• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Man punches woman into a coma over parking space

Status
Not open for further replies.
http://abcnews.go.com/US/woman-beaten-coma-parking-lot-rage/story?id=13082308

A New York City man faces felony assault charges after he punched an 100-pound woman who was standing in a space he wanted. Lana Rosas, 25, was saving the space for her boyfriend. Now she's in a coma

"Nobody would think anything would happen that would go this far," said Oscar Fuller, the alleged attacker, to reporters.

Fuller said the evidence would prove he acted in self-defense.

"She hit first ... and just like we know there are cameras everywhere inside New York City," said Fuller.


Rosas is still in the hospital. Doctors have removed part of her skull to reduce the brain swelling.

"I am very very sorry for the situation she is going through right now, and I am hoping for a speedy recovery," said Fuller. Fuller left the scene before paramedics arrived but said he didn't realize Rosas was so badly hurt when he left the scene.

This isn't the first time finding a parking space, or getting out of one, has been taken to another level.


In this Youtube video, you can hear angry honking in a face off between three grown women in a Las Vegas parking lot.

You can see it in this mechanical shoving match over a space between these cars in England.

Another driver in England lost his license for a year for ramming into a car that was blocking his way out of a garage.

When you are looking for a space, you are often already on edge, like a hunter.

It seems like these responses are completely disproportionate to finding a parking spot.

"Obviously, they are making it much bigger than it is, and once they are there often something that goes along with anger is a righteousness. I am just I am in the right so in that case there is no reason to measure my response," said Ryan Fuller, a psychologist.

And when one someone snaps, they just lose control.
"Some people will have a rage response for minutes and minutes, and they won't even know what has happened. They really see red," said Fuller.


Oscar Fuller is free on $100,000 bail.

Thoughts?

Did a search, couldn't find anything. Cock if old.
 
I'm 100 pounds, any decent sized dude could easily pin me down or keep me at arms length to keep me from hitting them. Punching her into a coma could have been avoided by walking away too.

Also people need to chill about parking, but I'm a public transit enthusiast.
 

Salazar

Member
Fuller left the scene before paramedics arrived but said he didn't realize Rosas was so badly hurt when he left the scene.

I would have citizen's arrested that motherfucker so hard.
 
If he has a good lawyer that can prove self defense more power to him. It's not like there is a punching power meter you can set to "Stun", "Bruise" or "Coma". If she attacked him and he felt his life was threatened he has the right to defend himself.
 

Monocle

Member
lightless_shado said:
http://abcnews.go.com/US/woman-beaten-coma-parking-lot-rage/story?id=13082308



Thoughts?

Did a search, couldn't find anything. Cock if old.
Everything happens for a reason?
SKj7l.jpg


Yeah, no. Let's hope the megadouche goes to prison for a long time.

Serenade said:
he should be killed, sent to rot in prison, and then killed again
He should be killed, sent to rot in prison, baked into a pizza, then fed to a tiger centipede (like a human centipede, but with tigers).
 

richiek

steals Justin Bieber DVDs
MWS Natural said:
If she attacked him and he felt his life was threatened he has the right to defend himself.

A man feeling his life was in danger by a 100 pound woman? Really?
 
MWS Natural said:
If he has a good lawyer that can prove self defense more power to him. It's not like there is a punching power meter you can set to "Stun", "Bruise" or "Coma". If she attacked him and he felt his life was threatened he has the right to defend himself.

It comes down primary physical aggressor and size difference, in some states anyways.
 
MWS Natural said:
If he has a good lawyer that can prove self defense more power to him. It's not like there is a punching power meter you can set to "Stun", "Bruise" or "Coma". If she attacked him and he felt his life was threatened he has the right to defend himself.

Kind of the equivalent of pulling a knife on someone that shoves you though isn't it? It doesn't make sense for someone who is much bigger and stronger to just go all out on someone who is clearly weaker than him.

Apparently there were cameras recording too, so whatever case he has could be demolished if its proven that he went too far even if he was already attacked.
 

markot

Banned
Self defence has to be proportional. You cant shoot someone for slapping you.

And its got to be hard to be threatened by a hundred pound woman to the point where you need to punch her so hard she goes into a coma..... I like how he justifys his crap 'I had no need to measure my response' wtf?

Also there is a punching power meter... there is a huge difference between knocking someones head with your fist and putting your entire body and force into it..... Hell even professional boxers have light and heavy punches.
 
Oblivion briefly mentioned this in PoliGAF

kelly-troll.jpg


If he has a good lawyer that can prove self defense more power to him. It's not like there is a punching power meter you can set to "Stun", "Bruise" or "Coma". If she attacked him and he felt his life was threatened he has the right to defend himself.

There's a limit to which self defense can be used.
 
markot said:
Self defence has to be proportional. You cant shoot someone for slapping you.

And its got to be hard to be threatened by a hundred pound woman to the point where you need to punch her so hard she goes into a coma..... I like how he justifys his crap 'I had no need to measure my response' wtf?

My 120lbs ex could kick the shit out of me. We don't even know if she had any combat training.
 

Salazar

Member
MWS Natural said:
It's not like there is a punching power meter you can set to "Stun", "Bruise" or "Coma".

I can set mine to "man" or "small woman".

And to "serious situation" or "bizarrely trivial scuffle".
 
Cereal KiIIer said:
My 120lbs ex could kick the shit out of me. We don't even know if she had any combat training.

I'm sorry bro but it takes a lot to punch someone into a coma, unless it was a one punch she hit her head on the pavement deal, he went way too fucking far.

Also I'm biased because I'm the same size, it does not take a lot to take us out.
 
richiek said:
A man feeling his life was in danger by a 100 pound woman? Really?
Yes? I'm sure to him the current headline reads better than:
"Man get's eyes gouged out by 100lb woman over parking space."

People act like women don't have the capacity for violence.
 
I doubt a hundred-pound woman could even be classified as death-threatening... unless she were some specially-trained assassin or had laser vision. In the given circumstances, that seems unlikely. In fact, she probably could've been easily subdued w/o punching her in the friggin head.
 

markot

Banned
Cereal KiIIer said:
My 120lbs ex could kick the shit out of me. We don't even know if she had any combat training.
But just listen to his quote, about being rigtheous and just. It seems clear to me he went over board and he knows it, but he justifys it by 'she hit me first'. Then he goes into 'rage' and how people can go mental without knowing it.

I mean I know he is a psych but damn.
 

Dresden

Member
Sounds like she hit him once and he figured this was a good chance to let his stress out.

It wouldn't be hard to knock out a 100lb woman with a single blow. That's like hitting a child.
 

Gospel

Parmesan et Romano
Monocle said:
He should be killed, sent to rot in prison, baked into a pizza, then fed to a tiger centipede (like a human centipede, but with tigers).
Even better. It's good because tigers are just bigger cats

that'll show him
 

Freshmaker

I am Korean.
Devolution said:
I'm 100 pounds, any decent sized dude could easily pin me down or keep me at arms length to keep me from hitting them. Punching her into a coma could have been avoided by walking away too.

Also people need to chill about parking, but I'm a public transit enthusiast.
100lbs nothing. Self defense ends once the threat is gone. You can't beat anyone who isn't coming after you with lethal force into a coma and claim self-defense. (It's not likely to fly in any case unless it was one or two freak shots that ended with a coma.)
 
Sounds to me like some of you have no self-control or sense of proportionality. You guys need help.

Also, parking is for suckers. Ride the metro, bitchessss
 
Salazar said:
I can set mine to "man" or "small woman".

And to "serious situation" or "bizarrely trivial scuffle".

That's good for you. Being a grown man who would have no need to fight other than to defend myself I don't have such varying settings on my punches. If for a reason I need to throw a punch it is to fully neutralize the attacker.
 
I bet she did attack him first. A lot of women believe they can hit men anytime they want with no repercussions. Not saying that is any excuse for putting her in the hospital though.
 

antonz

Member
Self defense or not guy deserves a lengthy prison sentence. There is a difference between defense and beating someone so badly they go into coma and need to have part of their skull removed to control brain swelling.

Asshole should have never gotten out of his car and moved on.
 
Dresden said:
Sounds like she hit him once and he figured this was a good chance to let his stress out.

It wouldn't be hard to knock out a 100lb woman with a single blow. That's like hitting a child.

Well we aren't sure if he hit her just once. There's a good chance that he kept punching until she couldn't stand up.

And people shouldn't make this into a gender thing. The outrage would still be strong if he punched out a teenage boy or a small man. Maybe not as strong since we have this programming in us that makes us think that women are harmless and never hurt anyone whereas men are easily angered, obviously that's wrong as women some women can be as agressive as some men.
 

Satyamdas

Banned
markot said:
But just listen to his quote, about being rigtheous and just. It seems clear to me he went over board and he knows it, but he justifys it by 'she hit me first'. Then he goes into 'rage' and how people can go mental without knowing it.

