Yeah but it's still pretty stupid to assume a Pokemon looks useless because it looks stupid. I mean, look at Charizard, it's apparently "awesome" but it sucks big time.
Yes it does, that factor pretty much nails it. You have a nostalgia with it back then, so obviously playing it again will give you the feeling. So the argument that the remake is "soulless" is stupid and insipid because it pretty much translated Gen 1 near-perfectly (much to its limitations).
It's the same people who says MMPR is the "best" season that even them rewatching those episodes are "good" because they have experiences on it when they were young.
Read again. It's
post game, something that didn't exist in Gen 1. It means the "remake" officially stops there and is more of the new stuff they could add. It includes Sevii Islands and stuff. Hell, it didn't have berries or even Happiness until post game too!
As much as how flawed Smogon's mindset is, it IS very annoying and broken.