el_colibri
Member
Arya in the books has been also called "Arya Horseface" due to her lanky figure and gaunt face. That said, Maisie Williams is amazing playing her!
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Actors/Actresses in "Born to Play" Roles
- Thread starter digitalrelic
- Start date
- Status
Arya in the books has been also called "Arya Horseface" due to her lanky figure and gaunt face. That said, Maisie Williams is amazing playing her!
Really. These you think these dudes were born to play these roles?
Who the hell are ANY of these people?
And:
One of those people has almost been acting since Ford was born.
If you have gotten your perfect role, why else do you need another one?
spazchicken
Member
el_colibri
Member
You know... you're right. He's not a great actor, but I couldn't see anyone else playing Riddick.
Also, for better or for worse:
I'm not a big fan of the film but he truly personalized the role.
Yup. Riddick is an amazing character and such a badass. Vin Diesel plays him well I think but his acting skills aren't exactly great hahaha.
Forrest Gump couldn't be anyone else, you're 100% right!
Soapbox Killer
Grand Nagus
Linda Hamilton as Sarah Conor
The_Hitcher89
Member
Clint Eastwood as Roland Deschain kind of but not really
Linda Hamilton as Sarah Conor
To this day my favorite female character in movie history. Just look how fucking badass she looks. To me, that particular picture is the archetype of "strong, badass woman".
QuantumZebra
Member
Arnold as Conan
Bruce Willis as John McClane
Signorey Weaver as Ripley
Professor X
All of these.
David Suchet as Poirot. Embraced the part so much to the extent that he's filmed the entire canon over 25 years.
Tom Nook
Member
CopperPuppy
Member
Keanu Reeves and Alex Winter as Bill and Ted:
Matthew Broderick as Ferris Bueller:
Really, the whole main trio of that movie.
In a perfect future, Rosamund Pike as Jessica Atreides.
Matthew Broderick as Ferris Bueller:
Really, the whole main trio of that movie.
In a perfect future, Rosamund Pike as Jessica Atreides.
Please, someone make this happen.
DiipuSurotu
Banned
Crispin Glover as George McFly (Back to the Future)
Jim Carrey as Joel Barish (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind)
Megadragon15
Member
Linda Carter as Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (although she would've made a good 'Linda Carter Student Nurse' if Marvel was using a live action version of her during the 1970s).
Arnold as Conan
I have to disagree with this one, as much as I love Arnold and his first Conan movie. Conan is supposed to be as intelligent as he is beefy, which really doesn't come across in Arnold's portrayal. Also, there's the whole accent thing...
Captainbojanglesiii
Banned
Sam Worthington as John Mclane son
Underrated post
Shelley Duvall as Olive Oyl in Popeye.
Pretty sure Robert Altman sold it to her on the fact she was born to play the role, in fact.
Bingo. She was perfect for that role.
Vigilant Walrus
Member
O'Shea Jackson, Jr., literally is born to play his Dad.
Besides the pun on this, I have to say. Friends told me that they were disappointed that there was not more emphasis on Easy-E's character and there was too much Dre.
I won't say I disagree with it and I think Easy was the best character (thematically) but I was just so blown away by this kid.
It would be so hard to nail Ice Cube because he is the king of "resting bitch face" and his son portrays him EXACTLY like that, but at the same time, he knows how to act with his eyes.
He completely sold me. Insane performance!
Mariah Carey
Member
"Born to play" probably means something different to different people, but to me it's best exemplified when you have an existing character and you hear someone's name associated with it and you just think "YES". It's not so much about an actor transforming him or herself as it is their public persona already fitting a certain role.
So, for instance, while Heath Ledger did an amazing job and arguably even best job of playing the Joker, I wouldn't say he was 'born to play it'. That'd be something more along the lines of Jack Nicholson, which had most people nodding along in agreement and going "oh, yes, yes" when first hearing of his casting.
