Calavera520 said:
What is up with this thread? Why all the hate for good concepts and designers who've had a good pedigree in the past. Have I missed something here? Smith was connected to DX:IW, and Area 51 which weren't the greatest, but he also worked on System Shock and Deus Ex so I don't see were all this negativity comes from.
Ummmm, because he's a hack? Smith worked on Deus Ex and System Shock with Warren Spector and the folks from Looking Glass who deserve the lions share of the credit. So arguably he got a good name in the industry by riding their coat tails, even if this wasn't his intention.
He's then put in charge of Deus Ex 2 and produces one of the most maligned sequels to a beloved series in years. A product so disappointing that he even rags on it (I'll give him props for admitting he fucked up).
Afterwards, he goes on to work on Area 51, which was not only a bad game, but featured ham fisted political commentary that pleased no one. And then he whined that "No one got it". Which wasn't the case at all - everyone got it Harvey, they just thought it sucked.
So yeah, putting Harvey's name on the box isn't likely going to be a strong selling point these days.