I dont think many are "justifying" anything by pointing out reasons why they are choosing the Xbone version. I own both consoes since launch, and have purchased many more games on ps4 over xb1, and spend alot more time on my ps4. Pointing out controller preference, preferring Xbox Live, or having more friends that play COD on Xbox is hardly "justifying". Its simply pointng out there are other factors other than resolution alone in making that decision (for those of us fortunate enough to own both consoles).
Which still adds absolutely nothing to an resolution topic.
If you're and others are so eager to talk about it, the OT works pretty great.
These answers just don't bring anything into the discussion, they just blow it up and people will provoke each other and we know the circle...
It's fine to choose whatever platform you prefer, but it comes across as justifying or a more harmless version of thread whining.
The size of NeoGaf has gotten so big over the years, topics like these easily get blown out of proportion.
Plus the actual discussion wouldn't even be constantly on page 1, if people didn't bring it up over and over again.