF, where's the diversity", "where's the PC version" "where the woman at"

Now, the lack of a PC version I can understand as being disappointing, but the rest? We haven't even seen a trailer or a game clip yet!

tumblr_n50rnleVkt1smvngpo1_400.gif


I need to learn to internet rage more...
 

kraspkibble

Permabanned.
I guess I shouldn't be surprised at no PC version. RDR didn't make it either. That said, my situation has changed since that games release so that pretty much makes this game a rental or a complete skip by the time it comes out.

Hoping for a pretty trailer though!

i would be seriously surprised if this doesn't get a PC version. they just won't announce it right now. they didn't announce the PC version of GTA V until about 9 months after it came out on PS3/360.
 

Trigker

Member
honestly if they had a female in there. it would ruin it for me, it wouldn't be realistic at all, just a very unlikely scenario.

I don't think it would be ruined, i'd enjoy the game with any type of race like a normal human being...but if the first thing you do when they announce an anticipated game is to yell at the screen for the characters races, then i guess you have a much bigger problem to resolve.


Anyway, let's wait for the trailer :)
 
Top Bottom