-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Digital Foundry: Gran Turismo 7 vs. Forza Motorsport (2023)
- Thread starter Insane Metal
- Start date
THE DUCK
voted poster of the decade by bots
If you need an hour long video back and forth saying one is better than the other in some ways, etc, they are both in the same general space/league. Both games actually look and play at a high level, excellent work by both teams.
blue velvet
Member
The signage is built from the ground up™. Good thing is, that typo could easily be fixed.
Last edited:
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
One is a next (current) gen only game. That is why, at least around here, this is a bigger deal than it would have otherwise been.
THE DUCK
voted poster of the decade by bots
Regardless of that, the two machines have proven to be similar in terms of raw power. Optimization will only get you so far, regardless of cross gen.
Last edited:
Turk1993
GAFs #1 source for car graphic comparisons
No, i have 200h in both games, don't need a reddit post to judge both games graphics. And i didn't say that the game was issue free, i said that they have improved the pc version alot since launch which is true.
Here the latest update with improved RTAO, RT reflections and materials.
Did you see some of the older tracks in GT7? You think that GT7 doesn't have quality issues? Did you see some of the gameplay lods in GT7? You can point out alot of issues in both games if you search on reddit or GTplanet. Sure Forza launched in a shitty state and was one of the worst launches from AAA studio. I have shat on them and pointed out lots of bugs and glitches it had at launch, but im also seeing some nice improvements they make with the latest patches. GT7 is far less glitchy/buggy which is true and i praised them for that.
Turk1993
GAFs #1 source for car graphic comparisons
This is the reason why FM is disappointing, it didn't have last gen console holding it back and they had enough time to "build it from the ground up".
Last edited:
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
Last edited:
TrebleShot
Member
They could have saved a lot of time and effort , for anyone that’s played both GT7 is better in every way by a considerable margin.
LiquidMetal14
hide your water-based mammals
Not bad for a 10tf console.
Hawking Radiation
Member
Polyphony Digital obsess over detail and it shows in their Gran Turismo games.
That pretty embarrassing for the forza studio, gt7 is a cross-game gen game and they were really going all in on the next gen standard-raising visuals of the new forza motorsport, and yet the sheer lack of polish is just disappointing. Past Forza games did much better overall in terms of polish and coherency...I would hope microsoft would let one of the few great major ips they have in hand to be polished to perfection.
Thick Thighs Save Lives
Gold Member
Just popping by to post in a soon to be legendary thread since I'm sure this will get to 50+ pages in the coming future lol.
Spitfire098
Member
Doubt it. When not only John, but the rest of the DF crew gave the nod to GT7 you must be seeing something that nobody else is seeing if you continue to argue FM > GT7.
Thick Thighs Save Lives
Gold Member
I'm not arguing about anything lol, it was just a lighthearted remark with no ill intention behind it.
Last edited:
Spitfire098
Member
I was more talking about those users who pushed the other thread to 50+ pages or whatever it was. I don't think it'll happen here as it'll just be a rehash of the same talking points.
Thick Thighs Save Lives
Gold Member
Ah, okay. You might be right on that. Didn't follow that thread too closely, tbh.
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
Too bad we can't use them outside photo mode.
Insane Metal
Gold Member
And RDNA 1.5
Clintizzle
Lord of Edge.
Does this come down to the capability of the console or the capability of the developers?
skit_data
Member
Not everything of course, but there is stuff like the dashboard lights and most of all the paint that applies to gameplay.
Quixz
Member
I blame the devs 100% this time since Forza Horizon 5 is a thing
BigLee74
Member
Has to be said, Forzas photo mode is horrendously bad and outdated, and shouldn’t be used as any basis for in game graphics comparisons - especially when zooming in when we all know it keeps LODs based on the initial camera position (refer to the tree that looks like a big leaf of lettuce).
Raw GT7 car models are unmatched, but have a significantly lower LOD in game. Maybe the PS5 Pro can improve that?
Raw GT7 car models are unmatched, but have a significantly lower LOD in game. Maybe the PS5 Pro can improve that?
freefornow
Member
Remind me again why we need a PS5 Pro?
BlitzerRadic
Member
Jesús.
TBF this isn't as bad as the comparison makes it look.
Those are style 67 rims and there are actually two variations 18" and 19". 18s on left and 19s on right and thats how they look IRL.
Neo_game
Member
They tried to be neutral and be nice to both games as expected. But honestly GT7 is a slightly improved GTS and Forza I think has made GT7 look relevant instead
I have already seen enough comparison from multiple sources but definitely they put some effort in this video. Not sure why they did not talk much about performance and resolution much. Forza TAA or whatever upscaling they are using is really poor, GT7 clearly looks much sharper. Another poor decision was to add to lights and trees, they even modelled tress wrong especially in Le mans that do not exist IRL
I have already seen enough comparison from multiple sources but definitely they put some effort in this video. Not sure why they did not talk much about performance and resolution much. Forza TAA or whatever upscaling they are using is really poor, GT7 clearly looks much sharper. Another poor decision was to add to lights and trees, they even modelled tress wrong especially in Le mans that do not exist IRL 
U n i o n 0015
Member
That's a fair response. I've definitely seen some improvements with Update 2 and 3, but what annoys me the most is that T10 is sitting on a build internally that they use to publish bullshots to social media on a constant basis, with LODs and sharpness that is simply not attainable on either PC or XSX.
GT7 has issues here and there, but you kind of have to go hunting for them. With FM8, they're right in your face, showing a complete lack of QA and polish.
(I should add, I think it was a HUGE mistake on T10's part to not offer MSAA. All of FM8's antialiasing options are substantially blurry in the mid-field--the place where you're almost constantly looking in a race. All the reasons they mentioned for switching AA methods in their Digital Foundry interview don't hold up under scrutiny).
Last edited:
Bogroll
Likes moldy games
Yes and the 18's look too small imo on the M3 IRL.
sncvsrtoip
Member
Surprised John and generaly DF chose winner (gt7) but imo thats better, there will be haters but it was so good and quite deep comparison.
Insane Metal
Gold Member
This is one of my favorite effects in Gran Turismo, the sun reflecting off the car
It looks exactly as it does to our eyes in real life.
It looks exactly as it does to our eyes in real life.
Turk1993
GAFs #1 source for car graphic comparisons
Forza has the same effect also if the sun angle matchesThis is one of my favorite effects in Gran Turismo, the sun reflecting off the car
It looks exactly as it does to our eyes in real life.
Insane Metal
Gold Member
Looks kinda fake with those 'points' resembling a star but better than no effect!Forza has the same effect also if the sun angle matches
Digity
Member
It still sucks. Far more racing games out there with way better AI that isn't being done with machine learning. Hell even the AI iracing added not too long ago is leagues ahead of anything GT has done. At least GT has stars in the night sky in the correct locations. /s
Turk1993
GAFs #1 source for car graphic comparisons
If you know a little about camera lenses than you know how it looks on a camera with small aperture (f8 to f22) to keep everything in focus. Forza tries to simulate a real camera, just like they do with the raindrops on the screen when its raining.
Insane Metal
Gold Member
I know about that. I just think it looks more like it is in real life in Gran Turismo. Don't worry.If you know a little about camera lenses than you know how it looks on a camera with small aperture (f8 to f22) to keep everything in focus. Forza tries to simulate a real camera, just like they do with the raindrops on the screen when its raining.
GHG
Gold Member
ShaiKhulud1989
Gold Member
One hour later, It still bugs me that T10 CEO was PROMOTED to lead all XBS after this disaster. Because T10 problems are not tech or even gameplay-related. It’s a stark lack of any sort of culture inside the studio. Almost every visual element in FM is simply half-backed, half-assed or just plain wrong. And many mistakes are carried over since FM4, ffs.
I swear Xbox HR is all about failing upwards.
I swear Xbox HR is all about failing upwards.
Ass of Can Whooping
Gold Member
This is one of my favorite effects in Gran Turismo, the sun reflecting off the car
It looks exactly as it does to our eyes in real life.
Truly encapsulates the divine radiance gracing the splendor of GT, as the sun's celestial glow bestows its benediction upon the masterpiece, while Forza languishes in the obscure penumbra of its overshadowed existence.
BbMajor7th
Gold Member
John lobbying hard for the 'both are good narrative' but let's be honest, Forza took a fucking bath there. GT's lighting and modelling is a world apart.
Crispy Gamer
Member
GT7 is almost 1:1 with the real life track while Forza takes a lot of liberty in adding stuff they obviously had different goals but I prefer the look of GT polyphony seems to obsess over the smallest detail I love stuff like that.
Similar threads
- Locked