• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

ResetEra deplatforms and bans Angry Joe for his TLOU2 review

Coolwhhip

Neophyte
more ?



ECbDaVJXUAA3XmN


I will keep it simple and call anyone who honestly cares about this shit by their proper pronoun: retard.
 
You explain to me how he gave TLOU a 10/10 and a 6/10 bordering on 5/10 to TLOU2 even though he praised... the gameplay, the graphics, A.I... Somehow women with muscles was one of the big problems. Muscles.

As predicted , you cannot.

You make the claim, you provide the evidence. The burden of proof is on you. I'm not required to do anything. Again, you're the one making the usual claims with the usual degree of certainty and the usual amount of evidence to back it all up. Your assumptions prove nothing besides your own personal inclination and disposition towards Angry Joe.

The supreme gal you have then to act sanctimonious.
Pfff.
 

JeloSWE

Member
You explain to me how he gave TLOU a 10/10 and a 6/10 bordering on 5/10 to TLOU2 even though he praised... the gameplay, the graphics, A.I... Somehow women with muscles was one of the big problems. Muscles.
I think AJ didn't understand the story or at least didn't agree with the choices characters made. If one pays attention most of their actions are very well explained and within character which in my opinion AJ didn't pick up on.
 
Last edited:

Thirty7ven

Banned
So you are trans and lesbian for being "ready to bite" on that, or what does that retarded rhetoric argument you try to play here mean?

I don't even understand what you're trying to say here.


That's nonsense, since I don't give a shit about your trans issues and lesbians and other people you feel the need to defend politically.
It's me having a direct conversation with YOU here, who is acting like a hypocrite.

Are you able to spot the difference, mate?

You're not having a conversation. You first tried to pin me down on the use of the word "little" because you thought "little men" meant "little people", and when that failed you went on a weird take about the word "little" being used as synonymous of "bad".


Okay, I am counting on you to do that on each and every thread now, Captain Social Justice.

Oh you the Commanding officer? My bad, I should've called it in. I should have. It's just, it was short notice, but I understand these little things add up, so I'll be sure to check with high ranking next time. Higher, I mean.
 
Last edited:

GeorgPrime

Banned
I haven't watched the whole review yet but one thing I'll say about what I've seen so far.

Story spoiler
He flips out over the fact that Ellie doesn't kill Abby and that the whole games story of revenge is pointless because she didn't fulfill her revenge. It's as stupid as saying the story in TLOU1 would be pointless. The aim of that 12 hour game was to deliver Ellie to the Fireflies so they can create a cure. Ellie was delivered to the Fireflies but no cure was created. OMG POINTLESS STORY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

First Part:

- A strange virus broke out
- Ellie may the reason for a cure
- joel gets to deliver her to the fireflies
- Joel and Ellie become like Father and Daughter on the journey
- Joel kills the scientists to save Ellie because ge cant stand losing her for a shitty mankind.

Second Part:

- Joel gets killed cause of Revenge abd they let Ellie live on.
- Ellie wants revenge and kills all the people
- Abby beats the shit out of Ellie and lets her stay alive AGAIN!
- Ellie wants revenge AGAIN snd searches for Abby
- while winning over Abby she gets crippled by her
- Ellie lets her live but loses everything. She won a battle out of three but lost the war.

The real main character is Abby. She kills Joel. She beats the shit out of Ellie. She cripples Ellie after stuck to a post for several days and saves Lev. Ellie loes everything.

Aside from.the fact that Part 2 is just about feminist propaganda with unrealistic female representation its a run-of-the-mill shitty story with shitty writing and a shitty ending.

Its more understandable that Joel prevents the cure (i would do it too. Fuck mankind) than the developmrnt of Ellie and Abby
 
Last edited:

Thirty7ven

Banned
As predicted , you cannot.

You make the claim, you provide the evidence. The burden of proof is on you. I'm not required to do anything.


This ain't a court of law, deductive reasoning is allowed. To be blunt, I would never censor or deplatform AJ. Regardless of what I think of him.
 

OutRun88

Member
I didn't know a deplorable dumpsite echo chamber housing diminutive minded ideals could be considered a platform.

Nonetheless, unsurprising.
 
Last edited:

Unknown?

Member
I never knew how bad Resetera really was...until I did one thing:

Go pick a controversial thread. Literally any one. Now scan the first page - only the first page (just to illustrate how bad it's gotten) - and look at the bans and what they were for. This will blow your fucking mind.

For example, I think it was the AC Vahalla thread, in the first page someone asked a very innocent question...I think it was "is it historically accurate to depict females like this?" and BAM, motherfucker was banned. You now, it's a video game so I don't give a shit about historical accuracy, so make it a trans character with an iPhone for all I care, whatever. But no one should be banned for asking such an innocent question.

Seriously if anyone wants to see just how bad it's become do as I suggested; go look at the reasons people are being banned and you will be STUNNED. This is what lead me back to Neogaf. After seeing that I thought...you guys don't want discussion. You guys don't want intellectual debates. You guys just want a fucking echo chamber. Jesus.
Yeah, I came here after getting banned for pointing out the left send death threats too. They always point out how right wing extremists send death threats but never the opposite side.

I don't condone threats of any kind, but they act as if their fecal matter doesn't stink. Only the OTHER guys act bad.
 
This ain't a court of law, deductive reasoning is allowed. To be blunt, I would never censor or deplatform AJ. Regardless of what I think of him.

This isn't a court of law - the stock Resetera comeback - but the principle nonetheless applies. Claims require evidence. I have also provided an objective piece of information, a 10/10 score, that strongly suggests your interpretation is probably false. And then what do you do? You move the goal posts from Lesbian characters to "women with muscles".

I'm not having trouble deciding what's happening here.
 

Thirty7ven

Banned
This isn't a court of law - the stock Resetera comeback - but the principle nonetheless applies. Claims require evidence. I have also provided an objective piece of information, a 10/10 score, that strongly suggests your interpretation is probably false. And then what do you do? You move the goal posts from Lesbian characters to "women with muscles".

I'm not having trouble deciding what's happening here.

Why should you be having trouble? You believe my interpretation is false, well there it is. Your world your rules.

A 10/10 for TLOU remastered which happens to include the DLC is not objective proof of anything.

And is it really goal posting, lesbians, trans, and women with muscles? Are these completely different topics with no association with each other at all? Ok I’ll play pretend.
 
ResetEra is yet another example of why tankies and the far-left have more in common with fascists than with actual normal people and reasonable political viewpoints.

Plus, the site is full of child predators and most definitely has connections to Discord groups that distribute CP.
 

Darth

Member
Deplatformed / Cancelled / all the other words... don't mean jack shit if you don't give a fuck.

People are being banned there for stuff like this. Keep in mind people are banned there for pretty much any ridiculous thing you can think of.


FireTheft
Banned
Sunday at 2:04 PM
User banned (permanent): troll account
I really liked that review. He had few good points in there. Game was big disappointment for me”
 
Why should you be having trouble? You believe my interpretation is false, well there it is. Your world your rules.

Your interpretation is rejected because a) you can't provide supporting evidence, b) there's at least one hint to the contrary and c) your language suggests a bias against AJ.

A 10/10 for TLOU remastered which happens to include the DLC is not objective proof of anything.

It certainly doesn't support the narrative Angry Joe is motivated by alleged homophobia. Homophobia would have prevented him from awarding the remastered version a perfect score when the culminating DLC prominently features a character coming out as lesbian. I understand, That fact is an inconvenience for your unsupported theory. I understand you handwaving it.

Not only did he post the review and a walkthrough, he also put out an extended review discussion which lasts for almost an hour. This is poorly compatible with the idea his 6/10 isn't the result of assessing the various aspects of the game but just motivated by an irrational disdain of LBGT+ characters.

And is it really goal posting, lesbians, trans, and women with muscles? Are these completely different topics with no association with each other at all? Ok I’ll play pretend.

You make claims. You provide the evidence and/or the argument.

Your brightest argument has been "Why, Thirty7ven can't fathom any reason other than nebulous overarching phobia against LBGTQ characters as an explanation for his 6/10, so he'll assert it, assert it and assert it some more till everyone simply takes his word for it."

You have a nice day.
 
Last edited:

scalman

Member
Its not about bad score more about those joel lovers who just cant stand what happened to him thats why hate game. Its not real life its not real stuff and its doesnt need to fit you just because you want it to be one way or another.
 
I like Joe but it's worth saying that he has been a strong supporter of the SJW movement throughout the years even when many of us warned him the group was becoming radical. If you help create Frankenstein and it turns around and kills you i can't say i feel bad for you.
 

The_Mike

I cry about SonyGaf from my chair in Redmond, WA
You've been shadow banned. they do that so that it does not show up on the ban tracker and expect to never have a reason or duration added. If you have the same name and avatar here as you do on Resetera the mods actively search other forums for people criticizing the forum and will ban for it.
They are probably reading this topic now looking for people to ban. Its an insane overreach of authority.

Common behavior when you're a communistic leader.
 

jigglet

Banned
They might be bigger than GAF, sure. But compared to Youtube or Twitch, ERA (and by extension GAF) is a footnote at best.

Look I'm not trying to support them. I think they're a bunch of fucking idiots. But I'm not going to be delusional about how much sway they have in the industry.

Sweet icon btw. Best game of the year IMO.
 
Last edited:

royox

Member
Please no.
Then these idiots will come back here. We already purged them. This is a fantastic place for normal talking

I would be fine with those idiots coming back here. They would be here and learn that a Forum is a place where opinions are not banned, not an echo-chamber or a Hive Mind where they ban any diferent kind of thought. Maybe that could help them get a toughter skin instead of "literally shake" at any comment.
 

FukuDaruma

Member
The mods who banned you years ago on Neogaf are the same ones who started and run Resetera. The irony is that 95% of the people who left Neogaf did so to get away from the bullshit bans and group think, unaware they were being shepherded by the most extreme offenders. Collin Moriarty (noted Grandwizard and Weinstein/Epstein sympathizer /s) famously started a thread there in their first days, celebrating the liberation of the hivemind. He was banned and locked within seconds...for that TV-PG 90's sitcom joke about "Finally a day of silence" on womens day.

Damn... I wasn't aware of any of that. Some time after I got banned here in NeoGaf I remember reading something like "NeoGaf is run by perverts/molesters/bullies, come to Resetera, which is a great new site without all that, blah blah blah..." and so I registered there. 🤦‍♂️
 
Top Bottom