I think anyone that thinks they qualified for the promo with a ~$95 purchase might want to re-check their order confirmation. Otherwise I could see a lot of unhappy buyers thinking they got the promo when they didn't.
Wow, that's totally weird. I double checked all my orders just to be sure and I didn't have that problem, like my Yakuza 0 & Nier Automata preorder came out to:
$95.98 with GC discount before tax ($47.99 x2)
My order status shows the order total being $77.02 with tax ($38.51 x2) after the $24 discount
and each game when you take the tax out comes to $35.99
I wonder if the offer was glitched for some people and not others, strange