• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GAF Creates: Super Smash Bros. 4

Masked Man

I said wow
AzureJericho said:
Using the daily vote on one who should have been playable from the start...

Toad. Do it bitches. :lol

<3 you for that. As soon as my beloved Masked Man gets on the list, I will follow suit. Toad is my favorite Mario character. :D
 
Here's the updated list after the past two days of voting:

THE LIST SO FAR:

Super Mario Bros.:

Mario
Peach
Bowser

The Legend of Zelda:

Link
Zelda

Kirby Super Star:

Kirby

Pokemon:

Pikachu

Donkey Kong Country:

Donkey Kong

Star Fox:

Fox

Metroid:

Samus

Yoshi's Island:

Yoshi

F-Zero:

Captain Falcon

MOTHER:

Ness

Fire Emblem:

Marth

Wario:

Wario
Captain Syrup

Pikmin:

Pikmin & Olimar

Punch-Out!!:

Little Mac

Nazo no Murasame-j&#333;:

Takamaru

Wii Series:

Mii

Mega Man:

Mega Man

The Suggestion List (As of Now):

Little Mac- Punch-Out (6)- SAFE
Megaman- Megaman (6)- SAFE
Takamaru- Nazo no Murasame-j&#333; (5)- SAFE
Marth- Fire Emblem- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ LEAD OF SERIES
Captain Syrup- Wario Land (5)- SAFE
Mii- Wii Series (5)- SAFE
Tom Nook- Animal Crossing (4)
Isaac- Golden Sun (4)
Travis Touchdown- No More Heroes (3)
Geno- Super Mario RPG (3)
Skull Kid- The Legend of Zelda (2)
Mike Jones- Startropics (2)
Lyndis- Fire Emblem (2)
Masked Man- MOTHER (2)
Toad- Super Mario Bros. (2)
Lucas- MOTHER (2)
Sukapon- Joy Mech Fight (2)
Professor Layton- Professor Layton
Luigi- Super Mario Bros.
Neku- The World Ends With You
Ridley- Metroid
Saki- Sin and Punishment
Ray- Disaster: Day of Crisis
Captain Rainbow- Captain Rainbow
Lip- Panel de Pon
Jill- Drill Dozer
Falco- Starfox
Waluigi- Super Mario Bros.
Ike- Fire Emblem
Lucario- Pokemon
Wolf- Starfox
Layle- FFCC: The Crystal Bearers
Diddy + Dixie- Donkey Kong Country
Bomberman- Bomberman
Impa- The Legend of Zelda
Flint- MOTHER
8-bit Mega Man- Mega Man

A few notes after yesterday's voting:
- Mii, the highly customizable Wii avatar, is now a playable character!
- Toad has finally appeared on the list and with two votes no less!
- Isaac & Tom Nook are one point away from being included.
- The roster now stands at 21.

KEEP UP THE VOTING!
 

jay

Member
Captain Rainbow (Captain Rainbow)
Tingle (Zelda)
Mii (Wii)
Kart (Mario Kart)
Professor Layton (no idea)
 

BGBW

Maturity, bitches.
There shouldn't just be Toad, but Blue Toad and Yellow Toad taking up two valuable spots.

laughs
 
BlueSummers, I'm counting your Skull Kid support as a vote, :lol

And BGBW, should I count those Toad votes separately? If not, I'll put those both toward Toad.
 
BGBW said:
There shouldn't just be Toad, but Blue Toad and Yellow Toad taking up two valuable spots.

laughs

Good one. :lol

"Oh, sorry, we were going to include Masked Man, but there was just no more room on the select screen!"
 
Yesterday's voting really made an effect on the list! Check out the results!:

THE LIST SO FAR:

Super Mario Bros.:

Mario
Peach
Bowser
Toad
Luigi

The Legend of Zelda:

Link
Zelda

Kirby Super Star:

Kirby

Pokemon:

Pikachu

Donkey Kong Country:

Donkey Kong

Star Fox:

Fox

Metroid:

Samus

Yoshi's Island:

Yoshi

F-Zero:

Captain Falcon

MOTHER:

Ness
Lucas

Fire Emblem:

Marth
Ike

Wario:

Wario
Captain Syrup

Pikmin:

Pikmin & Olimar

Punch-Out!!:

Little Mac

Nazo no Murasame-j&#333;:

Takamaru

Mega Man:

Mega Man

The Suggestion List (As of Now):

