Well I forgot Kingdoms too. Many redeeming mangas still out there, so that was just negativity caught me off guard.
It's still partially true though
Ha! If only more smut have the 1/3 quality of Prison School or Shokugeki no Soma in art alone.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTY| Creatively Bankrupt
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
Ha! If only more smut have the 1/3 quality of Prison School or Shokugeki no Soma in art alone.
You should read more smut then~ (As Soma is relatively easy to match)
Let's see, aside Ancient Magus Bride, that's ongoing:
But if WSJ ToC is your measuring stick for quality of manga in Japan, you only have your bad taste to blame.
- All Rounder Meguru
- Gunka no Baltzer
- Prison School
- Shiori Experience
- Dead Dead Demon's Dededededestruction
- Knights of Sidonia
- Vinland Saga
- MIX
- Girls & Panzer - Ribbon no Musha
- Innocent (Rouge)
- Otoyomegatari
But if WSJ ToC is your measuring stick for quality of manga in Japan, you only have your bad taste to blame.
dakkumauji
Member
DTL wins in the end
oh when it became Naruto, lol
Then again, isn't this the first ranking?
it literally sounds like you haven't read past the first few chapters, wwwwwwwwwwww
Well said, though with the selection of mangas within Jump right now I expect them to choose much better.
Not freaking out till next week (assuming it sticks in the top 3 or 4), but holy shit what is going on
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Naruto 700+5
Wow Sasuke guess you never learned how not to be a total asshole.
Here it comes boys, NINJA ALIENS. There was a reason Kaguya was building an army to take over nothing because she already took it all over. Or we could just bring back old villains, that's been going well for the last few years
Bleach 628
Woah, Kubo remembered the cat thing? Props to him!
One Piece 788
I wonder if this last minute can be stretched a full chapter
And why is Fujitora so useless? You are an admiral, dude. In Doflamingo's weakened state Akainu, Kizaru or Aokiji would have been able to beat him easily. What are you doing?
Wow Sasuke guess you never learned how not to be a total asshole.
Here it comes boys, NINJA ALIENS. There was a reason Kaguya was building an army to take over nothing because she already took it all over. Or we could just bring back old villains, that's been going well for the last few years
Bleach 628
Woah, Kubo remembered the cat thing? Props to him!
One Piece 788
I wonder if this last minute can be stretched a full chapter
And why is Fujitora so useless? You are an admiral, dude. In Doflamingo's weakened state Akainu, Kizaru or Aokiji would have been able to beat him easily. What are you doing?
Pretty much. Even shonen's going great with Keijo and Tsugumomo.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Terra Formars 122-124
Take solace in the fact that this is actually worse then Naruto and Bleach and you are not reading it.
Take solace in the fact that this is actually worse then Naruto and Bleach and you are not reading it.
Aaronrules380
Member
Pretty sure Fuji is intentionally not being the one to take out doflamingo
Rafa=FedKilla
Banned
It was two last week. And had two consecutive color pages before. It's for real.
AquaWateria
Member
I was just joking I know that there are many great ongoing manga in other Magazines.
But yeah nice list.
Dedication Through Light
Member
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Say what you will about Akainu but he would leap at the chance to kill Doflamingo with an opening like this.
He already didn't want to tussle with Aokiji. He probably knows he can't fight the admirals, even if Fujitora is the weakest of them.
Aaronrules380
Member
Akainu and Fuji clearly have pretty different goals
Rafa=FedKilla
Banned
Precisely. Akainu is a become justice itself type of guy while Fujitora is clearly the wandering ronin. Can't wait to see Fujitora's tragic past and his reason for wanting the end to Shichibukai.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Assassination Classroom 140
Nice conclusion to their story that we knew before. Students will probably tear up.
Nice conclusion to their story that we knew before. Students will probably tear up.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Real Account 16
Despair faces were pretty silly in this artstyle, but kind of entertaining. Mukai is a really pleasant guy.
Despair faces were pretty silly in this artstyle, but kind of entertaining. Mukai is a really pleasant guy.
That bacteria does exist and i believe a Japanese research group made an experiment with street models to make better traffic routes or something. Author made the Toriko scale adjustments of course.
SenorArdilla
Member
Naruto 700+5
Ahaha! The Sauce did it. He actually did it. He tried to stab and threaten his own daughter.
Ahaha! The Sauce did it. He actually did it. He tried to stab and threaten his own daughter.
TheRealTalker
Banned
Final streatch, let's go!
KNIM 251-255
A long-distance relationship is not going to work if you see each other ever weekend and travel 650km for it. Like, what? Be reasonable people.
And now, chapter by chapter:
256
Yoooo hey, eternal love and stuff, then you break up over your first real roadbump? Get a grip you two. And how the hell do you break up while getting on a bullet train? Psssss.
257
Haruto used work recovery. It was pretty efficient.
Now do that threesome thingy with Adachi and Yamazaki, no holding back anymore!
258
Akari/Takashi really do make for better chapters. And I mean, I get the reason for breaking up, but you would think they could go about it in a more mature way. Like, talk about it? Not break up in the spur of the moment and never see each other again because the train took off?
Well, who am I kidding...
259
Who would have guessed that he would transfer to Tokyo at some point? Nooooo way.
I hope he's feeling silly now for not at least trying to get that relationship thingy going a bit longer. Would be fun if Yuzuki has gotten herself another man by now, or something similary devastating. But alas, we only have 2 more chapters and a happy end to get. Boooring.
260
Haha, of course. Dude dumped you on a train platform, if you're unlucky you could've even dropped down the rails and got run over because of the sudden shock, but you still waited nearly two years anyway, without a word. These two are way to forgiving to each other while ticking off all the other people around 'em.
But if Haruto ever forgets a simple promise to go shopping with Yuzuki again, like he did back then when he was all about that cooking, she'll go into hiding for days until he jumps of the tallest building I guess.
Dumb.
261 END
Well, I guess that's the way it had to end, right?
And Asuka was never shown with another man. Pft.
Well, that's a wrap, thanks MangaGAF for keeping me company in these dark times. Overall, Kimi No Iru Machi wasn't even that bad. There were some good parts, like the Kazama Arc and some of the side character stories later on, even Haruto was a kinda decent MC for half of the story. What ultimately killed it for me was the rather ugly break-up with Asuka to be with a woman that always played around, was selfish and never truly trusted Haruto. Even Yuzuki herself seemed to admit that plottwist was junk, since she turned into a lesser version of Asuka during her time as the girlfriend.
KNIM 251-255
A long-distance relationship is not going to work if you see each other ever weekend and travel 650km for it. Like, what? Be reasonable people.
And now, chapter by chapter:
256
Yoooo hey, eternal love and stuff, then you break up over your first real roadbump? Get a grip you two. And how the hell do you break up while getting on a bullet train? Psssss.
257
Haruto used work recovery. It was pretty efficient.
Now do that threesome thingy with Adachi and Yamazaki, no holding back anymore!
258
Akari/Takashi really do make for better chapters. And I mean, I get the reason for breaking up, but you would think they could go about it in a more mature way. Like, talk about it? Not break up in the spur of the moment and never see each other again because the train took off?
Well, who am I kidding...
259
Who would have guessed that he would transfer to Tokyo at some point? Nooooo way.
I hope he's feeling silly now for not at least trying to get that relationship thingy going a bit longer. Would be fun if Yuzuki has gotten herself another man by now, or something similary devastating. But alas, we only have 2 more chapters and a happy end to get. Boooring.
260
Haha, of course. Dude dumped you on a train platform, if you're unlucky you could've even dropped down the rails and got run over because of the sudden shock, but you still waited nearly two years anyway, without a word. These two are way to forgiving to each other while ticking off all the other people around 'em.
But if Haruto ever forgets a simple promise to go shopping with Yuzuki again, like he did back then when he was all about that cooking, she'll go into hiding for days until he jumps of the tallest building I guess.
Dumb.
261 END
Well, I guess that's the way it had to end, right?
And Asuka was never shown with another man. Pft.
Well, that's a wrap, thanks MangaGAF for keeping me company in these dark times. Overall, Kimi No Iru Machi wasn't even that bad. There were some good parts, like the Kazama Arc and some of the side character stories later on, even Haruto was a kinda decent MC for half of the story. What ultimately killed it for me was the rather ugly break-up with Asuka to be with a woman that always played around, was selfish and never truly trusted Haruto. Even Yuzuki herself seemed to admit that plottwist was junk, since she turned into a lesser version of Asuka during her time as the girlfriend.
really?
the more you know
It's a recurring theme in Toriko using obscure creatures with peculiar abilities as reference point but powered up thousandfold to fit the manga's madness. Very cool.
Naruto 705
The man closest to being a sharingan tank appeared! Can he fulfill the prophecy?
Glad to hear that you at least somewhat enjoyed yourself reading it. I must admit I'm impressed by how composed and analytical you remained during the whole thing.
The breakup was completely out of character, Haruto spent the last years doing life changing decisions around Yuzuki, he never really cared for a carrer, and suddenly he breaks with her due to his job?
Yeah, not buying it. It really felt like a forced scenario to bring some drama to the story before the happy ending.
261 chapters?
That's even longer than I recalled, I can't believe the majority of the series was the slice of life section.
Anyway glad you enjoyed it, from your impressions I thought you were going to have an overall more negative opinion of it.
Shouta
Member
Ooh Kasahara is doing FMP Zero? His artwork is godlike.
Not everyone can have an as great of a breakdown as Costi-kun~
It's because the characters were too flat to care about and most events were over too quick to really unfold into serious drama, so I could read the story more with curios glee than emotional investment. Additionaly I've read shit way worse than that to be shaken by it, I guess.
I'm a pretty forgiving guy when it comes to entertainment, I can bitch and moan about it and still enjoy stuff and at times even welcome the negative emotions. Rarely does something upset me to the point of dropping and outright hating it, and KNIM was a pretty inoffensive read all in all.
My honest trying-to-be-objective opinion of it would be way worse. The art is ugly, the romance poorly done, the pacing a mess and the only redeeming quality of the manga is the depiction of friendship, both with Kazama/Asuka and Akari/Takashi. Everything else is frankly pretty bad. It's junk food manga. You just have the urge to get this stuff at times, knowing it's bad, experiencing the bland unhealthiness and regretting it deep down afterwards. But you still enjoyed it and will surely come back for more in the future. You can't escape. You don't want to either.
Or I'm just a crazy masochist. Who knows?
Was that in some older thread? I'm intrigued.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Haikyuu!! 159
Omg my favorite Karasuno combo is definitely TsukiKage. Tsukki controlling the tempo and then, bring the one to spike Kageyama's ball. Incredibly chapter.
Final panel was amazing.
Omg my favorite Karasuno combo is definitely TsukiKage. Tsukki controlling the tempo and then, bring the one to spike Kageyama's ball. Incredibly chapter.
Final panel was amazing.
Dedication Through Light
Member
2015: A Space Series 14
Finally a space essay on hope and preseverence. Humanity will always prevail over climate change, war, and other acts of god.
Finally a space essay on hope and preseverence. Humanity will always prevail over climate change, war, and other acts of god.
Oh, I can definitely understand that.
It's just that it's less fun for us to not see you experience all the RAGE~
It begins here, and the fun part comes around five pages later.
Costi-kun has never been the same after that.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Snailogy
Aidyn is too hawt especially that outfit, but also for not smoking or drugs or etc.
ColossalLazy
Member
Maou no Hajimekata 3
Our evil lord succesfully "train" the captured heroine into one of his minions.
This chapter was essentially a hentai chapter.
Our evil lord succesfully "train" the captured heroine into one of his minions.
This chapter was essentially a hentai chapter.
Thanks, that was a pretty sad flow of events. The poor guy even liked Yuzuki in the beginning. :O
It's especially great how Costi tried to recommend KNIM to newcomers a couple of months later.
And now I feel ashamed for my poor performance at showing my emotions through words. I will do better next time, I still have to reread Nozoki Ana from the beginning some time, stopped at Volume 7 once I think, that was a story that really brought me to tears because I had to hit too much stuff while reading.
Save 'N Quit
Banned
That "Bitch, please" face.
That "Father, son" resemblance.
I enjoyed seeing those almost as much as seeing Sasuke continuing to prove how much of a shitty dad he is.
That "Father, son" resemblance.
I enjoyed seeing those almost as much as seeing Sasuke continuing to prove how much of a shitty dad he is.
ColossalLazy
Member
Yotsuba 87.2
Cleaning is serious business. Yotsuba too cute with the apron.
Cleaning is serious business. Yotsuba too cute with the apron.
Infinite Justice
Member
It was crazy to see Costi-kun go full Stockholm Syndrome for a little while, even organizing a Suzuka reading club, which a dozen of us (including myself) were stupid enough to participate, and referring to Seo as MangaGAF Hero Seo Kouji.
Good times.
Infinite Justice
Member
All of you were insane.
That prize banner tho.
ArclightBorealis
Member
That was a hell of a time for me to get acquainted with MangaGAF.
I spared myself from that club, thankfully.
Save 'N Quit
Banned
Best panels from the chapters.
Unfortunately couldn't save either chapter from the same levels of awfulness.
Unfortunately couldn't save either chapter from the same levels of awfulness.
You could have put one of your favorites series on that prize banner had you participated, though!
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll