• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

RedGamingTech: "Why Series X is having performance problems."

kingpotato

Ask me about my Stream Deck
I'm sick of this FUD, just boot up ... One of the many series x exclusives... And you'll see....
star-wars-anakin-skywalker.gif
 

sircaw

Banned
Probably 15-30% win over ps5

Seriously dude, no disrespect but do you like getting fucked up or something, ARE you like one of those Gimp guys that loves a good seeing too.

I just don't get you, for months you spoke shit, the chickens have come home to roost and yet your still here carrying on with your bullshit.

Half the extreme xbox people have fled like cowards, but your still hear, promoting phil spencers spin, maybe its just time to say sorry and that you were wrong and then move on so we can all get along again.

its ok to be wrong about things. no one will remember in a month or two but this constant denial.
 
Last edited:

BabyYoda

Banned
Wait....what? You are giving Microsoft a pass for a "year or two"?
I never give Microsoft a pass, but it will be more convincing in a year or so considering all of the disruption atm. OK I'll make it easier for you, if it's still the same in six months, then this gloating has some merit. It reminds me of the current US election, too much gloating going on far too early, they'll only look like fools later if it doesn't go the way they thought it would. At least if you are humble about things now, you won't have to hide your face in shame later ;) I'm a PC gamer and I likely won't ever buy one of these consoles for myself, but the numbers don't lie.
 
Last edited:

Topher

Gold Member
I never give Microsoft a pass, but it will be more convincing in a year or so considering all of the disruption atm. OK I'll make it easier for you, if it's still the same in six months, then this gloating has some merit. It reminds me of the current US election, too much gloating going on far too early, they'll only look like fools later if it doesn't go the way they thought it would. At least if you are humble about things now, you won't have to hide your face in shame later ;) I'm a PC gamer and I likely won't ever buy one of these consoles for myself, but the numbers don't lie.

Fair enough. I don't see any need for gloating at all, frankly. But at the same time, I certainly expected to see XSX holding the advantage in visuals and performance. so trying to understand all this and parse out factual information from the outright fluff that is being passed around is challenging. Having said that, if this is as simple a thing as tools needing to be updated then I'd expect that to happen much sooner than later. The pressure, though, is on Microsoft. They touted XSX as the "most powerful console" and I don't think they even have a grace period to deliver on that. Should be as advertised right out of the gate.

I too am a PC gamer, first and foremost, but I buy PS for exclusives.
 

BabyYoda

Banned
Fair enough. I don't see any need for gloating at all, frankly. But at the same time, I certainly expected to see XSX holding the advantage in visuals and performance. so trying to understand all this and parse out factual information from the outright fluff that is being passed around is challenging. Having said that, if this is as simple a thing as tools needing to be updated then I'd expect that to happen much sooner than later. The pressure, though, is on Microsoft. They touted XSX as the "most powerful console" and I don't think they even have a grace period to deliver on that. Should be as advertised right out of the gate.

I too am a PC gamer, first and foremost, but I buy PS for exclusives.
Yeah me too, it doesn't look good does it? That coupled with superior exclusives on the PS5 and imo a far more innovative and exciting controller (Microsoft just phoned in their controllers updates) and with PSVR 2 ready to pounce at some point, Sony are looking a lot better positioned for the next several years. I guess 18% more power isn't enough in this scenario, they really needed the kind of gap that PS4 had over X1. It's certainly interesting to see how this all plays out.

I personally hope Sony fully supports the Dual Sense on PC and ports more of their games there, then I'll have the best of all worlds (well almost all unless Nintendo pulls their finger out!). I've gamed long enough (40 years or so) that any kind of innovation is really welcome and anything that brings me closer to my dream of a personal holodeck is always going to grab my attention! Game Pass is of course fulfilling my dream of paying as little as possible for as much gaming as possible, so kudos to Microsoft there as well!
 
Last edited:

ZehDon

Gold Member
Ok, so DF aren’t MS shills anymore because of their Dirt 5 comparison, and RTG is now an MS shill because of this video. They’ve flip flopped.

Is there an actively updated list of who’s shilling for who? I can’t keep up anymore, and I’ll need the geniuses on this forum to keep me informed.
 
Ok, so DF aren’t MS shills anymore because of their Dirt 5 comparison, and RTG is now an MS shill because of this video. They’ve flip flopped.

Is there an actively updated list of who’s shilling for who? I can’t keep up anymore, and I’ll need the geniuses on this forum to keep me informed.

I think all that matters in the end are the games. At least that's what I'm using as proof of how the systems perform.
 

Topher

Gold Member
I assume you own an Xbox and are upset?

I own an Xbox 360. But why would I be upset? His answer seemed odd and so I asked for clarification. He provided it. All good.

Ok, so DF aren’t MS shills anymore because of their Dirt 5 comparison, and RTG is now an MS shill because of this video. They’ve flip flopped.

Is there an actively updated list of who’s shilling for who? I can’t keep up anymore, and I’ll need the geniuses on this forum to keep me informed.

Wow....so some specific people responding here called DF and RTG shills and now those same people are saying that is no longer the case? Who?
 
Last edited:
Genuine question.
How come I seldom see people talk about Series S tools? Is Series S tools more mature than Series X tools?
GDK is the unified toolkit. So as it becomes more mature it affects all the consoles. Its entire point is to unify development for XSX, XSS, PC, XB, XBX. It is very telling that even first-party game enhancements have certain hiccups in comparison to Sony's, but the games still run much better than the third party games despite being technically the same gen.

P.s. sometimes I feel like a lot of posts are just driveby trolling :messenger_tears_of_joy:
 
Last edited:

assurdum

Banned
Ok, so DF aren’t MS shills anymore because of their Dirt 5 comparison, and RTG is now an MS shill because of this video. They’ve flip flopped.

Is there an actively updated list of who’s shilling for who? I can’t keep up anymore, and I’ll need the geniuses on this forum to keep me informed.
Let's be clear: no one can deny entirely there isn't anything of wrong in the tools. But the real question is we really believe when such issue will be fixed suddenly multiplat on series X will destroy the ps5 counterpart? Because hearing the narrative to the other side, seems we are still stuck in this preconception.
 
Last edited:
Serious question. SeriesX BC is software emulation _ isn't it working wonders and far ahead of Sonys implementation?
And what about Velocity architecture that is getting the games loading as fast as on PS5, when on paper the theoretical difference is double the speed? They are software tools, they working as advertised and even better, they are up to date...
Problem here is that all the games you're thinking of are all cross-platform. I expect SSD solutions to perform similar without some kind of patch. Once multi-platform games are fully moved to the PS5/Series X is where differences will show up. Than again, Series X SSD performance could be the target, so we may not see a large difference but who knows.

What we do know is that Sony exclusives are already utilizing it. Demons Souls is the best example so far. In the Digital Foundry interview with Bluepoint, one of the developers mentioned offhand streaming in asset at 4 gigs per second compressed. I bet you anything there's areas in the game where it's higher. Also mentioned streaming in large chunks as soon as the player rounds a corner.

All this means better RAM utilization which translates to more assets in RAM and at higher quality for the GPU to draw.
 

kuncol02

Banned
PS5 tools and APIs aren't static and also keep improving.
If MS doesn't catch up quickly it might impact the growth of their install base.
How to explain you that...I know I will use totally not real life example (that totally wasn't a case in company I work). It's easier to cut getting one customer from database from 8minutes to 20ms than to lower that time even more.
If MS really have some performance tanking bugs or workarounds in their SDK then it's probably easier to fix them than make another round of optimization for Sony.
 
Already been stated PS5 is easier to work for, I don't get people don't understand that tools do have something in this regard to xbox but people don't want to accept that.
Because that sounds like an excuse for not delivering according to expectations.

Also:
  • MS are supposed to be the biggest software company, infinite money, etc.
  • MS used that same excuse last gen.
There are only so many times you can cry wolf.
 
Because that sounds like an excuse for not delivering according to expectations.

Also:
  • MS are supposed to be the biggest software company, infinite money, etc.
  • MS used that same excuse last gen.
There are only so many times you can cry wolf.

Last gen they had worse hardware and the console performed accordingly. Then they had better hardware and again the console performed accordingly.
 

assurdum

Banned
How to explain you that...I know I will use totally not real life example (that totally wasn't a case in company I work). It's easier to cut getting one customer from database from 8minutes to 20ms than to lower that time even more.
If MS really have some performance tanking bugs or workarounds in their SDK then it's probably easier to fix them than make another round of optimization for Sony.
Uh. Why Sony should make another round of optimization when MS will fix such issue? It's not like suddenly multiplat will start to run shitty on ps5.
 
