• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Phil Spencer: Still have flagship games in development; "new IP critical"

Toa Freak

Neo Member
My personal opinion is halo is being annualized.

2011 = H1a
2012 = halo 4
2013 = console transition (aka not enough x1s to justify cost)
2014 = h2a
2015 = Halo 5
2016 = H3a
2017 = Halo 6
2018 = reach or odst or h4 anniversary?

2013 would be Spartan Assault. You could have yearly Halo games without them all being major console titles. I am heavily against a H2A so soon, but a Halo 3 Anniversary should never happen, at least not in this decade.
 
They are committed to exclusive games imo.

In other words, water is wet. All platform holders with first- studios are naturally commited to exclusive games. :/

Let's be fair, it's very difficult to know at this point of time, how committed the respective companies are towards new IPs.

One would be forgiven to assume MS is kings of new IP development at the first 3 years of the Xbox 360, but things change, stuff break and Kinects was sold, so you know... things turned out differently compared to the bright future that the 360 had.
 

beast786

Member
Lol, and calling it "Halo on Xbox One" instead of "Halo 5" is a marketing genius idea too, right?
Obviously they are trying to hide the identity of the game.

What?

because the "title " of the "next game" was not set. Do we need a new title for a port?

you guys are crazy if you think they were hyping on an old port by setting up a disappointed of a year delay of new halo true next gen game. Seriously. that would be GTA teasing , hey New GTA at the end of the year guys with all the bells and whistle with 60fps, and then reveal nay it's just GTA2 port............. SURPRIZE
 

beast786

Member
Lol, and calling it "Halo on Xbox One" instead of "Halo 5" is a marketing genius idea too, right?
Obviously they are trying to hide the identity of the game.

What?

because the "title " of the "next game" was not set. Do we need a new title for a port?

you guys are crazy if you think they were hyping on an old port by setting up a disappointed of a year delay of new halo true next gen game. Seriously. that would be GTA teasing , hey New GTA at the end of the year guys with all the bells and whistle with 60fps, and then reveal nay it's just GTA2 port............. SURPRIZE

Not necessarily; the original Crackdown included access to the Halo 3 beta, but that beta didn't actually start until like 4 months after Crackdown launched, iirc.

there is a big difference between 4 months and 12 months
 
If I remember correctly Ryse actually sold quite well, taken at face value it was a solid launch title; however, it could've used much more variation as stated by many.

We have no stats to prove how well it has sold.

All numbers has shown Ryse to be underperforming quite a bit compared compared to Forza/DR3, and we know DR3 shipped a million as of last month.

Besides, for a new IP, one would guess that MS/Crytek would like to tout the million benchmark if it was achieved, but that hasn't happened.
 

imtehman

Banned
Sounds like the Xbox One is going to be a serious Halo, Gears and Forza churning machine lol. With the odd bit of Fable thrown in.

The Black Tusk new IP was the best first party entry in the mix, shame they put that to rest.

with a lot of new ips mixed. Go figure right, making sequels of franchises that are known to sell and having new ips to boot? what a unique business move that is
 

RoKKeR

Member
I really like the Fall lineup. H2A, Forza Horizon 2, Quantum Break, Sunset Overdrive...I don't see how anybody can brush all of those exclusives aside, not to mention anything else we haven't heard about yet.

New IP, established franchises, it's the mix I was expecting and it looks like we'll be getting it.

Still very unconvinced on the whole Halp 3/4 HD ports, I just don't see how that fits in.
 

tfur

Member
I had no idea the new halo was delayed. Is this just a rumor or something real? I suppose having your principle engine architect jump ship might affect things.
 

jem0208

Member
I had no idea the new halo was delayed. Is this just a rumor or something real? I suppose having your principle engine architect jump ship might affect things.

Well, if ntkrnl is legit (and he's been confirmed by bish so...) then yes this is probably something real.


Also she wasn't the principle engine architect. She worked on tools. (I'm guesing you're referring to Corinne Yu?)
 

ironcreed

Banned
Time to quote one of my favourite CBOAT posts:

predator_duck_hunt.gif
 

beast786

Member
as per MS. New IP discussion.


It is a fact that MS have shown plenty of diverse new IP for XB1. you can't argue with that fact. but, the problem some have is those are paid 3rd party support that usually dies mid to end of console life cycle as they become to expensive to money hat. 1st party is what set the console apart. here sony has done a good Job of creating these new IP by its first party that doesn't need to be money hat at the mid/end console years. that is why you see new IP by sony constant while also milking core franchise.

MS do need to change that image about there first party and people believed black tusk game was exactly that. 1st party studio with new IP. And by canceling that they literally ignited the old fears again that first party that carry console in 2nd half would again just recycle old IP and again xb1 will dry out on exclusives new IP on 2nd half of its life span
 
How many copies did Ryse sell? I still think it gets a sequel.

It should. The game was flawed in arguably many ways but the core elements where still full and it had very nice production value. It has a lot of potential to expand on the universe and fix the problems they had on a sequel. To me it was the most surprising game of the launch titles pretty much based on the fact that every other title was hyped to death and under delivered and this one was getting a ton of flack and turned out to be alright.
 

jem0208

Member
My personal opinion is halo is being annualized.

2011 = H1a
2012 = halo 4
2013 = console transition (aka not enough x1s to justify cost)
2014 = h2a
2015 = Halo 5
2016 = H3a
2017 = Halo 6
2018 = reach or odst or h4 anniversary?


I can't see Halo 3 getting an Anniversary remake. Especially if it is actually ported to the X1. I also can't see them releasing a mainline Halo 2 years after the release of Halo 5. I wouldn't be surprised if we saw another spin off ala ODST (which is fine by me, I loved ODST) or something similar to bridge the gap between mainline titles.
 

tfur

Member
Well, if ntkrnl is legit (and he's been confirmed by bish so...) then yes this is probably something real.


Also she wasn't the principle engine architect. She worked on tools. (I'm guesing you're referring to Corinne Yu?)

I was just going by the Wiki saying she was hired as such.

If she ended up working on tools, I can see why she left.
 

Chitown B

Member
LIST WARS!

I have a list...the only list that matters.


WHERE ARE THE GODDAMN SEQUELS/REBOOTS?

Hell, at least a dozen from that list would be new IP for a whole generation of gamers. Do something with them, Microsoft. Spend some of that $1b on hiring some third party studios to work on those fantastic IP.

Jesus Christ...

Banjo Kazooie - Banjo Tooie
Conker - Conker: Live and Reloaded
Perfect Dark - Perfect Dark Zero
Crackdown - Crackdown 2
ilomilo - studio went bust
Ninety Nine Nights - N3: Ninety Nine Nights II
Viva Pinata - Viva Pinata trouble in paradise
 

JaggedSac

Member
If I remember correctly Ryse actually sold quite well, taken at face value it was a solid launch title; however, it could've used much more variation as stated by many.

Yep, variation definitely would have helped. I, personally, am hoping they are moving ahead with a sequel. Add the ability to switch primary weapons, add some more stat building, add some more visual differences to equipment on your online character, etc.
 

imtehman

Banned
Knowing target dates is no megaton. now if he actually said some cool stuff about the game then I can understand the hype.

The fact this leak was so clean to reveal nothing yet still creat hype and awareness was and is sounds like plant.

The biggest news was delay of halo 5 to 2015 when all of us thought it was coming this year because MS hinted. Yet now that bad bomb shell was drop and no one even cares.

you were wrong beast, just move on to the next battle and let it go
 

ironcreed

Banned
It should. The game was flawed in arguably many ways but the core elements where still full and it had very nice production value. It has a lot of potential to expand on the universe and fix the problems they had on a sequel. To me it was the most surprising game of the launch titles pretty much based on the fact that every other title was hyped to death and under delivered and this one was getting a ton of flack and turned out to be alright.

It's obvious just from looking at it that it has a great foundation to be built upon. No way should they throw in the towel, considering what it could be with proper time and attention. Can't wait to try it.
 

Codewar

Neo Member
there is a big difference between 4 months and 12 months

Um, right- point is that the Halo 3 beta started 4 months after Crackdown released, ran for a month (or whatever) and then Halo 3 launched about 5 months after that.

So Halo 5 wouldn't necessarily be launching a year after the beta if they follow a similar roadmap.
 

JaggedSac

Member
I was just going by the Wiki saying she was hired as such.

