• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ornlu

Banned
The topics in the discussion need to be discussed separately and there needs to be a bigger discussion. First you have to consider the motivation behind those events, then you have to consider the actual violence in those events, what they mean to state order overall, what lessons can be learned, how the media covered them. There's a lot of variables that don't exactly fit inside a tangent to what was a pretty clear cut terrorist act motivated by asinine allegations, this discussion needs to go deeper than "there are double standards".

If we're told that an opinion can't be expressed, then no amount of walking on eggshells or effort put into a well written post is going to change that.

Can i ask why phonepunk was banned? Not sure if i got the name right, he was pretty active in the reeee topic.

That's actually crazy, especially how elaborate and coldblooded it is. Also German Shephard...I mean it's not a reach to think that he probably sympatise with one of the most vile person in history. I've heard this before from skinhead... Not what I expected to read before my launch.


He was falling into pet of madness lately and call EvilLore that he is narc and that he is asking for permaban. Seems like it takes toll on his head the current pandemic situation, because his post sometimes get really heated, as seen in my thread for example:


And that was way before.

Phonepunk came across as fiery in almost every post of his I saw. 90% of the time I was right there like "Fuck yeah hoss, give it to em", and then the other 10% I was thinking "Damn dude, too much".

I personally love people like that; you always know where you stand with them. Unfortunately the internet is where the people who use 10,000 words to say nothing reign supreme.

Icarus flew too close to the sun.
 

Dacon

Banned
FFXIII Trilogy is a masterpiece!
iqgdezdlyhxry.gif

XIII and XIII-2 are decent games but Lightning Returns is god awful.
 
Phonepunk came across as fiery in almost every post of his I saw. 90% of the time I was right there like "Fuck yeah hoss, give it to em", and then the other 10% I was thinking "Damn dude, too much".

I personally love people like that; you always know where you stand with them. Unfortunately the internet is where the people who use 10,000 words to say nothing reign supreme.

Icarus flew too close to the sun.
He always felt to me when I read a post of him like that old drugged out asshole bum complaining in the supermarket that he has to stand in the queue like everybody else.
 
Last edited:

EviLore

Expansive Ellipses
Staff Member
I have to say I disagree with that, I think the 2017 Las Vegas shooting is by far the most significant since 9/11 and completely dwarfs the Capitol. 60 dead and 411 wounded.
Horrific incident, definitely. Didn’t alter the landscape of the country though. Prompted legislation against a specific type of bump stocks. But binary triggers and other alternatives still exist for faux full-auto.

The Pulse nightclub massacre didn’t reshape the country either. Or the Boston bombing. Or El Paso.

The attack on the Capitol has prompted over 100 arrests for domestic terrorism, a nationwide FBI domestic terror investigation, a major social media platform has been permanently nuked, the POTUS has been impeached and silenced from social media, three Cabinet members resigned, and the shockwave will continue expanding. Glenn Greenwald has expressed concerns that this will prompt a second War on Terror that erodes freedoms, similar to the post-9/11 world.
 
I have to say I disagree with that, I think the 2017 Las Vegas shooting is by far the most significant since 9/11 and completely dwarfs the Capitol. 60 dead and 411 wounded.

I was in Vegas a week before that for a work conference. I will tell you, after that event I vowed to never go to public concerts again. The shooter had a room booked for Lolapalooza in Chicago and just never showed up. Very scary.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
Horrific incident, definitely. Didn’t alter the landscape of the country though. Prompted legislation against a specific type of bump stocks. But binary triggers and other alternatives still exist for faux full-auto.

The Pulse nightclub massacre didn’t reshape the country either. Or the Boston bombing. Or El Paso.

The attack on the Capitol has prompted over 100 arrests for domestic terrorism, a nationwide FBI domestic terror investigation, a major social media platform has been permanently nuked, the POTUS has been impeached and silenced from social media, three Cabinet members resigned, and the shockwave will continue expanding. Glenn Greenwald has expressed concerns that this will prompt a second War on Terror that erodes freedoms, similar to the post-9/11 world.
Yup. The difference now is that the lawmakers were in harms way. These people make laws for a living, and some of them feared for their lives in those bunkers. They are going to go all out.
 

