The thing is... He doesn't lie about anything he deems to be a problem in games so it's a stretch to say his reviews are inaccurate. If you look at his infamous witcher 3 review for example, he's not wrong about anything he says, it's just that those things didn't bother a lot of people or they actually found those aspects to be enjoyable.
He's an old school PC gamer and he likes what he likes. He also doesn't play any PC games with a controller so if the game has shit mouse and keyboard controls then it's immediately going to be in for a bad time on his channel.
A lot of the time (not all the time) my tastes align with his so I will always listen to what he has to say about a game but like with any single reviewer I won't take their word as gospel.
He just says what he thinks, he doesn't care if he upsets anybody and that's why he doesn't get review codes from a lot of publishers. Most publishers don't enjoy seeing their game get torn to shreds the moment the embargo ends. This is a good video that will give you an idea of what he's about:
To each their own. I just know my first experience with him was a DOOM Eternal preview and I remember a lot of the information he was going off of was incorrect and off. I mean, a simple Google search would've provided correct information. So, I was like, "Ehhhh, sounds like this guy doesn't do research", which for any kind of YouTube personality or influencer is pretty off putting to me. If that was just some schtick, well, then fair enough, haha. I guess he just isn't my cup of tea.
That bad? I actually had fun with the Friday the 13th game although it got old fast. Glad i didn't impulse buy it then.
Honestly I personally wouldn't go as far as to say it's "shite", but to each their own. However, I CAN say, if you loved F13 but it got old fast, I feel like you may have the same experience here. I'm having a lot of fun with it on PC. Apparently a lot of performance issues are currently on PS4. There are definitely some bug fixes, buffs, nerfs, etc. that would make this game better, but just give it some time. Plus, it wouldn't hurt to see what they have planned for future content if you feel like you can wait a bit. The standard edition is already below standard MSRP, but I'd feel like the time it drops to $20, it's incredibly worth it. Even more so considering by that point I'm sure a large number of things will have been ironed out.