Last edited:

kuncol02

Banned
Uh. Why Sony should make another round of optimization when MS will fix such issue? It's not like suddenly multiplat will start to run shitty on ps5.
Reading comprehension problem or ignored user? I was answering to specific post.
"PS5 tools and APIs aren't static and also keep improving."
PS5 tools improvment will be much harder and slower to do than fixing that hypothetical bugs in MS SDK (which also would give biggest gains).
 

assurdum

Banned
Reading comprehension problem or ignored user? I was answering to specific post.
"PS5 tools and APIs aren't static and also keep improving."
PS5 tools improvment will be much harder and slower to do than fixing that hypothetical bugs in MS SDK (which also would give biggest gains).
But it's totally a nonsense. You don't even know what cause such issue on series X multiplat, it could even requires the same time if it's something radicate deeper in the tools or in the hardware management.
 
Last edited:

kuncol02

Banned
But it's totally a nonsense. You don't even know what cause such issue on series X multiplat, it could even requires the same time if it's something radicate deeper in the tools or in the hardware management.
Are you sugesting that XSX running almost on One X level of performance is expected behavior? BC games with made with old XDK are running as they are supposed to.
 
Last edited:
Last gen they had worse hardware and the console performed accordingly. Then they had better hardware and again the console performed accordingly.
They still gave false hopes... DX12, the cloud and who knows what. Phil himself was at the helm.

Either way, sony has their wizards at the ICE team, they optimize every single aspects of the APIs at a very low level... It's not like MS were the only ones releasing new versions.

It's not like the series x was alien technology, with a new OS and what not, it's a PC with a couple of custom hardware features. The GPU has a very similar structure as the one in the PS5, if Sony can get it straight (performance wise anyway, the PS5 seems to have a couple of issues, just not at the same level), I don't see why MS can't deliver the same or better performance with the series x.
 

Leyasu

Banned
Are you sugesting that XSX running almost on One X level of performance is expected behavior? BC games with made with old XDK are running as they are supposed to.
Not in the slightest expected.

It obvious that these launch games have problems that are nothing to do with the hardware, but internet forums are what they are.
 
Are you sugesting that XSX running almost on One X level of performance is expected behavior? BC games with made with old XDK are running as they are supposed to.

From the comparisons that I've seen it doesn't appear that the XSX is running the XB1 versions of those games. There's definitely differences between the X1 and XSX versions beyond higher resolution and improved framerates.
 

Leyasu

Banned
From the comparisons that I've seen it doesn't appear that the XSX is running the XB1 versions of those games. There's definitely differences between the X1 and XSX versions beyond higher resolution and improved framerates.
Unlock the frame rate on red dead 2, run it on the XsX, and it would perform/look better than any of the games that have launched and are having problems. These launch titles are half baked at best
 
Last edited:

assurdum

Banned
Are you sugesting that XSX running almost on One X level of performance is expected behavior? BC games with made with old XDK are running as they are supposed to.
You should read again what I said. We don't know the full picture, we don't know if it will requires short time or more.
 
Last edited:

kuncol02

Banned
You should read again what I said. We don't know the full picture, we don't know if it will requires short time or more.
We know there are scenarios where XSX can go as bad as 20fps lower than PS5 at the same time rendering in lower resolution. That's basically 30-40% power difference. There is nothing in that hardware that would explain that.
 
We know there are scenarios where XSX can go as bad as 20fps lower than PS5 at the same time rendering in lower resolution. That's basically 30-40% power difference. There is nothing in that hardware that would explain that.

Maybe it's something outside of the paper specifications?
 

Onironauta

Member
Well, we know that Xbox APIs work on a higher level of abstraction than PS5's ones and that games run inside a virtual machine separated from the OS.

While this is good for software emulation/BC and portability between different HW configurations, there must be a performance cost caused by the overhead, whether big or small.

Even with better SDKs available to the devs, i doubt the performance gap will be solved if PS5 runs games closer to the metal.
 

MrMephistoX

Member
I agree, the Series X is the best last gen console

Lol it really is though I haven’t played anything current gen on it but am enjoying the performance boost on last gen games. Similar boat with PS4 exclusives they actually do run and look better and I still haven’t played Last of Us 2 or Ghosts so I’m good. Last gen sucked at launch IMHO aside from Killer Instinct and Dead Rising 3.
 
I weirdly have been playing more series x because I suck at demons souls - this might be OT but does the series x run bc games faster than the ps5 does? Cus it seems like the loading times for older games are way improved on the x and only moderately on the PlayStation - or is that just due to me playing different games on each
 
Top Bottom