Rentahamster

Rodent Whores
EviLore EviLore now that I've taken the time to think about it can you ban me from politics for a week or two?
I think I've been letting shit distract me too much from important things I need to focus on, and I think it'd help to kill the temptation to get caught up in unnecessary conflict.
May I suggest a replay of your favorite game of 2020, Final Fantasy 7 Remake!

j/k get some rest and relaxation in 🍻
 

Happosai

Hold onto your panties
Horrific incident, definitely. Didn’t alter the landscape of the country though. Prompted legislation against a specific type of bump stocks. But binary triggers and other alternatives still exist for faux full-auto.

The Pulse nightclub massacre didn’t reshape the country either. Or the Boston bombing. Or El Paso.

The attack on the Capitol has prompted over 100 arrests for domestic terrorism, a nationwide FBI domestic terror investigation, a major social media platform has been permanently nuked, the POTUS has been impeached and silenced from social media, three Cabinet members resigned, and the shockwave will continue expanding. Glenn Greenwald has expressed concerns that this will prompt a second War on Terror that erodes freedoms, similar to the post-9/11 world.
I was in the middle of my work shift while all this was going down. Mexico always runs American news before their own and my wife told me what was going on. Took one look at the motive, the act, and live coverage and called it domestic terrorism. I figured that many don't like hearing that and they think they were "freedom warriors" but it was it was pretty close on par to any terrorist act the U.S. has experienced. I don't even go into the politics about it. I just take things at face value without bias. Glad the mods can see that it's something the community shouldn't be defending.
 

EviLore

Expansive Ellipses
Staff Member
EviLore EviLore now that I've taken the time to think about it can you ban me from politics for a week or two?

I think I've been letting shit distract me too much from important things I need to focus on, and I think it'd help to kill the temptation to get caught up in unnecessary conflict.
All set.
 
Horrific incident, definitely. Didn’t alter the landscape of the country though. Prompted legislation against a specific type of bump stocks. But binary triggers and other alternatives still exist for faux full-auto.

The Pulse nightclub massacre didn’t reshape the country either. Or the Boston bombing. Or El Paso.

The attack on the Capitol has prompted over 100 arrests for domestic terrorism, a nationwide FBI domestic terror investigation, a major social media platform has been permanently nuked, the POTUS has been impeached and silenced from social media, three Cabinet members resigned, and the shockwave will continue expanding. Glenn Greenwald has expressed concerns that this will prompt a second War on Terror that erodes freedoms, similar to the post-9/11 world.
We had the german goverment + parliament discussing about the Capitol riot and its consequences today.
This didn't happen with shootings.
 
Last edited:

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
The attack on the Capitol has prompted over 100 arrests for domestic terrorism, a nationwide FBI domestic terror investigation, a major social media platform has been permanently nuked, the POTUS has been impeached and silenced from social media, three Cabinet members resigned, and the shockwave will continue expanding. Glenn Greenwald has expressed concerns that this will prompt a second War on Terror that erodes freedoms, similar to the post-9/11 world.

I completely agree with Glenn Greenwald and in my opinion it's already happening. Some scary shit brewing these days.
 

Boss Mog

Member
Horrific incident, definitely. Didn’t alter the landscape of the country though. Prompted legislation against a specific type of bump stocks. But binary triggers and other alternatives still exist for faux full-auto.

The Pulse nightclub massacre didn’t reshape the country either. Or the Boston bombing. Or El Paso.

The attack on the Capitol has prompted over 100 arrests for domestic terrorism, a nationwide FBI domestic terror investigation, a major social media platform has been permanently nuked, the POTUS has been impeached and silenced from social media, three Cabinet members resigned, and the shockwave will continue expanding. Glenn Greenwald has expressed concerns that this will prompt a second War on Terror that erodes freedoms, similar to the post-9/11 world.
Oh you meant that will have the most repercussions, then yeah I agree, I just thought you meant biggest terror attack, because in terms or scope/fatalities and damage, the capitol attack was rather small, but yeah the repercussions will surely be huge and felt for years to come.
 