Megaman- Megaman (7)- SAFE
Mii- Wii Series (7)- SAFE
Little Mac- Punch-Out (6)- SAFE
Toad- Super Mario Bros. (6)- SAFE
Takamaru- Nazo no Murasame-j&#333; (5)- SAFE
Captain Syrup- Wario Land (5)- SAFE
Luigi- Super Mario Bros.- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Ness- MOTHER- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ LEAD OF SERIES
Marth- Fire Emblem- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ LEAD OF SERIES
Lucas- MOTHER- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Ike- Fire Emblem- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Tom Nook- Animal Crossing (4)
Isaac- Golden Sun (4)
Masked Man- MOTHER (3)
Travis Touchdown- No More Heroes (3)
Geno- Super Mario RPG (3)
Skull Kid- The Legend of Zelda (3)
Professor Layton- Professor Layton (2)
Neku- The World Ends With You (2)
Mike Jones- Startropics (2)
Lyndis- Fire Emblem (2)
Captain Rainbow- Captain Rainbow (2)
Sukapon- Joy Mech Fight (2)
Ridley- Metroid (2)
Salsa- MOTHER
Tingle- The Legend of Zelda
Impa- The Legend of Zelda
Saki- Sin and Punishment
Mr. Dream- Punch-Out!!
Ray- Disaster: Day of Crisis
Lip- Panel de Pon
Jill- Drill Dozer
Falco- Starfox
Waluigi- Super Mario Bros.
Lucario- Pokemon
Daisy- Super Mario Bros.
Meowth- Pokemon
Wolf- Starfox
Layle- FFCC: The Crystal Bearers
Diddy + Dixie- Donkey Kong Country
Bomberman- Bomberman
Linebeck- The Legend of Zelda
Flint- MOTHER
Bowser Jr.- Super Mario Bros.
8-bit Mega Man- Mega Man
Edward- Full Metal Alchemist
Kart- Mario Kart

A few notes after yesterday's voting:
- Luigi, Lucas and Ike have all been added to the list of confirmed returning verterans!
- Toad, the lovable assistant of Princess Peach, is now a playable character!
- Isaac & Tom Nook are still only one point away from being included.
- The roster now stands at 25!

KEEP UP THE VOTING!
 

Yazus

Member
Masked Man- MOTHER
Travis Touchdown- No More Heroes
Geno- Super Mario RPG
Waluigi- Super Mario Bros
Daisy- Super Mario Bros
 

spanks

Member
I think it would be cool for the next Smash Bros to have a specific theme. Like, they could expand the 3rd party lineup for a Nintendo Vs 3rd parties type thing. A more interesting one I've thought of is a Good Vs Bad setup. We already have a good starting point:

Bowser
Ganondorf
Mewtwo
King Dedede
Wolf
Captain Syrup

Some nice additions would be (you can add these as my votes for the next few days if you want):

King K Rool- Donkey Kong Country
Black Shadow- F-Zero
The Black Knight- Fire Emblem
Ridley- Metroid
Skull Kid- Zelda

edit- forgot to add Wart from SMB2!
 

Masked Man

I said wow
One more for my beloved Masked Man! <33

I would love to see a more explicit "good v. evil" dynamic in the next Brawl, if only to secure more villains on the roster. And yayyy for Toad, Lucas, and Takamaru! :D
 

fernoca

Member
You know..
After seeing Nintendo make Super Mario Galaxy 2, which is Galaxy..but with more and more..and Yoshi..

I wouldn't mind if they made a Super Smash Bros. Brawl 2..
Brawl with like 10 new characters, dozens of new items and assistants..every Smash Bros. game/stages remade, a few new ones..no Adventure mode, a revamped Create a Stage with more things to add, more music and a more robust online mode with voice chat.

Just..more!!

Then take their sweet time for Super Smash Bros. 4...
 

NeonZ

Member
fernoca said:
You know..
After seeing Nintendo make Super Mario Galaxy 2, which is Galaxy..but with more and more..and Yoshi..

I wouldn't mind if they made a Super Smash Bros. Brawl 2..

There were news about Nintendo making a new studio for Sakurai last year.

They mentioned that the studio would make a new core game. At the time, based on their statements, it seemed like they were talking about a new franchise... However, this is Nintendo, they wouldn't waste too much money on a new non-expanded audience franchise, so it's probably either another Smash or a new Kirby.
 

Masked Man

I said wow
Furthermore, their website implies that the project is wholly new. Iwata requested "a project (mission) that is not Smash Bros."; Sakurai said that it will be "a different experience from what we have seen until now."
 

GamerSoul

Member
spanks said:
I think it would be cool for the next Smash Bros to have a specific theme. Like, they could expand the 3rd party lineup for a Nintendo Vs 3rd parties type thing. A more interesting one I've thought of is a Good Vs Bad setup. We already have a good starting point:

Bowser
Ganondorf
Mewtwo
King Dedede
Wolf
Captain Syrup

Some nice additions would be (you can add these as my votes for the next few days if you want):

King K Rool- Donkey Kong Country
Black Shadow- F-Zero
The Black Knight- Fire Emblem
Ridley- Metroid
Skull Kid- Zelda

edit- forgot to add Wart from SMB2!

the good and evil idea would be fun....

i'm voting for Bowser Junior.
 
HEY I REMEMBER THIS THREAD!

And since the current confirmed list lacks Pokemon, I'm going to focus on the Pokemon cast I think deserves inclusion

Gold (replacing the Pokemon Trainer with a Chikorita/Quilava/Feraligatr combo)
Lucario
Mewtwo
Deoxys

That gives every generation representation, while sticking to the iconics and the guys that wouild actually be suited to fighting.

Also: Tetra/Toon Zelda.
 
WOW. Yesterday's voting made the greatest impact on the list of any previous vote! Check out the awesome results! Many fan-favorites are now included into the playable roster!:

THE LIST SO FAR:

Super Mario Bros.:

Mario
Peach
Bowser
Toad
Luigi

The Legend of Zelda:

Link
Zelda

Kirby Super Star:

Kirby

Pokemon:

Pikachu
Lucario

Donkey Kong Country:

Donkey Kong

Star Fox:

Fox
Falco

Metroid:

Samus

Yoshi's Island:

Yoshi

F-Zero:

Captain Falcon

MOTHER:

Ness
Lucas
Masked Man

Animal Crossing:

Tom Nook

Fire Emblem:

Marth
Ike

Wario:

Wario
Captain Syrup

Pikmin:

Pikmin & Olimar

Golden Sun:

Isaac

Mario RPG Series:

Geno

Punch-Out!!:

Little Mac

Nazo no Murasame-j&#333;:

Takamaru

Mega Man:

Mega Man

The Suggestion List (As of Now):

Megaman- Megaman (7)- SAFE
Mii- Wii Series (7)- SAFE
Toad- Super Mario Bros. (7)- SAFE
Little Mac- Punch-Out (6)- SAFE
Takamaru- Nazo no Murasame-j&#333; (5)- SAFE
Captain Syrup- Wario Land (5)- SAFE
Masked Man- MOTHER (5)- SAFE
Tom Nook- Animal Crossing (5)- SAFE
Geno- Mario RPG Series (5)- SAFE
Isaac- Golden Sun (5)- SAFE
Luigi- Super Mario Bros.- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Ness- MOTHER- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ LEAD OF SERIES
Marth- Fire Emblem- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ LEAD OF SERIES
Lucas- MOTHER (2)- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Ike- Fire Emblem (2)- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Falco- Star Fox- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Lucario- Pokemon (2)- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Skull Kid- The Legend of Zelda (4)
Travis Touchdown- No More Heroes (4)
Professor Layton- Professor Layton (3)
Ridley- Metroid (3)
Mike Jones- Startropics (3)
Neku- The World Ends With You (2)
Lyndis- Fire Emblem (2)
Captain Rainbow- Captain Rainbow (2)
Sukapon- Joy Mech Fight (2)
Waluigi- Super Mario Bros. (2)
Daisy- Super Mario Bros. (2)
Salsa- MOTHER
King K. Rool- Donkey Kong Country (2)
Black Shadow- F-Zero
The Black Knight- Fire Emblem
Tingle- The Legend of Zelda
Mewtwo- Pokemon
Impa- The Legend of Zelda
Saki- Sin and Punishment
Mr. Dream- Punch-Out!!
Ray- Disaster: Day of Crisis
Lip- Panel de Pon
Jill- Drill Dozer
Meowth- Pokemon
Wolf- Starfox
Layle- FFCC: The Crystal Bearers
Diddy + Dixie- Donkey Kong Country
Bomberman- Bomberman
Linebeck- The Legend of Zelda
Flint- MOTHER
Boy and His Blob- A Boy and His Blob
Bowser Jr.- Super Mario Bros.
Gold (Pokemon Trainer)- Pokemon
Deoxys- Pokemon
Tetra/ Toon Zelda- The Legend of Zelda
8-bit Mega Man- Mega Man
Edward- Full Metal Alchemist
Kart- Mario Kart

A few notes after yesterday's voting:
- Falco and Lucario have been added to the list of confirmed returning verterans!
- Tom Nook, Animal Crossing's Tanooki shopkeep, is now a playable character!
- Geno, the possessed doll from Mario RPG, is now a playable character!
- Isaac, Golden Sun's leading man, is now a playable character!
- The Masked Man, MOTHER 3's misunderstood antagonist, is now a playable character!
- The roster now stands at 31!

KEEP UP THE VOTING!
 

IntelliHeath

As in "Heathcliff"
>.> alright, it dont make any sense since you send me a private mail regard to my ike vote. (when I actually followed your rule)

you send me a private mail about my voting so I will post to refresh your memories.

You have 5 votes, not just one for Ike.

You can vote for four other unreasonable characters!
 
Yesterday's results (AKA: YEAH MIKE JONES!):

THE LIST SO FAR:

Super Mario Bros.:

Mario
Peach
Bowser
Toad
Luigi

The Legend of Zelda:

Link
Zelda

Kirby Super Star:

Kirby

Pokemon:

Pikachu
Lucario

Donkey Kong Country:

Donkey Kong

Star Fox:

Fox
Falco

Metroid:

Samus

Yoshi's Island:

Yoshi

Game and Watch:

Mr. Game and Watch

F-Zero:

Captain Falcon

MOTHER:

Ness
Lucas
Masked Man

Animal Crossing:

Tom Nook

Fire Emblem:

Marth
Ike

Wario:

Wario
Captain Syrup

Pikmin:

Pikmin & Olimar

Golden Sun:

Isaac

Mario RPG Series:

Geno

Punch-Out!!:

Little Mac

Startropics:

Mike Jones

Nazo no Murasame-j&#333;:

Takamaru

Mega Man:

Mega Man


The Suggestion List (As of Now):

Megaman- Megaman (7)- SAFE
Mii- Wii Series (7)- SAFE
Toad- Super Mario Bros. (7)- SAFE
Little Mac- Punch-Out (6)- SAFE
Takamaru- Nazo no Murasame-j&#333; (5)- SAFE
Captain Syrup- Wario Land (5)- SAFE
Masked Man- MOTHER (5)- SAFE
Tom Nook- Animal Crossing (5)- SAFE
Geno- Mario RPG Series (5)- SAFE
Isaac- Golden Sun (5)- SAFE
Mike Jones- Startropics (5)- SAFE
Luigi- Super Mario Bros.- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Ness- MOTHER- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ LEAD OF SERIES
Marth- Fire Emblem- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ LEAD OF SERIES
Lucas- MOTHER (2)- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Ike- Fire Emblem (2)- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Falco- Star Fox- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Lucario- Pokemon (2)- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ MAJOR SUPPORTING CHARACTER OF SERIES
Mr. Game and Watch- Game and Watch- SAFE DUE TO PREVIOUS INCLUSIONS/ LEAD OF SERIES
Skull Kid- The Legend of Zelda (4)
Professor Layton- Professor Layton (4)
Travis Touchdown- No More Heroes (4)
Ridley- Metroid (3)
King K. Rool- Donkey Kong Country (3)
Neku- The World Ends With You (2)
Lyndis- Fire Emblem (2)
Captain Rainbow- Captain Rainbow (2)
Sukapon- Joy Mech Fight (2)
Waluigi- Super Mario Bros. (2)
Daisy- Super Mario Bros. (2)
Salsa- MOTHER
Diddy Kong- Donkey Kong Country
King Dedede- Kirby Super Star
Black Shadow- F-Zero
The Black Knight- Fire Emblem
Tingle- The Legend of Zelda
Mewtwo- Pokemon
Impa- The Legend of Zelda
Saki- Sin and Punishment
Mr. Dream- Punch-Out!!
Ray- Disaster: Day of Crisis
Lip- Panel de Pon
Jill- Drill Dozer
Meowth- Pokemon
Wolf- Starfox
Layle- FFCC: The Crystal Bearers
Diddy + Dixie- Donkey Kong Country
Bomberman- Bomberman
Linebeck- The Legend of Zelda
Flint- MOTHER
Boy and His Blob- A Boy and His Blob
Bowser Jr.- Super Mario Bros.
Gold (Pokemon Trainer)- Pokemon
Deoxys- Pokemon
Tetra/ Toon Zelda- The Legend of Zelda
8-bit Mega Man- Mega Man
Edward- Full Metal Alchemist
Kart- Mario Kart

A few notes after yesterday's voting:
- Mike Jones, the yo-yo slinging island hopper from Startropics is now a playable character!
-Skull Kid, Professor Layton, and Travis Touchdown are all only a point away from being included.
- Mr. Game and Watch has been voted to return!
- The roster now stands at 33!

KEEP UP THE VOTING!
 
Top Bottom