posted yet
Man, DF really fucked up this time didn't they...
This gif showcases exactly what I'd expect of a 720p vs 900p difference.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
Man, DF really fucked up this time didn't they...
This gif showcases exactly what I'd expect of a 720p vs 900p difference.
bigbaldwolf86
Banned
These games are being made for multiple platforms. If they had built this from the ground up for the next gen systems I'm willing to be both would have better resolutions but for cross gen launch games I think it looks impressive. BF4 seems to be the only PS4 game that isn't 1080p (I could be wrong) and it's still running at 900p. Maybe if DICE had more time to optimize the game they could have reached 1080p.
I'll take 900p @ 60fps to have the full Battlefield 64 player experience on PS4 versus 24 players on last gen.
To try and get the point across that if you sharpen the image to the level that the X1 is at the PS4 version looks better. There have been too many bad comparisons and the compressed videos on Youtube are barely worth watching.
I did mistake with ElGato because i thought it was what was DF using. My point still stands. There is no blurr going on in PS4 version.
if you look at relief and textures quality they are the same.
IAmRandom31
Banned
Xbox One - Built for Screenshots
Seeing BF4 in motion on the X1 on a big screen TV, which most people have nowadays, is ... not good.
I just watched the youtube videos on my living room TV. Results were a " tad " different then watching on my computer monitor.
Seeing BF4 in motion on the X1 on a big screen TV, which most people have nowadays, is ... not good.
I just watched the youtube videos on my living room TV. Results were a " tad " different then watching on my computer monitor.
PodcastFips
Member
This is all confusing as hell.
So many different sources with different videos... for me it's really hard to get a fair comparison. Especially with all the compression. Gamersyde, help me.
Oh, and there are so many different images an gifs in this thread, I don't even know which one was edited or not anymore.
So many different sources with different videos... for me it's really hard to get a fair comparison. Especially with all the compression. Gamersyde, help me.
Oh, and there are so many different images an gifs in this thread, I don't even know which one was edited or not anymore.
Pretty sure if this is the vast casm or disparity Mr. Penello is pretty happy right now.
Considering yesterday the PS4 Multiplayer was supposed to look better than XB1's single player.
The PS4 is a bit better looking, higher resolution and more consistent frame rate.. but it's not running laps around the XB1 by any means (and the hardware upscaler seems to be *really* solid on the XB1).
phosphor112
Banned
Photoshop
Levels Layer
Limit RGB Levels to 16-235.
That'll give you exact same colors.
If you want the sharpen filter, do "filter more" and that'll get you the exact same "texture" results as X1. Even though I think that looks like ass...
He said "dirt road ahead".
N30RYU
Member
NTIETS13A_Superiority
Banned
PS4 version looks much better here.
I am not suprised DF fucked it all up. Incompetence to the max.
Muppet of a Man
Member
originally posted by canis lupus:
posted yet
And there it is: uncompressed, native captures with correct output calibration.
PS4 is clearly superior in just about every way.
posted yet
And there it is: uncompressed, native captures with correct output calibration.
PS4 is clearly superior in just about every way.
Sorry its really hard to tell,because someone did the the exact same thing you did in this topic.no way! OMG!
was just kidding
Sword Of Doom
Member
It's because of the sharpness. But if you compare the XB1 vs PC you'll see that the XB1 is even sharper than the PC. It's like setting your TV on the Vibrant setting. Everything is blown out and sharpness is set to Max. Looks weird tbh
silver.tongue
Member
We are supposed to not see the huge explosion on the PS4 side, right?
Both versions look pretty good, but the PS4 version looks better.
Doesn't crush blacks like the XB1 version. Less jaggies. Just seems overall more realistic.
I equate it to TV shopping when you walk into the store and people immediately gravitate to the brightest/sharpest LED TV and people think it looks great.
But I'm sure whatever version people get, they will have a great time with the multiplayer.
Doesn't crush blacks like the XB1 version. Less jaggies. Just seems overall more realistic.
I equate it to TV shopping when you walk into the store and people immediately gravitate to the brightest/sharpest LED TV and people think it looks great.
But I'm sure whatever version people get, they will have a great time with the multiplayer.
Muppet of a Man
Member
From OP but I just turned up the contrast on PS4 shot (as you can do easily on any TV) to what looked like similar to the XBOnes, but the XBOnes bloom is f'd up so it's pretty off. Should I do this with the other shots?
Why not use good captures from IGN (I know it's ironic that IGN has the better captures here)?
That's not an explosion, that's just how blurry walls are in the PS4 version.
From OP but I just turned up the contrast on PS4 shot (as you can do easily on any TV) to what looked like similar to the XBOnes, but the XBOnes bloom is f'd up so it's pretty off. Should I do this with the other shots?
There are more light sources on the xb1 pic. Behind the trees on the right there.
Sword Of Doom
Member
Exactly. That's what it is.
DragonSworne
Banned
Just as I expected, Digital Foundry has become a joke.
I can't believe they let Leadbetter fanboyism comprosime their integrity. Time to clean shop and get a new crew.
I can't believe they let Leadbetter fanboyism comprosime their integrity. Time to clean shop and get a new crew.
are you serious??
I hope not.
edit
DF needs to revaluate themselves, do they want clicks due to technical merit or due to a LACK of merit.
Hmm... the 1080p shots seem to be native. Not 100% sure though.
JetBlackPanda
Member
holy shit. looking at these photos on an actually computer monitor at desktop resolution the difference is striking. Last night I was looking at them on my iphone and that really helped the XO version.
its pretty clear the PS4 version wins. on top of that it does it at a higher resolution and with more stable frame rate.
I am still a little disappointed the PS4 didn't bring it home @ 1080p I feel like moving forward that should be the standard everyone shoots for.
its pretty clear the PS4 version wins. on top of that it does it at a higher resolution and with more stable frame rate.
I am still a little disappointed the PS4 didn't bring it home @ 1080p I feel like moving forward that should be the standard everyone shoots for.
Hexa
Member
Can you link them?
Masked_Ninja
Member
They both look good.
The only big difference i see is in the multiplayer.
The only big difference i see is in the multiplayer.
Muppet of a Man
Member
fwiw, as someone who on his TV has his backlight turned all the way down, sharpness off, contrast at around 45% and brightness at around 50% (all calibrated in with test patterns)
The PS4 shots look more natural.
xbone shots look "bolder", but way less natural and with horrible black detail as a result.
if the latter is how you like your TV setup, enjoy the xbone version. If you like the more natural look or want the ability to choose which look you want, and get better performance, higher resolution and less aliasing to boot, enjoy the PS4 version.
The PS4 shots look more natural.
xbone shots look "bolder", but way less natural and with horrible black detail as a result.
if the latter is how you like your TV setup, enjoy the xbone version. If you like the more natural look or want the ability to choose which look you want, and get better performance, higher resolution and less aliasing to boot, enjoy the PS4 version.
MDSLKTR
Member
Muppet of a Man
Member
jordan0386
Member
Why, getting 900p shows how strong the card is for PS4.
velociraptor
Junior Member
8k - with 6 TITANS I think we can reach this goal.
And booom! There it is folks. The PS4 is clearly superior!
BigEvilTurtle
Banned
Which version is blurry again? ; )
Are these raw? XO is a blurry yet somehow also very aliased mess.
The resolution of real life is one giant, colorful and oval Pixel.
Fyi, Dice said they are adding HBAO to the xbox one version for launch. So it will look a bit better than what we see now.
Always-honest
Banned
depends on the person. Some people only see in 140P
Obviosly PS4 version is technically better, but - Jesus H. Christ! - this "can be easily emulated on your TV" bullshit needs to stop. TV sharpening filter is not as smart as the one in Photoshop or even Irfan View or whatever people use to make those "enhanced" PS4 screenshots. I don't know what Xbone uses, but it's disingenuous to say "you can easily change the settings on your TV".
/PC-gamer rant.
/PC-gamer rant.
So sub-720p then. No need to worry about Xbox One.
JetBlackPanda
Member
I agree and i think games will start to hit 1080p once people really get working with it. Its just crazy that these systems are 7-8 years removed from last gen and we are still struggling to get to 1080p (granted there is a lot more going on then just resolution )