Horrific incident, definitely. Didn’t alter the landscape of the country though. Prompted legislation against a specific type of bump stocks. But binary triggers and other alternatives still exist for faux full-auto.

The Pulse nightclub massacre didn’t reshape the country either. Or the Boston bombing. Or El Paso.

The attack on the Capitol has prompted over 100 arrests for domestic terrorism, a nationwide FBI domestic terror investigation, a major social media platform has been permanently nuked, the POTUS has been impeached and silenced from social media, three Cabinet members resigned, and the shockwave will continue expanding. Glenn Greenwald has expressed concerns that this will prompt a second War on Terror that erodes freedoms, similar to the post-9/11 world.
THIS. Also, don't forget China and Russia are studying the fuck out of this attack to find more weaknesses in our security.
 
Oh you meant that will have the most repercussions, then yeah I agree, I just thought you meant biggest terror attack, because in terms or scope/fatalities and damage, the capitol attack was rather small, but yeah the repercussions will surely be huge and felt for years to come.
I find it funny, how many of you still don't understand how crazy it is what actually happened there probably just because the funny bearded people from Duck Dynasty and The Dukes of Hazard were involved and how could they do no good.
 
If we're told that an opinion can't be expressed, then no amount of walking on eggshells or effort put into a well written post is going to change that.





Phonepunk came across as fiery in almost every post of his I saw. 90% of the time I was right there like "Fuck yeah hoss, give it to em", and then the other 10% I was thinking "Damn dude, too much".

I personally love people like that; you always know where you stand with them. Unfortunately the internet is where the people who use 10,000 words to say nothing reign supreme.

Icarus flew too close to the sun.
Honestly, he became WAY too anti-trans for me. Like it was an unhealthy obsession you would swear a trans person killed his mother or something. His post started to make me uncomfortable after a while.
 
Last edited:

Boss Mog

Member
I find it funny, how many of you still don't understand how crazy it is what actually happened there probably just because the funny bearded people from Duck Dynasty and The Dukes of Hazard were involved and how could they do no good.
The footage I saw was mostly people walking around nonchalantly unchallenged posing for selfies and grabbing "souvenirs". Seems like security was completely inadequate. So when AOC goes on TV to say she feared for her life, it kinda hard not to read it as hyperbole. The shock of the capitol attack was more like "why is nobody stopping these people, it's the capitol for fuck's sake". When you compare it to footage of the "summer of love", that was shocking in a completely different way. Sections of cities taken over, public roads blocked, people dragged out of their cars and beaten to death, people executed at point blank range, chaos, destruction, looting all around with buildings burning everywhere, it was like scenes from a post-apocalyptic movie. Meanwhile both the democrats, woke celebrities and the mainstream media were all cheering it on and encouraging more. Trump is definitely responsible for inciting the capitol attack, but the people I just mentioned are equally responsible for inciting this past summer's attacks which were far more deadly and destructive.
 

GloveSlap

Member
Honestly, he became WAY too anti-trans for me. Like it was an unhealthy obsession you would swear a trans person killed his mother or something. His post started to make me uncomfortable after a while.
I'm just glad I don't have scroll past any more 1000 word "death cult" rants. But yeah there was too much nasty stuff flung at gay/trans people by a small number of posters for a while (calling them freaks/degenerates/etc.).
 
The footage I saw was mostly people walking around nonchalantly unchallenged posing for selfies and grabbing "souvenirs".
Have we seen the same videos?

Seems like security was completely inadequate. So when AOC goes on TV to say she feared for her life, it kinda hard not to read it as hyperbole. The shock of the capitol attack was more like "why is nobody stopping these people, it's the capitol for fuck's sake".
Your government was threatened and was on the run while it tried to do its job.
It seems you are still not able to realize what happened there.


When you compare it to footage of the "summer of love", that was shocking in a completely different way. Sections of cities taken over, public roads blocked, people dragged out of their cars and beaten to death, people executed at point blank range, chaos, destruction, looting all around with buildings burning everywhere, it was like scenes from a post-apocalyptic movie.
I concur that this was horrible. Don't expect any downplaying of this by me.