I mean I know he is a psych but damn.
Read the article again, the guy mentioning being righteous is a psychologist who just happens to have the same last name as the guy who punched her. He was describing the 'hunter' mentality of those searching for parking spots.

Oscar Fuller, the alleged attacker

Ryan Fuller, a psychologist


lightless_shado said:
Well we aren't sure if he hit her just once. There's a good chance that he kept punching until she couldn't stand up.
I doubt the guy would be asking for video evidence to prove his innocence if he pounded her face after she had fallen unconscious. It is more likely that one or two shots crumpled her and her head slammed against the pavement causing the trauma.
 
threenote said:
Death penalty. What a fucking psycho.
If the video feed shows she threw the first punch, he might just get in trouble for fleeing the scene. There's a world of difference between swinging at someone and running, and dragging them to the ground and beating the life out of them blow by blow. Add to that, it's his word versus, well...
 
lightless_shado said:
Well we aren't sure if he hit her just once. There's a good chance that he kept punching until she couldn't stand up.

And people shouldn't make this into a gender thing. The outrage would still be strong if he punched out a teenage boy or a small man. Maybe not as strong since we have this programming in us that makes us think that women are harmless and never hurt anyone whereas men are easily angered, obviously that's wrong as women some women can be as agressive as some men.

Next time title your thread "person punches 100lb person into coma over parking space". Just sayin' you kind of already framed the gender issue with that title.
 

Zeke

Member
Devolution said:
I'm 100 pounds, any decent sized dude could easily pin me down or keep me at arms length to keep me from hitting them. Punching her into a coma could have been avoided by walking away too.

Also people need to chill about parking, but I'm a public transit enthusiast.
holy crap I didn't know you're part of girl-gaf double the shock considering the last thread we were in. I wonder if he will get out on self-defense if the video shows her swinging first.
 

markot

Banned
Satyamdas said:
Read the article again, the guy mentioning being righteous is a psychologist who just happens to have the same last name as the guy who punched her. He was describing the 'hunter' mentality of those searching for parking spots.
Oh, lol >_< sorry.
 
Zeke said:
holy crap I didn't know you're part of girl-gaf double the shock considering the last thread we were in. I wonder if he will get out on self-defense if the video shows her swinging first.

It always amazes people, dunno why, maybe it's cause i'm super vulgar.
 
FlightOfHeaven said:
Sounds to me like some of you have no self-control or sense of proportionality. You guys need help.
How about if you want to avoid a physical altercation, you don't throw the first punch? The policy has served me well enough thus far. It should be good enough for everyone, no matter what chromosomes you carry.
 

Salazar

Member
MWS Natural said:
That's good for you. Being a grown man who would have no need to fight other than to defend myself I don't have such varying settings on my punches.

The implication that I am not

a) a grown man
b) peaceful

amuses me.
 

unomas

Banned
Getting sick of reading about stuff like this in our society in general. People are just rude and clueless.
 
Ignis Fatuus said:
How about if you want to avoid a physical altercation, you don't throw the first punch? The policy has served me well enough thus far.

I don't think people who get punched should be going into full on violent rages either. Self-defense shouldn't be used as a rationalization for putting someone into a coma, at least in this case.
 

Freshmaker

I am Korean.
lightless_shado said:
Maybe not as strong since we have this programming in us that makes us think that women are harmless and never hurt anyone whereas men are easily angered, obviously that's wrong as women some women can be as agressive as some men.
That's nice, but a woman's still going to lose out in strength pound for pound. Put a 100lb woman up against a 170lb man and the deck's even more stacked.
 

antonz

Member
Zeke said:
holy crap I didn't know you're part of girl-gaf double the shock considering the last thread we were in. I wonder if he will get out on self-defense if the video shows her swinging first.
I doubt he would get off scott free. Self Defense is not a blanket get out of jail free card. The man would have to prove his life was in danger or serious bodily harm was impending.

He clearly went above and beyond what the law states is a reasonable defense. It could very well be argued the man attempted to use deadly force against the woman considering the state of health she is in.
 
Devolution said:
I don't think people who get punched should be going into full on violent rages either. Self-defense shouldn't be used as a rationalization for putting someone into a coma, at least in this case.
I'm not saying she deserved to be put in a coma at all, and I seriously doubt that was the man's intention. I'm just saying that when you start a fight you have to accept a certain amount of fault for initiation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom