• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Nintendo E3 2017 Spotlight Thread: Not my problem. [Over]

What game are you most excited for?


Results are only viewable after voting.
Looks like my expectations were exactly on the dot, though Nintendo certainly did the bare minimum to clear the bar of what I said I'd be happy to hear and disappointed not to hear (one of the following: AC, Metroid, Platinum, Retro).

To be honest, though, this was a decently strong presentation, especially given its abbreviated running time.

- After seeing that English voices and localized text are in, I've swung all the way from extreme doubt that Xenoblade 2 will make 2017 to high confidence that it will. Placing Mario in October (rather than the usual late November slot Nintendo likes so much) clears plenty of room for it.

- Odyssey's core ability is exceptionally promising. Love that Pauline is back; love the song.

- Rocket League has been one of the top third-party requests for the Switch ever since it was announced. This was one of the biggest ports they could have landed (outside of games like Overwatch that clearly weren't going to happen).

- I felt that first-party side-scrollers were conspicuously missing from the Switch, especially as 2D Mario was unlikely to hit anytime soon. So Kirby was nice to have—but a second Good-Feel Yoshi (I assume it's theirs) was the best plausible item to fill this slot. This is definitely at the top of my shopping list for 2018 (seeing as how Prime 4 remains undated).

- Given how nothing was shown of Prime 4—this reminds me of the way SMTxFE (later Tokyo Mirage Sessions) was teased—I doubt we'll even hear about it again until E3 2018. This now joins main-line Pokémon and main-line FE in an unusually large category of minimal reassurances from Nintendo that something indeterminate exists.
 
Good stream in general. Mario Odyssey looks fantastic, Xenoblade 2, Yoshi, Breath of Wild DLC, Kirby etc...

Also since Retro isn't working on Metriod Prime 4, makes me wonder what they're developing instead. Curious about that.
 
Holy shit, Metroid Prime 4 is a thing!? Also, y'all are crazy, Super Mario Oddysee looks incredible! IMO, Nintendo easily had the best conference of E3. They had actual exclusive games you can't get anywhere else, and some of them will actually be out this year. Also, I wonder what the chances are for a Metroid Prime Trilogy HD on Switch before MP4 hits?
 
That was an overall decent showing. New Kirby and Yoshi, Metroid Prime 4 and new Pokemon rpg confirmed, plus cross play Rocket League
 
I need to see what the third party developers are doing. Rocket League is loved by a lot of people, but that doesn't really suffice as strong support.

The Big N dropped some bombshells, but we won't be seeing those for a while. But at least there will be stuff to play before Pokemon and Metroid release. I was expecting Mario to launch in November based on tradition, so the release date took me by surprise.
This is what I want to know.

The "oh, Switch is a surprise hit" grace period is gone. You have Ubisoft putting a ton of effort into MxRK and Bethesda porting Skyrim. Wtf is the rest of the third-party support?
 
Metroid Prime 4 was a bombshell, and I'm excited to see Kirby and Yoshi games coming next year already. Those seem like a lock for early 2018.

Mario looked mind-blowingly incredible and I'm so happy it's coming in October. I'm also sad that it's coming in October because that's the same day that Assassin's Creed will release...

Rocket League was a nice surprise and the whole cross-network play thing is awesome. It's looking like Switch + Xbox will be the dream combination for me going forward.

Otherwise, I'm slightly disappointed at the lack of Virtual Console news but I can't say I won't have anything to play on Switch this year! GG Nintendo.
 
A logo (Prime 4) and a voice confirmation of work on a new game (Pokemon) are not good E3 announcements.

The fact that the two new games they did show were from the exact same genre is really disappointing.
 
So quoting my predictions earlier:

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=240516069&postcount=7769

Making my final predictions before the world comes to an end:

- Mario Odyssey will be the game of E3. (yep seems to be likely)
- Xenoblade 2 will be a 2017 title. Repent you non-believers while you still can. (told ya)
- Monster hunter XX localization baybeee! (oops. mia)
- Fire Emblem Warriors full trailer (got it)
- A glimpse of Fire Emblem for Switch will be shown (didn't happen)
- Breath of the Wild DLC for the story content to be revealed (got that right)
- Slight Pokken Tournament trailer (I guess I got it too...maybe. We got a mainline Pokemon though)
- New Retro game will be shown. It will not be Metroid unfortunately. (It's actually the opposite lol.Metroid was shown, but Retro was missing)
- Smash Bros for Switch. (hahaha...c'mon Nintendo :( )

I guess that's 25 minutes worth of content lol.

I guess that's a good %FG. KD-esque lol.
 
Im a Sony fan, but microsft showed us 40 plus games and announced Xbox compatability and showed a new console, yeah no
Of which 35 ou will be able to eventually play on Playstation. Oh but Super Lucky's tail looks amazing
/s

Anyway pretty good showing. MP4 and Pokemon games are far out though.

MS 4/10 - Forza looks great and the console is sexy af
Beth - 5/10 Wolfenstein looked amazing
EA 4/10 Battelfront woop woop
Sony 7/10 No surprises(outside SOTC) but showed more tipple A exclusives than anyone else. Sony e3 2013 being a 6/10, 2014 3/10, 2015 a 8/10 and 2016 9/10
Ninendo 6/10 Surprise factor there and Mario looks fun but damn are there going to be software droughts.
Ubisoft 7.5 Well I never.
 
Wanted to play classic games on the go with a decent screen. That's not the only reason I'm jumping off. Mario looks meh and nothing interests me so far except the Pokemon game which won't release until the end of next year. The complete lack of 3rd from not just AAA devs, but indie devs too. Just nothing here for me.

Wouldn't it be easier to say you're not interested 3rd party offerings shown instead of pretending they don't exist?
 
This was a really mediocre E3 when confirmation of a Rocket League port alone made me more excited then anything Sony or Microsoft showed.
 
Mario is looking great from the Treehouse stream. Seems like it will be a nice, chill game to play. Love the 2D mural bits.
 
I'm so bored with Yoshi and Kirby. So many more exciting IPs they should prioritize.

As long as they retain the quality of Return to Dreamland, Triple Deluxe and Robobot, Nintendo can keep making Kirby games until the end of time and I'll be happy.

And as much as I love Metroid Prime, I'm more hype for Kirby :X
 
Of which 35 ou will be able to eventually play on Playstation. Oh but Super Lucky's tail looks amazing
/s

Anyway pretty good showing. MP4 and Pokemon games are far out though.

MS 4/10 - Forza looks great and the console is sexy af
Beth - 5/10 Wolfenstein looked amazing
EA 4/10 Battelfront woop woop
Sony 7/10 No surprises(outside SOTC) but showed more tipple A exclusives than anyone else. Sony e3 2013 being a 6/10, 2014 3/10, 2015 a 8/10 and 2016 9/10
Ninendo 6/10 Surprise factor there and Mario looks fun but damn are there going to be software droughts.
Ubisoft 7.5 Well I never.

Huh? 2017 is stacked
 
They should have just made a Mario game with this 2D/3D mix being the main focus.

This game just seems like they're throwing a ton of disjointed ideas at Mario.
 
Top Bottom