Meanwhile both the democrats, woke celebrities and the mainstream media were all cheering it on and encouraging more. Trump is definitely responsible for inciting the capitol attack, but the people I just mentioned are equally responsible for inciting this past summer's attacks which were far more deadly and destructive.
Once again. Yeah, these things are horrible.

But last week on Wednesday, your whole country and its way of how to govern was under attack.
It's crazy how you can downplay this.

You showed the whole world how weak you are. So weak that the German Bundestag was debating today if the US are still a trustworthy partner or if we should look elsewhere in future. And this debates have been held in every european country now as far as I know.
 
Last edited:

Rentahamster

Rodent Whores
The footage I saw was mostly people walking around nonchalantly unchallenged posing for selfies and grabbing "souvenirs". Seems like security was completely inadequate.
When you compare it to footage of the "summer of love", that was shocking in a completely different way. Sections of cities taken over, public roads blocked, people dragged out of their cars and beaten to death, people executed at point blank range, chaos, destruction, looting all around with buildings burning everywhere, it was like scenes from a post-apocalyptic movie.

How confident are you that the footage you are consuming isn't influenced by a selection bias, either self generated, or generated by others or an internet algorithm designed for emotional engagement?

Yes, in the capitol there was footage of people mostly milling about, but there's also footage of trespassing on restricted land, theft, and murder.

Yes, in the summer riots there is footage of hostile takeovers, theft, vandalism, and murder, but there is also footage of people speaking their mind without violence and just holding up signs and shouting.

Are you getting complete pictures of both scenarios via the pathways in which you consume information, or can they be flawed too?

The overall point I'm trying to make is that you can see these events through the lens of overall damage numbers or deaths, or implications. There's many ways to analyze this. Yes, the summer riots have a higher body count and more monetary damage, but that's because there was more of them. By contrast, the capitol incident was an attack on the fundamental institutions that are the bedrock of our entire country, both in law and in physical space.

If an attack like that was able to fester as much as a whole summer, what would you make of the comparison then?
 
How confident are you that the footage you are consuming isn't influenced by a selection bias, either self generated, or generated by others or an internet algorithm designed for emotional engagement?

Yes, in the capitol there was footage of people mostly milling about, but there's also footage of trespassing on restricted land, theft, and murder.

Yes, in the summer riots there is footage of hostile takeovers, theft, vandalism, and murder, but there is also footage of people speaking their mind without violence and just holding up signs and shouting.

Are you getting complete pictures of both scenarios via the pathways in which you consume information, or can they be flawed too?

The overall point I'm trying to make is that you can see these events through the lens of overall damage numbers or deaths, or implications. There's many ways to analyze this. Yes, the summer riots have a higher body count and more monetary damage, but that's because there was more of them. By contrast, the capitol incident was an attack on the fundamental institutions that are the bedrock of our entire country, both in law and in physical space.

If an attack like that was able to fester as much as a whole summer, what would you make of the comparison then?

I agree with your analysis, but one of my biggest complaints is that what happened in the summer was not tamped down quickly and effectively enough that it actually helped encourage what we saw on Jan 6. It’s like the kid who sees a sibling get away with things and then says well I’m going to start doing that too and amplifies the bad behavior. I think it’s a huge mistake not to see that connection as it’s a very real human condition.
 

Rentahamster

Rodent Whores
I agree with your analysis, but one of my biggest complaints is that what happened in the summer was not tamped down quickly and effectively enough that it actually helped encourage what we saw on Jan 6. It’s like the kid who sees a sibling get away with things and then says well I’m going to start doing that too and amplifies the bad behavior. I think it’s a huge mistake not to see that connection as it’s a very real human condition.
It was most likely a contributing factor but life is complicated. At what point are we going to draw the line between out of control factors vs personal responsibility?
 
It was most likely a contributing factor but life is complicated. At what point are we going to draw the line between out of control factors vs personal responsibility?

Personal responsibility should always be a thing. The line is crossed though when you start destroying innocent people’s property and killing other human beings. The government would not let the cops effectively protect their cities and themselves. People saw that and learned from it.

