Cool. Thanks for clearing that up. I just looked at it on my computer and it was pretty clearly him. In fact, it didn't even look like art on my phone. Just another screenshot.
I did MaleShep when I first played ME1, got four hours into the game and put it down because I wasn't feeling it. Picked it up again a month later, started over with FemShep and never looked back.
I do my main run with male Shep, then my second playthrough with FemShep. Played ME1 7 times thorough to get the achievements. ME2 a few times, didn't get as many achievements though.