XY the best pokemon games up till now. Fight me.
- EXP share is awesome, but can get you easily OP. While without it I find the game hard (that is not negative)
- Way too many old mons. My best experience with Pokemon was RSE. It gave a huge world and it had a good mix of old and new mons. When I battle the E4 or other Trainers I want to think "Holy shit, what mon is that? What can it do?" and not think "Oh yeah that is a gyarados/mon x, just use thundershock/attack y". Most of the mons you already saw and I think the reason of that wasn´t because of the low amount of new mons, but rather with the constant spawning of every mon.
SM did this right, eventhough they literally showed every mon before.
- Postgame was nice, but too easy and most people don´t even know that there is a postgame
- routes and overworld look beautifull and are detailled. But the routes are way way way to linear. Just look at the route to the fairy gymn. You can´t explore anything else. Sun Moon have also this linear routes, but they are kinda like Souls 3. Linear but you can explore them better.
- legendaries aren´t hidden anymore.
Oh and making many mons not that good. E.g. goodra not having a water/fairy/poison or a at least getting recover (goodra would be completly viable in gen 5 with weather wars, but this was so drastically nerfed in gen 6 that he didn´t have a chance) and noivern e.g.