Do you have kids? If so, I’m pretty sure you tamp down certain unacceptable behavior before it gets out of hand. Why? Because not doing so leads to more bad behavior and encourages their siblings.

Willy Wonka And The Chocolate Factory Tantrum GIF


As for the Capitol rioters, I said at the time this was a huge mistake. They endangered lives, killed an innocent man, and are going to lead to huge government overreach. They deserve to rot in prison and have no sympathy from me. My only issue is the hypocrites who are only now outraged. They should have been outraged back in the summer. I hope they continue to be outraged by this behavior should more riots happen regardless of the cause. I hope they also tone down their rhetoric and stop encouraging people to act like animals.
 
Last edited:

Rentahamster

Rodent Whores
Personal responsibility should always be a thing. The line is crossed though when you start destroying innocent people’s property and killing other human beings. The government would not let the cops effectively protect their cities and themselves. People saw that and learned from it.

Do you have kids? If so, I’m pretty sure you tamp down certain unacceptable behavior before it gets out of hand. Why? Because not doing so leads to more bad behavior and encourages their siblings.

Willy Wonka And The Chocolate Factory Tantrum GIF
When your own kids act like shitheads, what do you do (i.e. what is the priority, what is the most constructive and responsible response)? Deal with their behavior directly or make remarks about how your kids were influenced by the shitty behavior of other kids who have deficient parents?
 
Last edited:
When your own kids act like shitheads, what do you do (i.e. what is the priority, what is the most constructive and responsible response)? Deal with their behavior directly or make remarks about how your kids were influenced by the shitty behavior of other kids who have deficient parents?

I don’t act like an idiot and let the first one be a shithead.
 

Boss Mog

Member
Have we seen the same videos?


Your government was threatened and was on the run while it tried to do its job.
It seems you are still not able to realize what happened there.



I concur that this was horrible. Don't expect any downplaying of this by me.


Once again. Yeah, these things are horrible.

But last week on Wednesday, your whole country and its way of how to govern was under attack.
It's crazy how you can downplay this.

You showed the whole world how weak you are. So weak that the German Bundestag was debating today if the US are still a trustworthy partner or if we should look elsewhere in future. And this debates have been held in every european country now as far as I know.
I'm not downplaying it at all and I realized exactly what happened. Proper security (especially since they were warned in advance that some fanatics would probably try to storm the capitol) would have prevented this. Maybe the security forces they had were afraid to open fire on citizens and maybe some of them had doubts since during the whole summer the democrat politicians basically went on record to say that all cops are terrorists and should be defunded/disbanded. Obviously professional police officers should always do their duty though, even if it means protecting people that spit in their faces, so I don't condone law enforcement giving these terrorists a pass if any did. At the end of the day though Trump's presidency was only a thing because a lot of people were completely sick of wokeism and marxism taking over all facets of their lives. I seriously believe that if all these radical ideas weren't being pushed down our throats there's no chance Trump would've ever been elected. His election was like a big "fuck you!" to the establishment, that's all. All these radical politicians popping up in Western democracies only get support because arrogant mainstream politicians don't listen to what citizens want (which is the point of a democracy) and instead do what's best for them and their agenda, so some, in desperation turn to candidates who claim to hear their grievances.
 
That's not what I asked. As a parent you should know that no one is 100% successful all the time. Big or small, you're going to run into situations eventually.

I know that’s not what you’re asking. I’m purposely not answering the question because I nip it in the bud before that happens and I let my other kids know this behavior will not be tolerated so think twice before you do it because you’ll get the same. That way I don’t hear well the other one got away with it. I grew up in a large family. I’m well prepared for score keeping.
 
Last edited:
Then I'm sorry to say that you're dodging and missing the point of this thought experiment.

No, I’m not humoring a hypothetical that will not occur because I do my job as a parent and squash bad behavior. You’ve seen my answer, you see that I don’t tolerate bad behavior period, regardless of the excuse. Indirectly, I answer your question while not redirecting responsibility from the parent as it should be.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom