-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Colin Trevorrow Exits Episode 9
- Thread starter ryan299
- Start date
AlexFlame116
Member
Calm down everyone. We all have our different opinions of the Star Wars saga. There is no true list of "best" to "not as good as the others" Star Wars movies.
ryutaro's mama
Member
I'm calm.
I just don't understand when someone goes through the trouble of making it as clear as they can that it is a personal opinion, that somehow must still be kneejerk defended against by citing irrelevant data.
Maybe I should bold it all in red next time.
Yes x100.
AlexFlame116
Member
So you're including R1 and the sequel trilogy in that beyond?
If you were calm you would have ignored his post and kept at it.
Nevertheless it isn't my place to correct you so my apologies.
EDIT: Then again Surfinn is still bringing it up.
ryutaro's mama
Member
No one is talking to you atm.
It is possible to be annoyed while calm.
You're just casually still bitching about something I posted and clarified literally like 5 or 6 times.
Astral Dog
Member
Quality Concerns 😰
AlexFlame116
Member
So Star Wars guys! I can't wait for IX!
Sigh...it's also possible to ignore it and be calm.
Subpar Spatula
Banned
dayuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuum
well time go watch my japanese cartoons and reflect on my life choices
BronsonLee
Member
AlexFlame116
Member
BronsonLee would probably call it Episode IX: The Fast and The Wookieous.
ryutaro's mama
Member
Naw.
You're a Philly guy repping the Vikes.
I don't even know what to do with that information.
Just because you echo the plot points of a movie doesn't mean you "get it," not that I think JJ doesn't get Star Wars. JJ did a great job creating likable new characters but he took shortcuts, just like he did with the Star Trek movies.
It would have been nice to have a movie that wasn't about blowing up a space station.
I'll watch that.
A Star Wars thread without at least 3 fights is considered a dull affair.
I have the same problem when ever I discuss how mediocre Avatar is.
AlexFlame116
Member
Sure you say that NOW, but wait til we get to Episode XVII: The Fate of the Wookieous.
Am-am I allowed to use bolded words???
BronsonLee
Member
I'd work really hard on it, I swear. It'd be unlike any other Star Wars movie because I would have it entirely on the Enterprise this time
Speed kills.
So does space.
That the Eagles are trash and I've been ride or die with the Vikes since I was 10
Warm Machine
Member
There are very few directors out there I'd give this to. I think CT would have made an alright movie. I still think Favreau is the best choice for Star Wars. He gets fun and uses iconic imagery beautifully and understates it.
Too many directors out there have too much of their own style and it is distracting to Star Wars. I enjoyed Rogue One but Gareth Edwards kept using lenses with really shallow depth of field what is not in the style of Star Wars.
You can't put Fincher, Dennis, Edgar Wright, or other personality based filmmakers in this role. They have to know how to disappear and serve the story first.
Too many directors out there have too much of their own style and it is distracting to Star Wars. I enjoyed Rogue One but Gareth Edwards kept using lenses with really shallow depth of field what is not in the style of Star Wars.
You can't put Fincher, Dennis, Edgar Wright, or other personality based filmmakers in this role. They have to know how to disappear and serve the story first.
Claude Augario
Member
What the hell happened in here?
WhiteRabbitEXE
Member
Henceforth "Bronson bumb" will come to mean "bumping a billion-dollar franchise down to a hundred-dollar franchise".
ryutaro's mama
Member
Not surprising especially when you present it as consensus like this post.
I don't do that.
Rocky ain't no Vikings fan.
Astral Dog
Member
Now it can't be worse than Episode VII!
WhiteRabbitEXE
Member
As long as it's not italics your farts will be dry.
itwasTuesday
He wasn't alone.
i'll be waiting in anticipation for the heel turn
Wandering Robot
Member
I have skipped everything but the first page to come and say whew. We really need to know who'll be writing and directing the final product, though. Cool with Rian staying on, if not another good director
I was in the car and freaked out lol
I don't either. I don't think we have to tag posts as opinion or waste words trying to make sure everyone understands we're speaking for ourselves when we clearly are.
In other words I was agreeing with your post while also being snarky because we've argued about Avatar before.
WhiteRabbitEXE
Member
Class was starting and I blurted out "Holy shit!", then texted my friends and girlfriend lol
BronsonLee
Member
I dunno, Bobby brought his fucking APA handbook to the thread and I'm here to stop him from activating Skynet
WHAT man I don't see anything wrong here
teehee
I call this The Tronening
Rocky doesn't like football, too many concussions
How many Brinks trucks has Lucasfilm backed up to Rian Johnson's house? Over/under is 4 1/2.
Of course there is:
1. Ewok: Caravan of Courage
2-8 The live action movies
9. The Clone Wars
Of course there is:
1. Ewok: Caravan of Courage
2-8 The live action movies
9. The Clone Wars
AlexFlame116
Member
I vote to replace BronsonLee with another, more knowledgeable director.
Someone like
.
Someone like
not me
It's pretty big news. Pretty much a guarantee that EP9 will be improved.
You held the keys
Then locked yourself out.
ryutaro's mama
Member
Did we? I honestly don't remember as I haven't have a deep discussion of that film since it released.
I posted a lot about story stuff (and what I thought would be cool in a sequel) for the first couple of months but not much more after that.
shira
Member
AlexFlame116
Member
Toa TAK wouldn't work either. I'm sure he's too busy making masterpieces.
I....hmm....actually you have a point about number 1.
BronsonLee
Member
Now NOBODY gets a Star War! My mission is complete.
Get your own job bitch