It just looks higher res. Even the textures look better.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
It just looks higher res. Even the textures look better.
BladeSinner
Neo Member
Xbox one
Ps4
From the ign vid . The aliasing is due to the sharpening filter on x1 not a blurring filter on ps4. In fact ps4 looks more cinematic and x1 looks more cartoony
If you look at the dirt road ahead in this pic comparison, the XO version actually has a tremendous amount of added detail...
In the end we could argue on an on about this. What it comes down to ultimately is choice.
I personally think that the PS4 version looks best to my eyes, but the XO version looks far from crap...they both look excellent...I am actually surprised at how good XO version looks, I expected it to be night/day with PS4, but I simply cant say it is...really just different shades of gray.
Again, thats my opinion, and I am sure others will have their own opinion on the matter.
What matters is that you are happy with what you buy/use. If that is the case, dont let anyone tell you that you shouldn't be happy, and having fun playing games
velociraptor
Junior Member
Yes the PS4 MP footage looks better than what I saw on my PC. SP looks great though. It truly looks 'next-gen'. Of course the IQ isn't as good as the PC version but the PC version runs worse on my rig. I may buy BF4 for the PS4 for that reason..
shinra-bansho
Member
I made it [nerdpride] from some images a fellow gaffer posted, where he applied an "Xbox One filter" to the PS4 image.
Neither the original images nor the gif were made to show "which looks better" but rather this is what the PS4 version looks like when it's colours and sharpness are also fucked (which apparently a lot of people prefer and something you can easily achieve with your television settings.)
Deep Down is 720p as far as we know for now.
Sorry, just a dumb joke that some Killzone fans used to hurl at Guerrilla over things in their games, and then it bled over into blaming them for other developers' failures.
That's good to hear about the capture being messed up, I could see that being a problem. Will probably take a while for the outlets to get their capture devices and settings ready for the new consoles. Their comments definitely didn't jive with the pictures I saw, so makes sense that they didn't get everything captured correctly. I can only watch the videos thus far on my iPhone at work, and both versions look the same on a screen that size.
I thought the general feeling about Battlefield games was that Singleplayer is just filler stuff and Multiplayer is where the games shine and are fun..?
if that is a how people view the BF games, then why would anyone prefer the Xbox One version over the PS4 version when it comes to graphics..? The IGN video makes Xbox One MP look really underpowered..
if that is a how people view the BF games, then why would anyone prefer the Xbox One version over the PS4 version when it comes to graphics..? The IGN video makes Xbox One MP look really underpowered..
Dark_AnNiaLatOr
Member
These are exactly my sentiments. I don't what the heck is going on in people's minds to make them say the next gen console footage looks like crap. It looks amazing! So smooth with awesome muzzle flashes and bits and pieces of destruction that doesn't look glitchy. I feel like people are comparing next gen multi to PC 4k to 1080p downsampled single player in the back of their minds and then come out and say that the consoles suck.
Ultra settings on PC don't do much other than lower your framerate. Crysis 3 looked much better than it did on current gen consoles on low and played on cheap HW. Didn't look much worse than ultra either.
Hellsing321
Member
Both look like shit really. The fact they couldn't do 1080p on PS4 makes DICE look like a joke.
nope. we've had screens released both 720 and 1080...the only thing we know is it's 60fps.
I too was shocked that I preferred every XO screen to the PS4. I was prepared for the opposite.
I think they could have been done in 1080p .. but not 60 fps
TheZink
Member
Maybe its my computer but I couldnt tell much of a difference in the Multiplayer video. Any pics of the two?
posted yet
This really puts a better perspective of PS4 output accuracy.
shadowsdarknes
Member
Oh come on. I think they both look amazing.
posted yet
....that's a huge difference. Nothing like the pics in the OP.
I expect it to get better after the first year. All "hardcore" fans will already have made their decision and for the rest both systems will have differentiated themselves a bit more so it will be less emotional when someone picks one over the other.
Why is it DICE that looks like a joke and not the consoles?
posted yet
why cranes on the top of builidings are so out of place?
In pc aren't blueish, right?
Neither DICE, nor the consoles look like a joke actually. If I could run games looking like that on a 400 PC, I'd be a happy camper.
Because there are better looking games on the PS4 that are full 1080p.
I'm full of shit?
Up to 3:30, so boat cutscene, there are 6 drops, with 3 of them being by 4fps and two by 2fps.
How is this consistent with a shot that shows over 14fps difference? When for over minutes You have only 6 seconds of drops top and for the rest of the time game is locked in 60fps?
And in boat scene, the difference is 2-4fps still, mostly 2fps. There was no 60fps multiplatform game on this generation that was so consistent in terms of framerate in both platform and to reach its final frame target.
Without fps meter You wouldnt be able to tell the difference in fps in both version.
Thats outstanding parity in terms of framerate, anyone who is denying it or even nitpicking it, is full of shit.
Haven't been keeping up with the thread, where was this stated?
They could, they just focused on other things. Visual effects sell more than resolution and they wanted 60fps. Already a German PC site recommended the PS4 version over the PC version because it runs on 400 HW.
Link to 1080p screens?
The Playstation 4 version clearly looks better. It's not as big a difference as these last two days had led me to believe though, assuming that the footage is somewhat indicative of reality. Having said that, it's the type of difference that requires side by side comparison to truly notice, which leads me to believe that it's impact will be lost on those who aren't as dedicated to their craft as us. As the generation unfolds a little bit, and I eventually become a multiconsole owner, these comparisons will definitely hold weight.
My biggest take away from these side by sides is that the game pales in comparison to each console's first party offerings, both in terms of graphics as well as optimization. That's understandable of course, but it's still painfully obvious.
My biggest take away from these side by sides is that the game pales in comparison to each console's first party offerings, both in terms of graphics as well as optimization. That's understandable of course, but it's still painfully obvious.
not to mention once the pattern starts to form that one is superior to the other, these comparisons will becomes less relevant. it'll be a case of xbox owners expecting the lesser version, and PS4 owners expecting the superior version...just like current gen but reversed.
https://twitter.com/repi/status/395138203075633152
He also implies that there are other fixes, whatever that means
ElRenoRaven
Member
If you look at the dirt road ahead in this pic comparison, the XO version actually has a tremendous amount of added detail...
In the end we could argue on an on about this. What it comes down to ultimately is choice.
I personally think that the PS4 version looks best to my eyes, but the XO version looks far from crap...they both look excellent...I am actually surprised at how good XO version looks, I expected it to be night/day with PS4, but I simply cant say it is...really just different shades of gray.
Again, thats my opinion, and I am sure others will have their own opinion on the matter.
What matters is that you are happy with what you buy/use. If that is the case, dont let anyone tell you that you shouldn't be happy, and having fun playing games
I have to agree. I can't stand most of the shit MS has done but honestly both look damn good to me. I honestly think that most people aren't going to really notice and give a shit about which one has 10 more FPS for a second or two. I don't think they're going to count pixels. I really do think people are thinking that some very minor details are going to make a huge difference to the general public when they won't. That said since I have no interest in the Xbone and am getting the PS4 I'm buying that version.
I think it's because other games are doing 1080p on PS4, but this doesn't make DICE ook like a joke BF4 in 900p and 720p are both impressive, when we see CoD:Ghosts, people will realize that DICE have done a good job here.
Unfortunately BF4 will be compared to shadowfall which looks stunning at 1080p/60 for multiplayer, However BF4 is on a lot more platforms and so you would expect them to get less out of each piece of hardware.
http://www.gamersyde.com/news_tgs_deep_down_screenshots-14636_en.html
first half 720, second half 1080.
tweeted by a DICE dev, said the review build didn't have it, but retail version will
Both versions look amazing...
Don't get why this means so much to GAF tbh, 90% of gamers who buy an xb1 won't care when they are playing about these little differences, yet we have a 400k views thread about it. SMH
I finished re4 on PS3 the other day, and had just as much fun as the wii version when I played it last year. The resolution only mattered when I stopped and actually stared at the environments, but when I'm POP POP POP WATCHIN NIGGAZ DROP these ganados with the TMP i dont give a shit about resolution. I don't get you guys, bubt I'm thankful I don't have high standards bout this stuff i guess
Don't get why this means so much to GAF tbh, 90% of gamers who buy an xb1 won't care when they are playing about these little differences, yet we have a 400k views thread about it. SMH
I finished re4 on PS3 the other day, and had just as much fun as the wii version when I played it last year. The resolution only mattered when I stopped and actually stared at the environments, but when I'm POP POP POP WATCHIN NIGGAZ DROP these ganados with the TMP i dont give a shit about resolution. I don't get you guys, bubt I'm thankful I don't have high standards bout this stuff i guess
Not shitting on dice but Killzone has more detail, does 1080p native and higher framerates.
Ghost Cell
Banned
JackFrags PS4 MP footage looks fucking great. Can't wait for this.
Here:
ambient occlusion not aa
...there's a dirt cloud in the way in the PS4 version.
You'll do well here.
Agree 100%. Good post.
NTIETS13A_Superiority
Banned
DF shows their incompetence again.
posted yet
Lots of bullshit and mess to come in the next comparison war lol..
So now suddenly the PS4 is super sharp and the xbo version is blurry.. How did it turn blurry .. ??
I mean i'd be glad if the PS4 version looked clearly better in every comparison but this will quicly get boring if you can show anything and its contrary depending on who does it..
I'm all for a fair fight! This is pretty ridiculous how fanboys from on camp or the other are just taking whatever comes to make them happy without asking any questions. "Ho yeah that's more like it i like that comparison, must be the truth" lol..
IAmRandom31
Banned
one thing you are forgetting, you are watching compressed small window youtube videos. Things change alot when you go from a 20-22 inch monitor to a 40-50 inch HDTV.
I think that is why when you actually hear impressions from people who have played both PS4 and X1 versions, they say the difference is big and noticeable. On these videos though, everything is so compressed and condensed and doctored ( so it seems ), it is impossible to get a real world view of what you yourself will see when you take the game home.
Punkster_NY
Member
Anyone that's used ElGato hardware/software for capture knows that you can't really fuck it up I mean it's a plug and play setup and it captures exactly what you see on screen.
These changes were clearly made afterwards in Sony Studio or a similar app. DF should get their press pass pulled for tampering with the footage. They just destroyed their credibility with the gaming community over a game that we'll all probably forget about in a year or so. smh
These changes were clearly made afterwards in Sony Studio or a similar app. DF should get their press pass pulled for tampering with the footage. They just destroyed their credibility with the gaming community over a game that we'll all probably forget about in a year or so. smh
Isn't Killzone 30-60 fps? This is nearly always 60 fps and everything can be blown up.
KZSF doesn't do 60fps in SP. And KZSF doesn't have anywhere near as much shit going on in MP compared to BF4.