• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Manga is way more diverse and varied than I had imagined

Status
Not open for further replies.
The gods lie. It's a single volume, but it's oh so fantastic.
51yfHXyVsFL._SX365_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg

Also
Livingstone
a95a77012a647f8a80978578dccc9d9d.jpg
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
We'll need to make a new thread to recommend you anime titles.

No need, I got this.

Cowboy Bebop
Gurren Lagann
Princess Mononoke
Naruto
Samurai Champloo
Death Note

Am I missing any? No? Okay we can go back to manga.
 
Having read both this and Flowers of Evil last week for the first time ever, I think I'm done with this genre/style of manga for the foreseeable future.

The constant sense of dread/gloom and impending fuckery made reading these manga much more difficult than I anticipated. The catharsis they provided during their respective finales simply wasn't enough for me; I don't think I can ever re-read them from start to finish, lol

Gonna require some "palate cleansers" following those two, probably Horiyama or something.
If you ever get the desire to go back to that style, do check out Oshimi's Inside Mari. It's very, very good.
 

massoluk

Banned
As with many kids around this part of the globe, I was educated more by Doraemon than my primary school.

Doraemon is still a required reading for the child in my extended family.

:p
 

Necrovex

Member
Go read some Urasawa. Monster, 20th Century Boys, Pluto. I'm sure you'll like it.

No Billy Bat recommendation? I've read the following above, and Duckroll knows quality manga. All completed too.

Also I cannot recommend Oyasumi PunPun enough. It started to get English releases. Reminds me Mumei was supposed to have read this series.
 

Kurita

Member
Oh, Space Brothers is also a must read (the anime is worth checking out just for the music)
One of the most inspiring works of fiction out there. It'll make you laugh, cry, smile, think.
I'm not sure it's available outside of Japan, France and Italy tho...
 
Oh, Space Brothers is also a must read (the anime is worth checking out just for the music)

One of the most inspiring works of fiction out there. It'll make you laugh, cry, smile, think.
I'm not sure it's available outside of Japan, France and Italy tho...

Not sure about volume format, but I think you can read the whole thing on crunchyroll if you have a subscription
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Do they have a lower life expectancy? Rumiko Takahashi is still trucking along, although her artstyle isn't very laborious.

I think it's counterbalanced by generally higher Japanese life expectancy.

A notable recent case of, not exactly "overwork" but the manga artist's work ethic is Tadashi Kawashima who finished his manga while on his deathbed due to advanced liver cancer.
 
October, that's when I got into Parasyte

I had read Enigma sometime earlier, got to thanks GAF for that one

What do you use to read? A tablet or an e-reader? I'd like to get into reading manga again (sold all of mine long ago), but don't want to take up space. Also, do you use a manga reading app? (I think Viz has one)
 

orochi91

Member
If you ever get the desire to go back to that style, do check out Oshimi's Inside Mari. It's very, very good.

Does the story have a definitive conclusion? Or is it one of those "open" type of endings where things are left to interpretations?

The premise seems pretty unique.


Jeeeez

That's a lousy schedule, but I can only assume those authors/artists are passionate enough about their work to persevere though all that.
 

Trojita

Rapid Response Threadmaker
October, that's when I got into Parasyte

I had read Enigma sometime earlier, got to thanks GAF for that one

Did anyone ask you what genre's you usually like? Some of them are noticeable in the OP, but it would be good to get a baseline into what you usually like to then give recommendations.

Manga is diverse enough that one really popular manga is about Ball Room Dancing (Ballroom e Youkoso) and another popular award winning manga is about of dungeon crawlers that have to learn how to cook monsters in a dungeon so they can survive (Dungeon Meshi)

Code:
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/tjiB5aF.jpg[/IMG]

Code:
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/SC6p7f4.jpg[/IMG]
 
Yep. There's a reason the longer running series almost never finish. They get burnt out. Hell, Oda is all but being mandated to take weekly breaks now and again by his editors so he doesn't get seriously sick.

Togashi DID get seriously sick.
Yeah, definitely can't get too attached to the idea of series ever finishing. Becoming a fan of Beet the Vandel Buster as a teen as one of my earlier manga experiences, right around when it originally went on hiatus, was a mistake. :(
 

arigato

Member
For all the long-time enthusiasts of anime and manga. Here's two recommendations which I am sure some of you haven't seen or read yet. Earth Maiden Arjuna (anime), and Alice in Borderland (manga). Both of these are hidden gems.
 

Skittles

Member
I'd say to stay away from Knights of Sidonia (i say this as a huge nihei fan). It completely goes against what the author has done before it. The author pretty much sold out and included a bunch of generic, unnecessary, and distracting anime tropes just so he could sell more copies. Which is a shame because the premise and some of the ideas in it are amazing.

+1 to duckroll's 20th century boys recommendation. That manga is in my top 10.

I'm gonna go ahead and plug the manga version of Trigun. It's almost completely different than the anime and the anime only covered 3 volumes of the manga (out of 18). Has some of my favorite moments in manga.
 
Yeah, definitely can't get too attached to the idea of series ever finishing. Becoming a fan of Beet the Vandel Buster as a teen as one of my earlier manga experiences, right around when it originally went on hiatus, was a mistake. :(

Beet is actually one of those, like Arslan, that splits the duties Western style. Beet was written by Riku Sanjo and drawn by Koji Inada. While Inada has been sick, Sanjo has continued to work, notably on Digimon Xros Wars, Kamen Rider W, Kamen Rider Fourze, Kyoryuger, and Kamen Rider Drive. All of which are damned good.
 

duckroll

Member
Beet is actually one of those, like FMA, that splits the duties Western style. Beet was written by Riku Sanjo and drawn by Koji Inada. While Inada has been sick, Sanjo has continued to work, notably on Digimon Xros Wars, Kamen Rider W, Kamen Rider Fourze, Kyoryuger, and Kamen Rider Drive. All of which are damned good.

FMA isn't split though. The writer is the artist. Are you thinking of her other more recent work Aslan which is based on an older novel and she's only drawing it? Death Note would be a popular series which splits between writer and artist.
 
I'd say to stay away from Knights of Sidonia (i say this as a huge nihei fan). It completely goes against what the author has done before it. The author pretty much sold out and included a bunch of generic, unnecessary, and distracting anime tropes just so he could sell more copies. Which is a shame because the premise and some of the ideas in it are amazing.
I was under the impression that Knights was a more hard sci-fi mech combat/space adventure with some eldritch horror elements

And to be fair, anime/manga tropes don't mean much to me since I have no frame of reference for them. It's all new to me
 

Litan

Member
I was under the impression that Knights was a more hard sci-fi mech combat/space adventure with some eldritch horror elements

And to be fair, anime/manga tropes mean nothing to me since I have no frame of reference for them. It's all new to me
You'll learn to hate them soon enough.
 

Ray Down

Banned
Yep. There's a reason the longer running series almost never finish. They get burnt out. Hell, Oda is all but being mandated to take weekly breaks now and again by his editors so he doesn't get seriously sick.

Togashi DID get seriously sick.

Oda also has meetings at toei for the anime and smokes a lot with 3 hour sleep most of his days now
 

Trojita

Rapid Response Threadmaker
I was under the impression that Knights was a more hard sci-fi mech combat/space adventure with some eldritch horror elements

And to be fair, anime/manga tropes don't mean much to me since I have no frame of reference for them. It's all new to me
We may have found someone unsullied by NTR.
 

1upsuper

Member
Always kinda surprising to me how many people assume manga is this monolithic
moe
blob, but better late than never to see the light. :p As others have said, it's a medium, just like western comics, and as a medium there's a lot of crap to sift through, just like western comics. But there's also some great stuff too.
 

Skittles

Member
I was under the impression that Knights was a more hard sci-fi mech combat/space adventure with some eldritch horror elements

And to be fair, anime/manga tropes don't mean much to me since I have no frame of reference for them. It's all new to me
This is true when they're actually in the mechs, which is when the series is good. But a majority of what happens in-between the mech stuff is extraordinarily disappointing and turned me off(so the characters, their interactions, and the relationships).
 
Beet is actually one of those, like FMA, that splits the duties Western style. Beet was written by Riku Sanjo and drawn by Koji Inada. While Inada has been sick, Sanjo has continued to work, notably on Digimon Xros Wars, Kamen Rider W, Kamen Rider Fourze, Kyoryuger, and Kamen Rider Drive. All of which are damned good.
I was quite aware of the split, but I wasn't are that Riku Sanjo was involved in Xros Wars, which is definitely one of my favorite series of Digimon (mostly because I'm admittedly a terrible person and don't usually pay attention to writing staff and the like when it comes to anime, which I should probably be better about. >.<). No wonder I like it so much. :D Never really got into tokusatsu/super sentai, but maybe I should. Hmm...
 

casiopao

Member
Or love them.

:p



Good lord no.

It is so good lol. I damn love the manga that i even buy all the volume here.^~^

Of course for more classic one,Kurosagi is also damn nice. Or Nobunaga no Chef.^~^


If you love football/soccer Giant Killing is easily the best realistic soccer manga lol.
 
You should put Nausicaa: Valley of the Wind on your list. Especially if you like some of the Studio Ghibli films. It's post-apocalyptic Sci-fi that is far enough past the apocalypse that it is sort of fantasy epic as well.

EDIT:
Far future sci-fi with that art? Yes, that's my jam right there

Is there a lot of world building? Are you familiar with the Image comic Prophet? Another series like that would be amazing
 

duckroll

Member
This is true when they're actually in the mechs, which is when the series is good. But a majority of what happens in-between the mech stuff is extraordinarily disappointing and turned me off(so the characters, their interactions, and the relationships).

I... would not classify anything in Sidonia as "hard scifi". I swear that the term gets watered down more with each year. Gundam is not hard scifi. Just because something is relatively serious and details scientific bullshit elements for world building doesn't mean it is hard scifi. These are just space operas!
 
I... would not classify anything in Sidonia as "hard scifi". I swear that the term gets watered down more with each year. Gundam is not hard scifi. Just because something is relatively serious and details scientific bullshit elements for world building doesn't mean it is hard scifi. These are just space operas!
What about Planetes? That's another series I saw described as hard sci-fi
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
I... would not classify anything in Sidonia as "hard scifi". I swear that the term gets watered down more with each year. Gundam is not hard scifi. Just because something is relatively serious and details scientific bullshit elements for world building doesn't mean it is hard scifi. These are just space operas!

Awwwwww yeah hard vs soft scifi.
What about Planetes? That's another series I saw described as hard sci-fi

Yes Planetes is pretty hard.
 

Dio

Banned
Always kinda surprising to me how many people assume manga is this monolithic
moe
blob, but better late than never to see the light. :p As others have said, it's a medium, just like western comics, and as a medium there's a lot of crap to sift through, just like western comics. But there's also some great stuff too.

People outside of Japan tend to think that manga and anime have the same sort of social position, I guess.

IN Japan, fucking EVERYONE reads manga. There are genres for every demographic out there. There are manga for older office ladies, there are manga for blue collar workers, there are manga for gamblers.

Anime, on the other hand...it's more the domain of either kids or long-running-for-fucking-forever shows like Sazae-san, in the same vein as something like Peanuts or the Family Circus. Being 'really into anime' is just as weird in America as it is in Japan.

I mean sure, there are masterpiece anime series still being made to this day (see Shinsekai Yori) but that's quite a rarity. It didn't really sell that well either IIRC.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom