• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

'Ugly girl': The negative messages we send to our daughters

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do you realize how many fantastic people have greatly contributed to the human race because people were assholes to them. Some people perserve, some people don't. Survival of the fittest is a natural law. How arrogant to suggest otherwise.

You're mistaken, people persevered in spite of them not because of them.


This is the kind of bullshit that we should be fighting against. Natural beauty and fitness being distorted by fake lighting and photoshop into levels of perfection that are truly unattainable.

And I didn't know those stats about plus sized models, thanks for the info. I was more talking about the "big is beautiful" campaigns you occasionally see around.

There was a 14 yr old who successfully lobbied Seventeen to cut that shit with a petition.
 
Do you realize how many fantastic people have greatly contributed to the human race because people were assholes to them. Some people perserve, some people don't. Survival of the fittest is a natural law. How arrogant to suggest otherwise.
Oh dear, a social darwinist.
 

joe2187

Banned
Do you realize how many fantastic people have greatly contributed to the human race because people were assholes to them. Some people perserve, some people don't. Survival of the fittest is a natural law. How arrogant to suggest otherwise.

See...the world is filled with three types of people...
 
inspiration behind

rJ79u.jpg

...How is that hat staying on his head?
 

WanderingWind

Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
It's really not. It's nothing like it in fact.

Yeah. Yeah, it really, really is. Maybe there aren't hoards of boys feeling bad because they're not pretty enough, but you think teen boys don't go through the same feelings regarding their looks, athletic abilities, etc?

It's not like this is a pie of pain that we need to divvy up and decide who eats it more. Life sucks at that age, and yeah, if you were born ugly chances are your life will face challenges beautiful people will not. It sucks, but it can hardly be disputed.
 
right, because boys learn to take it and become men. we didnt have campaigns telling us our weak lungs were ok, just had treadmills

Boys have their own issues. If you honestly think men are judged on an equivalent level (notice I didn't say not at all) as women, you haven't seen much media.
 

daw840

Member
Boys have their own issues. If you honestly think men are judged on an equivalent level (notice I didn't say not at all) as women, you haven't seen much media.

Does this really have to turn into a "we have it worse than them" type of debate? Because that could go on forever with no resolution...
 

Platy

Member
I mean it's the same for boys. Pressure pressure pressure.

I googled "ugly actors" and google gave me 2 imdb lists
xkpLM.png


First one is :

2iA9X.jpg
eDRry.jpg
v0h64.jpg
uWFlk.jpg
gkdId.jpg
DP0v9.jpg
gnRCH.jpg


Anyone who call any of those ugly is suffering from "sharp knees" syndrome (I MIGHT understand Tilda Swilton .. not everyone is fan of androngynous looks)

second list has :

i74br.jpg
AS8Vl.jpg
Dj8fy.jpg
kqQ02.jpg
fw3Be.jpg
BDf2V.jpg
8RgDE.jpg
BqTK0.jpg
jiYym.jpg
Dx8ap.jpg
BhsAf.jpg
zKXcR.jpg


This list makes more sense ... but see the amount of girls in the list .. also LOL at Paris Hilton/Olsen/Miley Cyrus
 
Does this really have to turn into a "we have it worse than them" type of debate? Because that could go on forever with no resolution...

I didn't start that debate. Once again "what about the boys/men" comes in. I've already talked about how their issues are worse on some levels. Beauty is less of an issue, I'd say trying to conform to outdated masculine ideals is the real stinker for them.
 
Does this really have to turn into a "we have it worse than them" type of debate? Because that could go on forever with no resolution...
Yes, GAF bylaws dictate that all gender threads devolve into a pissing contest.
I didn't start that debate. Once again "what about the boys/men" comes in. I've already talked about how their issues are worse on some levels. Beauty is less of an issue, I'd say trying to conform to outdated masculine ideals is the real stinker for them.
To be fair, you can phrase the beauty issue as, "trying to conform to outdated feminine ideals."
 

Trey

Member
I would all of them

dove-models-real-beauty.jpg

None of these women are fat, or misshapen. This is a healthy size. The mean. All those curves are actually attractive.

I observe this shit every day. Young kids (8-14) tearing each other down, always, over hair and clothes and looks. It only gets worse as they get older. Their sense of self worth is tied to material things, and self centered attitudes are nurtured by a world which only cares about the way you look right then, at that moment, and not the experiences which made you the person you are today.
 

Platy

Member
those are beautiful men

why are they ugly in your eyes? why dont they have a campaign?

Some of those fail at bilateral symmetry ... but MOST if not all fit in the "I would not say WOW if I saw a dude like him on the street" .. 3 of those men are even bigger than the big campain image

I would be close to betting that if you took any 2 of that first list you would still not match the weight of the average gaffer =P

edit :
Well I think the first mistake is responding to lunch box.

I'm sorry =(
 

Atrus

Gold Member
You're overestimating the power of parents to make sure their kids don't fall into these traps. I had pretty good parents when it comes to this but the idea that you're failing in the looks department is very pervasive. We are constantly bombarded with it. Even if you manage to evade it at home and from the media, you have classmates and you'll see firsthand how many perks other girls (or boys) retain being more primped and pretty.

Then you parents were simply not sufficient enough. Parents play a significant role, the significant role, in how prepared children are for life both literally and philosophically.

It is not about evasion, it is about succeeding and overcoming. It should have been your parents place to give you a platform for life that is more trusted than that of strangers. Parenting is hard work, the measure of which reflects on the greatness of their children.

It is not and should never be the responsibility of the rest of society to raise you. It does not owe you one iota of contentment or happiness and this dependency will only raise a perpetual victim.
 
But those are the best ones!

I know! Hence me wanting some but I'm just a po' student right now though. Plus the cheaper ones are so bad on the inside too.


Then you parents were simply not sufficient enough. Parents play a significant role, the significant role, in how prepared children are for life both literally and philosophically.

It is not about evasion, it is about succeeding and overcoming. It should have been your parents place to give you a platform for life that is more trusted than that of strangers. Parenting is hard work, the measure of which reflects on the greatness of their children.

It is not and should never be the responsibility of the rest of society to raise you. It does not owe you one iota of contentment or happiness and this dependency will only raise a perpetual victim.

Who said anything about happiness? I'm talking about bombardment of imagery and standards held up by a society. If we do not actively fight to have them in the realm of realistic portrayals it negatively affects teenagers and causes them to harm themselves either in dietary measures or physically when they don't measure up. I don't know how you can honestly say that parents input alone will keep the pressure off. It's naive when ironically you're arguing the opposite.
 

Data West

coaches in the WNBA
If those were all men in that image, wouldn't the majority of people call them fat/out of shape? You see, curves are appealing on women to most men. Are they on men?
 

Lunchbox

Banned
If those were all men in that image, wouldn't the majority of people call them fat/out of shape? You see, curves are appealing on women to most men. Are they on men?

listen girl its ok to be fat, have curves, NATURAL curves!

Ron perlman? michael sera? ugly ass fat motherfuckers. dont they know men are just born with a great figure
 
I know people hate the "guys get this too" argument, but it's true. I think women should stop caring about how they look so much. Guys don't think you're attractive? So what. I'm sure most girls don't find me attractive and it's never bugged me before.
 

Atrus

Gold Member
Who said anything about happiness? I'm talking about bombardment of imagery and standards held up by a society. If we do not actively fight to have them in the realm of realistic portrayals it negatively affects teenagers and causes them to harm themselves either in dietary measures or physically when they don't measure up. I don't know how you can honestly say that parents input alone will keep the pressure off. It's naive when ironically you're arguing the opposite.

The issue is about raising people so easily malleable by people who intentionally try to exploit them. No amount of banning and controlling this or that will solve an issue of individual insecurity, you're simply changing the manner in which others will exploit an ever-willing victim.
 

Shouta

Member
Then you parents were simply not sufficient enough. Parents play a significant role, the significant role, in how prepared children are for life both literally and philosophically.

It is not about evasion, it is about succeeding and overcoming. It should have been your parents place to give you a platform for life that is more trusted than that of strangers. Parenting is hard work, the measure of which reflects on the greatness of their children.

It is not and should never be the responsibility of the rest of society to raise you. It does not owe you one iota of contentment or happiness and this dependency will only raise a perpetual victim.

The influence a parent has on a child is highly dependent on the society. The higher the power distance a country has, the more likely a child will absorb the information that is being transmitted from a parent. The social dynamics of a country like the US allows the society to affect children in spite of good parenting.
 

Platy

Member
I disagree with a lot of those. Most of those people aren't genuinely ugly at all. /shrug

I was talking about a binary definition of beautiful/ugly ..... those are totaly normal men. The other ones are NOT normal women.

Those are far from actualy ugly men, but they are NOT what you think when you think "handsome men"

It is not OMFG IMPOSSIBLE to achieve a Jack Black or Zach Galifinafianakis look ... but if you were not born with enoght genes, you CAN'T be the next Eva Green or Angelina Jolie
 

WanderingWind

Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
I was talking about a binary definition of beautiful/ugly ..... those are totaly normal men. The other ones are NOT normal women.

Those are far from actualy ugly men, but they are NOT what you think when you think "handsome men"

It is not OMFG IMPOSSIBLE to achieve a Jack Black or Zach Galifinafianakis look ... but if you were not born with enoght genes, you CAN'T be the next Eva Green or Angelina Jolie

...can't really be Brad Pitt or [insert some dude who women consider hot, I'm totally behind on these sorts of things] without the same assist from the genetic lottery.

It really does suck for everybody.
 
That is definitely a check in the "con" column for y'all.

It has its uses.


The issue is about raising people so easily malleable by people who intentionally try to exploit them. No amount of banning and controlling this or that will solve an issue of individual insecurity, you're simply changing the manner in which others will exploit an ever-willing victim.

There is no overt exploitation in a lot of cases, it's a bombardment of teasing and ridicule. In order to make these things stop they look to what's being cast in a positive light and try to emulate that. If the standards are ridiculous they never measure up and are always insecure. Even good parenting cannot stop bullying at the source but better and more realistic standards can be displayed rather than the current trend of digitally anorexic and photoshopped models. No one is asking for or entitled to a "happier" culture just that the media not reflect impossible standards and bombard people with that imagery.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom