LOL. What's a dump argument is using XBO X vs Pro as a reference.
In that case the hardware differences were stratospheric compared to those of PS5 vs XSX. The funniest? Even so, they have a lot of cases where the Pro version was on par with the XBO X or even several cases being the superior version.
The fact is that the XBO X vs PS4Pro comparison would serve as a basis to defend against your argument. Not only that there were many cases where the PRo version was equal to or even better than the XBO, the situation is that there are even more cases where the XBO X seems poorly optimized with bugs, Or worse graphic assets, or worse framerate when the resolution could be 2x that of Pro where you had a much more coherent and polished version.
Returning to the PS5 vs XSX comparison. I'm sorry, but what comrade Vergil describes are only facts, even if you don't want to see them and react by insulting arguments that make sense.
The funniest thing of all is that you go, for example, to the A Plague Tale Requiem comparison thread and you see a case with significant differences in favor of XSX and the general opinion was that "they have optimized it better for XsX" or the PS5 version should be better optimized. Which would have its logic, but it seems that this excuse only works in one direction for you
There is no dump argument in defending that the Studios are more interested in offering the most polished version in the one that will be the one that will dictate the reactions of the media and users in the vast majority. A PS5 version significantly worse than that of XsX produces discomfort and negativity at a game launch. The opposite not so much.
The number of times that the XSX version has been fixed in later patches and in many cases even to be the best version is already an indication that its optimization at launch was not the best.
It would be perfectly logical to think that, given an equality of hardware power such as that shown by both consoles, the Studios will "relax" with a respectable or "on par" XsX version (that is, slightly better, slightly worse or the same as that of PS5).
I already told you that if XSX were less powerful than Ps5, with 70% fewer units on the market and and distributing optimization time with XSS, the differences in favor of PS5 would be more significant in the vast majority of cases vs the general equality (We could say extreme equality) that you see today.