One example I think that never actually came to pass was Gillian Andersen as Clarice Starling. Now, I don't actually think she'd necessarily do the best job of playing the part, but it fits so well with her resume that it almost makes too much sense. All she'd pretty much have to do is put on a southern accent and she's good to go. In fact, she apparently lobbied for the part in Hannibal and one of the reasons she didn't get it was her role in the X-Files was too similar.
This one might well be the best example in the thread yet. Hell, it would not surprise me if the reason they even MADE a Flinstones movie in the first place was John Goodman was around to play Fred.
Another:
So, for instance, while Heath Ledger did an amazing job and arguably even best job of playing the Joker, I wouldn't say he was 'born to play it'. That'd be something more along the lines of Jack Nicholson, which had most people nodding along in agreement and going "oh, yes, yes" when first hearing of his casting.
One example I think that never actually came to pass was Gillian Andersen as Clarice Starling. Now, I don't actually think she'd necessarily do the best job of playing the part, but it fits so well with her resume that it almost makes too much sense. All she'd pretty much have to do is put on a southern accent and she's good to go. In fact, she apparently lobbied for the part in Hannibal and one of the reasons she didn't get it was her role in the X-Files was too similar.
Also as Fred Flintsone
This one might well be the best example in the thread yet. Hell, it would not surprise me if the reason they even MADE a Flinstones movie in the first place was John Goodman was around to play Fred.
Another:
I'm surprised there hasn't been a remake of Psycho yet with Andrew Garfield as Norman.
Yeah, "born to play" means "their real life personality/appearance is a perfect fit for this character". You can't just retroactively fit the title on an actor just because they did a great job on a character.
dapperbandit
Banned
King Theoden as played by Bernard Hill. Often overlooked, the character has some of the best quotes of the trilogy and the nuances of his character are subtly but effectively captured by Hill.
Davos Seaworth as played by Liam Cunningham. Dude captures the stubborn loyalty of the Onion Knight perfectly.
mechashiva
Member
I couldn't see anyone else as Hit Girl.
Mariah Carey
Member
Oh yeah, this is the same point I was trying to make earlier and missed this.
Like, Meryl Streep is an amazing actress but the entire reason she gets accolades is that she can completely disappear into a role. What amazed people about The Iron Lady is that she pulled it off even though she was absolutely NOT born to play Margaret Thatcher, she's nothing like her.
(I'm not trying to start an argument with anyone or discourage anyone's picks, just wanna get a discuss what it means for someone to be "born to play" a part).
JinjoUnchained
Member
For better or worse, the doctor from The Human Centipede.
mechashiva
Member
Bruce Campbell as Ash
I'd argue that Chris Evans was born to be the Human Torch but then became a great Cap.
I'd argue that Chris Evans was born to be the Human Torch but then became a great Cap.
In the meantime, we at least had a decent live action GeraltStill waiting for my Witcher movie starring Mads.
bootsthecat
Banned
I know it's not a movie, but it should be
Mariah Carey
Member
Argh, forgot to mention that a role Meryl Streep would be "born to play" would have to be like a master of disguise or shape shifter or something.
Jason's Ultimatum
Member
Matt Damon as Jason Bourne.
Mariah Carey
Member
In a less flattering example, this almost felt like someone on the production was trying to make a meta-joke or something:
ShadowSwordmaster
Banned
O'Shea Jackson, Jr., literally is born to play his Dad.
I was surprised on how well he acted in that movie.
LegendofDragoonLives
Member
He's fantastic in the TV show Chuck, and a major reason why his time in it the series was at its absolute best.
Jay Shadow
Member
Rami Malek as Elliot on Mr Robot
I mean he's even wearing his own hoodie on the show, so his look is almost as important as the acting. The show was dead in the water at the casting stage until he showed up.
I mean he's even wearing his own hoodie on the show, so his look is almost as important as the acting. The show was dead in the water at the casting stage until he showed up.
- Status