Wow, the "qualification" issue.
It is pretty much a lock to come up EVERY time, at every field wherever something like this is brought up.
Folks, it is the just world fallacy. You assume that everyone already in there already used proper means to get there. Problem is: it is not a just world. There have been countless studies and examples where white male circles tend to dominate otherwise large, relatively diverse groups because of social circles being formed and they themselves favoring each other over quality.
Just stop with this.
Also: game awards and qualifications? Do not hold delusions, please. They all wuw the new Call of Duty (some 7/10 love it, others 9/10 love it, others wish they could play it RIGHT NOW), they enjoy wandering around in Fallout 4, they just love the new Tomb Raider, embrace FIFA 16, and they all have a favorite of indie game out of a selection of 8-10 indie games this year. Oh, and do not get me started on Witcher 3.
They are all soooo qualified. You are bound to get the true gems come out of this year's awards as winners as well. Damn those wymin trying to steal the qualified positions with their boobs!
Quick edit: And uhm... the cherry on top? "50-50 would be unjust, SO 95-5 is where at is. Its all good".
Yes, its all good.