So I got that baseball game, here's my very brief impressions (only got to play for about 20ish minutes) -
Seems pretty okay. The controls might take a little bit to get used to. Like with pitching, you can select the pitch with either the d-pad or the shoulder buttons, but you move the cursor with the analog. Fielding some hits brings up a button prompt and if you miss, the ball goes by you. Running and hitting seemed simple enough, but I keep wanting to control everything with the d-pad and you can't. Might play a full game or two and get settled in, I only had time for about two innings.
You can also make a custom team. You pick home and away uniforms, with lots of colors and designs, but preset stuff. No making your own logos or patterns that I can see. You can also edit each character, with multiple body sizes (though female is just "girl" and there's only the one female body), skin tones/hair styles and colors/facial features, and which hand they bat and throw with, also which way they throw, like overhand or sidearm, etc.
I don't think you can edit stats at all, but I played with a custom team that I'd only customized one player for, and the other teams all had stats but mine, and five-star ratings scale for each. Mine had no stars yet. So maybe as you perform, you can have your level go up or down? Not sure. There was also a team spot marked with ? so I'm assuming you unlock something, no idea what.
But for $5, it seems not bad. I like baseball games when they aren't too sim-focused, and this doesn't seem to be.