If she ended up working on tools, I can see why she left.

Stinklez has come in several times to say she worked on the dev tools. Granted, I am sure that is a very important part of a games development.
 

Chitown B

Member
My personal opinion is halo is being annualized.

2011 = H1a
2012 = halo 4
2013 = console transition (aka not enough x1s to justify cost)
2014 = h2a
2015 = Halo 5
2016 = H3a
2017 = Halo 6
2018 = reach or odst or h4 anniversary?

Halo 3 came out 2007. So why would 2006 be the 10th anniversary release? I don't think it'll happen - it was already on the newer system, as opposed to H1/2 on the original Xbox.

NO one wants a Reach remake or needs an ODST remake (love ODST though).
 

Chitown B

Member
So getting an old old port of a game you already can get is megaton but getting your absolute new game from same franchise delayed a year is not a "big deal" .. Ok bro.

You cannot play Halo 2 on Xbox over live anymore. Which is the only reason people play H2.
 

beast786

Member
Um, right- point is that the Halo 3 beta started 4 months after Crackdown released, ran for a month (or whatever) and then Halo 3 launched about 5 months after that.

So Halo 5 wouldn't necessarily be launching a year after the beta if they follow a similar roadmap.


He said the beta will be in November of 2014 with 6-8 maps I believe and game will launch 2015 November .

that is 12 month gap between start of beta and the game. totally different from your example.
 

ironcreed

Banned
Talking about 2016 in January of 2014 and complaining that MS won't have new IPs then is such an utterly absurd thing to say.

Nah, they should announce everything they ever plan to release up until around 2019 or so. You know, just to be safe. But even then, that might not be enough.
 
It's obvious just from looking at it that it has a great foundation to be built upon. No way should they throw in the towel, considering what it could be with proper time and attention. Can't wait to try it.

When you do, play on hard from the get go. The gameplay is waaay more satisfying when you gotta use all of the of the games mechanics to crowd control and stay alive.
 

Omega

Banned
Quantum Break, Titanfall (though I do have a pc), and possibly Sunset Overdrive excite me. The rest is cool. I'll buy h2a,ill definitely get forza horizon 2, my interest in crackdown 3 is down after crackdown 2 but I'll give it a look for sure. But like many have said, these leaks are pretty vanilla. Good games, I'll buy them, but nothing holy shit inducing.



My personal opinion is halo is being annualized.

2011 = H1a
2012 = halo 4
2013 = console transition (aka not enough x1s to justify cost)
2014 = h2a
2015 = Halo 5
2016 = H3a
2017 = Halo 6
2018 = reach or odst or h4 anniversary?

Halo 3 Anniversary would have to happen in 2017, since it came out in 2007 and fits with the CEA and H2A (rumored) release of 10 years.

HALO WARS 2 = 2016! #BELIEVE
 

Bsigg12

Member
Halo 3 came out 2007. So why would 2006 be the 10th anniversary release? I don't think it'll happen - it was already on the newer system, as opposed to H1/2 on the original Xbox.

NO one wants a Reach remake or needs an ODST remake (love ODST though).

I think we'll get spinoff games like ODST instead of just HD editions of older games. I know they want to continue to expand the universe and there is literally an infinite amount of stories they could come up with that doesn't involve the Chief.
 
Neither company has a huge hit on their hands unless Sony gets uncharted out. I do agree that sales aside (which, seriously, fuck sales bickering) that what we know as of now has more exclusives I want to play on the xb1 than the ps4. Which was also true of this launch, imo.


Sony has an absolutely jam packed 2015 but getting there they are going to have to lean really heavy on stronger multiplats and indies.

Sony has DriveClub, Planetside2 and Infamous for the first half.
When is DeepDown coming?

vs. Titanfall, Kinect Sports Rivals and PvZ on Micrsofts side.

Thats pretty even I'd say. Even slightly better on Sonys side if you ask me.


Second half is Halo Anniversary 2, Quantum Break, Sunset Overdrive and Forza Horizon on MS side.

Only TheOrder1886 on Sony side now.
Do you think Sony will announce more stuff for that time? They better have more...
 

beast786

Member
You cannot play Halo 2 on Xbox over live anymore. Which is the only reason people play H2.


so you believe they were hyping halo 2 port by making everyone believe instead it was next new next gen halo?

you think that sounds like a great surprise for mass of people who bought XB1 for teased new halo game coming this November.?
 
so you believe they were hyping halo 2 port by making everyone believe instead it was next new next gen halo?

you think that sounds like a great surprise for mass of people who bought XB1 for teased new halo game coming this November.?

I don't think you understand Halo very well. After Halo 4, more Halo fans would rather play Halo 2 HD than Halo 5.
 

Prine

Banned
so you believe they were hyping halo 2 port by making everyone believe instead it was next new next gen halo?

you think that sounds like a great surprise for mass of people who bought XB1 for teased new halo game coming this November.?

Yeah, Halo 2 is renown for having the best multiplayer in the series, a new Halo 5 beta packed in is enough to quench that thirst.

But wow, what a 2014 lineup they have, going all out with games.
 
And its pretty obvious why it was barren, they were focusing on Kinect for 360 and gearing up for new franchises and partnerships on the Xbox One of which we're already seeing what they have coming. We also saw them publish games like State of Decay, they did plenty of new stuff on XBLA.

Lionhead, Twisted Pixel, Press Play, we know they're on new IPs. They've said new IP is critical: Sunset Overdrive, D4, Quantum Break, Project Spark all this year (based on current leaks). They've put a lot of investment in to new IPs, Ryse, Crimson Dragon, Powerstar Golf at XBO launch. I see no reason as yet to doubt that they're committed to new IPs on Xbox One.

Also Mort, if you wanted a 2013 Halo game, you could count Spartan Assault.

That excuse just doesn't fly, Sony has three consoles to support and they still managed to put a ton of new IPs, even in 2013. This is MS' third gen, they aren't the new kid on the block anymore
 

Chitown B

Member
so you believe they were hyping halo 2 port by making everyone believe instead it was next new next gen halo?

you think that sounds like a great surprise for mass of people who bought XB1 for teased new halo game coming this November.?

I think it's a great surprise, and makes sense since they refuse to call it Halo 5. It's part of a transition to Halo 5 if the beta is included with it. And I'd much rather H5 be 2015 so they get time to beta test the shit out of it with feedback. Because H4 was a disappointment.

That's not true. The campaign was awesome, if a little rushed. I think I must have spent 5+ hours getting the scarab gun and giant football. That was a fun day.

Campaign cannot be played over Live, which was the problem. Halo is meant to be played co-op for maximum fun.
 

Chettlar

Banned
Quantum Break, Titanfall (though I do have a pc), and possibly Sunset Overdrive excite me. The rest is cool. I'll buy h2a,ill definitely get forza horizon 2, my interest in crackdown 3 is down after crackdown 2 but I'll give it a look for sure. But like many have said, these leaks are pretty vanilla. Good games, I'll buy them, but nothing holy shit inducing.



My personal opinion is halo is being annualized.

2011 = H1a
2012 = halo 4
2013 = console transition (aka not enough x1s to justify cost)
2014 = h2a
2015 = Halo 5
2016 = H3a
2017 = Halo 6
2018 = reach or odst or h4 anniversary?




That's rad if you like halo. To me that's... well, I'll buy them but not at full price.





I'm more of excited short term. PvZ:GW looks awesome. Project Spark looks awesome. Titanfall obviously looks awesome.

It is rad if you like Halo, and I like Halo, but why would Halo 3 need a remaster? I don't like the art style all that much personally, but really it's only issue was water tessellation quality (was such a cool effect, but it could look odd at times), resolution (and AA), and framerate.

Some upped resolution with AA, 60 fps, and higher res textures (and I really hope an HD remake of whatever sort doesn't get rid of the water tesselation) are really mostly all it needs. I don't think it really needs a complete rehaul like Halo 2.

And while I can see an annualization happening, I don't expect it. I think we're more likely to get something like Halo Wars 2 in 2016 than Halo 3A if anything (especially since that's not even the anniversary anyway).
 
I don't think you understand Halo very well. After Halo 4, more Halo fans would rather play Halo 2 HD than Halo 5.

There is no way H2A sells anywhere near what a full fledged Halo title would. It's great for the hardcore Halo fans but for the general public, they'll just see it as a game they played 10 years ago.
 
Top Bottom