Could you give an example (not necessarily related to JKR and the trans debate) of what you mean by this?
- In the 1950s many in Alabama boycotted riding all of the buses in the city in order to show their displeasure with the standard at that time. The standard was that black people had to sit in the back of the bus. When 40,000 black people decided to not ride the buses in the city for over a half year, it wasn't until the courts made the city's rule illegal until things changed.
- In the video game's space it has happened with Microtransactions in some games. These days some companies shout out at the beginning of a marketing run that "our game doesn't have microtransactions", just so everyone is aware. Because with certain games and from certain companies, they've lose trust with some of us gamers.
- Boycotts were started in 2018 against Ivanka Trump. She ended up closing her fashion brand. Her brand's sales fell 45% due to those boycotts. They started as an act against her father.
- Colin Kaepernick still hasn't even had a practice try out for the NFL because of the noise that 40% of America has made about his "not" standing up during the national anthem.
In those 4 examples, people didn't do anything illegal. Yet they made their thoughts and dollar felt by major corporations. And those corporations\country changed their stance.
I would be all for "agreeing to disagree", however you made disingenuous claims, refused to back up said claims when confronted, and pushed strawman arguments. There is a difference between "I don't agree with the views in the "Aloy" thread" and making the claim that the arguments were "a female video game character isn't pretty enough". The former is an opinion, one we can agree to disagree on. The latter is a strawman argument made to dismiss valid criticism. And that is just *one* example of many.
If you truly "haven't picked a side", you would constantly make these argumentative fallacies every corner. It is clear as day which "side" you have chosen.
My claims are backed up. You simply just disagree with what I'm saying, so you move the goalpost by "claiming" that it's just a strawman argument. There were many guys all on GAF, Twitter, etc that claimed that Aloy isn't pretty enough and said that she was fat. And a good percentage of those people then went on to say that it's part of an agenda that western devs have at the moment. You've seen these arguments, so stop playing.
People like you can't take nuance, so you try to pin people like me into one box. I see you though. Your games don't work on me lol.