Oh yeah absolutely, if we are talking exclusively about face models TLOU2 is better, and also Uncharted 4 (that i sometimes think is even above tlou2), Death Stranding also has amazing characters models and face models, i was talking about the overall tech of the game, RDR2 has a lot going on and have much more interactivity level, and seeing a game at that level of details and graphics with so much stuffs around and everything in real time in just another level. While in TLOU2 it looks incredible but in a lot of place you are limited to walking and there isn't much going on around, i think we always need take into account those kind of things when comparing tech, because those kind of stuffs also have their part on the processing hardware.
Yeah HDR was bad on RDR2 PS4 pro, weirdly it didn't have same bug on Xbox One X, i'm not sure but i heard some saying HDR was fixed on RDR2 PS4 Pro.