• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

IGN producer gets irritated after Harada tweet

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, fuck what other people want!

Christ, people. Do you even listen to yourselves?

Tekken has always had it's share of scantily clad characters, why should it change now?

Wanna crusade for a game more toned down for the sake of gender equality, go make a new fighting IP

Would you complain about a new doa game with too many bathing suits?

I've been buying tekken games since 1 on PS1
 
Where is this coming from? Why are they saying it like it's never been like that before?

I think people only think of Tekken as the game with the crazy storyline about devils and volcanoes like good, god-fearing 90s anime. Then Lucky Chloe was the other, weird anime thing of modern, hitler-loving moe anime and people got super mad about it.
 
I have met Harada and he comes off as a genuinely likable, fun guy.

I fully believe he had no idea what he was saying here but ignorance is not really a good excuse and now he's set a boulder rolling off in a bad direction that was completely fucking unnecessary.

To be fair they're probably both sound and this is just another day on Twitter :)
 
"Hey, is that For Honor Samurai costume going to be the same in Japan?"

"It doesn't matter because your poor birthrate means no one will be alive to play it, hahaha"

That is an awful analogy. The response is completely disconnected from the question.

Harada's tweet basically amounts to "If people aren't too offended by the costumes, in your country", tweeted clearly as a joke.
 
Tekken has always had it's share of scantily clad characters, why should it change now?

Wanna crusade for a game more toned down for the sake of gender equality, go make a new fighting IP

Would you complain about a new doa game with too many bathing suits?

I've been buying tekken games since 1 on PS1
"Back in my day..." - e.g. blackface, no gays on TV, etc.

The status quo is not an excuse.
Sorry, I didn't mean to directly compare the representation of women to blackface. I was more talking about how the status quo or "well it's always been like this" should never be used to justify poor representation.
 
Here's a few quotes about what it's like to work in the Japanese game industry as a woman according to Emiko Iwasaki, who was a game director at Arc System Works before leaving the country to work in Singapore instead: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=176840071

We were a team with zero 3D experience, it was difficult to assign to me men who have experience and who entered the company earlier and are older than me. There were gender role issues deeply rooted in Japan. It is considered a shame for a man to work under woman because many people think "men first, ladies second".
Raising awareness is one way to help make the working environment better. In Japan, 95% of female developers retire within 5 years. We need to create an environment that would allow women to prove her worth via her skills and ability. Not only in the game industry, but everywhere else.
In Japan, most people assume that there are no gender issues in the working environments. In fact, it is hard to visualize such issues due to many factors and complex social structures. It also does not help that there are very few places for women to voice their real feelings safely. Many people say that "our work environments have no issues", but we can still see female workers crying in the ladies room, and then quit her job quietly.
What are some of the difficulties being a woman director in Japan?



For franchise or series IP projects, it isnÂ’t so difficult, but it becomes extremely difficult when it comes to original projects started from scratch. In Japan, there is a thinking that the important work is meant for the men, while the women are responsible for smaller tasks. Original projects are regarded as important works because it is something developers aspire to do. Because IÂ’m a woman director for an original project, a lot of people thought that I broke some taboos. This was not something that was acceptable to many people.
What brought you to Singapore and how is directing games here different from Arc System Works?

I was able to work in Arc System Works for a long time because the CEO, the Guilty Gear team and some passionate colleagues treat me as just a developer, not as a girl. But for most people, experienced women and my age are not welcome in the workplace. This is why I am interested to go to other countries, IÂ’m looking for something fun.
I think there's a reason people get concerned when you see someone like Harada throwing around the word SJW or some of the content you see in Japanese games, because it does reflect back down to the studios and how they treat their staff.
 
I'm pretty sure he understood the "context" of the word when he made the joke, he just didn't imagine people jumping down his throat over it, you know, cause it's a joke. A pretty benign one at that.

Really getting all pissy about it is kind of what he was making the joke about anyway.
 
I'm not sure what people are seeing wrong in Harada's Tweet?

If you do ask the SJW, and there are people who revendicate themselves as SJW so no it's not just a vitriolic term, what they think about said costumes they might say they shouldn't be included. So he's laughing it off..

I don't get why that's terrible?

He's wrong in the sense that you don't need to ask a "SJW" if a bikini will be featured in the western version, because those "SJW" don't have any decision.

And before you try to argue... no, they really don't.
 
That is an awful analogy. The response is completely disconnected from the question.

Harada's tweet basically amounts to "If people aren't too offended by the costumes in your country", tweeted clearly as a joke.

You're right that it's not a perfect analogy. The US doesn't have an even worse birth rate problem that goes totally ignored as is the case with gender politics in the US and Japan.
 
Harada was insensitive or crass.

Gav made a honestly pretty nasty personal attack.

Both were dumb, one was more dumb.
 
Sorry, I didn't mean to directly compare the representation of women to blackface. I was more talking about how the status quo or "well it's always been like this" should never be used to justify poor representation.

Oh okay, well in that context I actually agree with you. Sorry for the misunderstanding
 
This Gav Murphy guy surely has some sort of established friendly rapport with Harada because otherwise whatthefuck.
 
no they didn't

You know how Internet works. If the score is high "they're just trying to be cool because of that tweet", if the score is bad "they don't like Harada as proven in that tweet". At least it will generate traffic for them, I guess.

You're with Harada on this thing he already walked back and apologized for? What does that say about you?

I meant Harada's side, which includes the whole exchange.Don't extrapolate.
 
He not that busy if he knew enough to reference SJW

I know on GAF we insist that the term SJW is only a slur connected to gamergate, but I'd say that the word has entered the wider lexicon of English. So why wouldn't he know it?

I hear it all over the place, usually from liberals eye-rolling about about more over-zealous liberals. They're not using it ironically either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom