• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Wii U Achievements/Trophies

Good old Mario coins would have been better.

fdq7F.png
 
Would have preferred something a little more Nintendo themed, Stars or Coins or something.

Accomplishments is like one whole syllable more than Achievements, and two more than Trophies, I'm not sure I have that extra syllable in me to say it all the time.
 
I don't have a huge problem with the name but I spend very little time talking about this stuff verbally. As long as it doesn't get an insufferable shorthand like "cheevos" I'm fine. I want to scream every time I read that.
 
No real surprise that it's called an "Accomplishent" -- that's the same nomenclature as on 3DS. I don't think there will be any quantitative value assigned to each one either. Probably like Steam Achievements.

Would definitely be cool to get rewarded in some kind of Wii U variation on Play Coins, however. You can't walk around with one so you earn them by actually playing games.
 
Coins for individual accomplishments. A red coin or star for their platinum.

I would have had Coins for normal ones, have Yellow worth 1, and Red and Blue are worth 2 and 5 respectively iirc, and then have a Star as their version of a Platinum Trophy.

From memory there were Silver and Purple coins too in some games, plenty of options for Nintendo to have difficulty or rareness according to coin colour.
 
I don't like a numerical value attached to the accomplishments. The XBOX achievement scores got so ridiculous once they added DLC achievements. No uniformity whatsoever.

But I think there should be one icon (gold cup, silver cup) or percentage (like ps3) assigned to each game indicative of the overall progress. Just something for the completionist out there or for friendly comparisons between friends.
 
Coins and stars would have probably ended up confusing the mainstream who are on club nintendo, seeing as stars and coins are used in the shops in america and europe.
 
I would not want coins. It's confusing enough with Club Nintendo. Plus, those red coins are evil. Hate collecting those bad boys. :P

I do wish they would make a little channel or whatever the Wii U is getting where we can browse our trophies like that trophy room that I don't think ever showed up with Home.
 
I am surprised they're not going with something more Nintendo themed. I hope Accomplishments, especially if they start using them on the 3DS for games, had up to bonuses like Play Coins, or Hats for the Plaza.

NeoGaf Accomplishment: turn 100 Nintendo threads to crap.

Trophcomplievment unlocked!

jflK0AvyQFGpG.png
 
People asking for "stickers" (what?), "coins", and "smiley face stars" have to keep in mind the system has to be ubiquitous of the entire catalog of software. Having something like a "smiley face star" for 30 head shots in Call of Duty: BLOPS 2 does not make sense.
 
Miyamoto says: No new 3DS model.
*New 3DS model announced*.
Miyamoto says: No achievement system.
*Accomplishments leaked*.

Miyamoto seems clueless on what's going on at Nintendo. Anyway, it should have been called Stars.
 
Wouldn't have thought so. Blizzard use that term.
Not sure where I'm going to be able to find this, but I have a feeling that the "Achievement" in regards to system wide level scoring rewards may be patented. Valve, Blizzard (and pretty much anyone else) can get away with it because their thing isn't a "system applied to a hardware level".
 
Miyamoto says: No new 3DS model.
*New 3DS model announced*.
Miyamoto says: No achievement system.
*Accomplishments leaked*.

Miyamoto seems clueless on what's going on at Nintendo. Anyway, it should have been called Stars.

Or.. maybe they follow their own schedule of when to make this information public?
 
Source link doesn't work for me. Why are we assuming this isn't a game specific thing (like Metroid Prime 3 or Wii Sports Resort)?
 
I like the trophy system and would have copied that wholesale

Coin- bronze

Red Coin- silver

Yoshi Coin- gold

Star- platinum

Or some shit
 
Yeah, I can easily see "comps" becoming shorthand for accomplishments. Also to echo an earlier sentiment, it would be nice if accomplishments could somehow be tied to Club Nintendo rewards.
 
I thought Nintendo don't wanted to enter that space? Or is that exclusive to 3rd party games? Or even on/off turnable?

MP3 on wii had achievements. Hell even SSBM on gamecube had achievements.
More recently Xenoblade has ahievements.

The question is whether it is a centralized unified system or remain game specific.
 
As long As I can stop them popping up in mid game I'll be happy. I prefer a summary at the end if anything and don't want game interrupted.
 
As others have mentioned, they've dabbled in this already:

3ds-accomplishments.jpg
You're even about 10 years late.
The father of the current achievements system used by MS and Sony, and it's still the best one too since it actually rewards the player with in-game content (in the case of this game, Kirby Air Ride, new stages, vehicles and game modes). Some would even argue it appeared back in SSBM but there wasn't a checklist system when you see the goals until Brawl.
It should be a standard for all the games with rich content. A globalised system like the achievements and trophies isn't as much interesting.

it should have been called SHINE GET
LLShC.gif
"SHINE GET : Kill all the aliens in sector 6"

:lol

Needs something neutral. Accomplishments is okay.
 
/pokes head into thread...

Interesting

Hmmm...

I wanted coins to be honest =/, Bronze, Silver, Gold, and Star as Plat
 
You're even about 10 years late.

If you want to go even further back, the GameBoy Camera rewarded you with Album B pictures for meeting certain requirements. However there was unless you kept track of the stats you'd have no idea why you unlocked certain images.
 
Give me a Brawl/Icarus system and I'd be happy -- one in which every challenge unlocks something.

definitely this. kirby's air ride, brawl, kid icarus uprising all have fantastic achievement systems.

achievements rewarding you with in game content = awesome

achievements awarding "gamerscore" or something akin to that = completely meaningless

my opinion, at least.
 
This. It was interesting at first, but the stupid points system has held back the 360's (and by extension, the PS3's) Achievement system. Let developers add all the achievements they want without having to worry about an arbitrary points cap.

Disagree.

I am absolutely not a trophy-whore. I have not one single platinum. However, the quickest way to get me to not care about your achievement system is to not have any overall score, level, or maybe reward associated with it. Doesn't feel like there's any "point" to doing them. It's like getting the high-score on an offline-only game. Who gives a shit. That's why that, other than the sale promotions, I have mostly ignored Steam achievements.

Yes, I know that my gamerscore and trophy level are mostly meaningless but personally it gives me a sense of progression. It helps me to care a little. And caring about the goals is what makes them fun to try to do.
 
Disagree.

I am absolutely not a trophy-whore. I have not one single platinum. However, the quickest way to get me to not care about your achievement system is to not have any overall score, level, or maybe reward associated with it. Doesn't feel like there's any "point" to doing them. It's like getting the high-score on an offline-only game. Who gives a shit. That's why that, other than the sale promotions, I have mostly ignored
Steam achievements.

Yes, I know that my gamerscore and trophy level are mostly meaningless but personally it gives me a sense of progression. It helps me to care a little. And caring about the goals is what makes them fun to try to do.
Agreed. Without a sense of completion I wouldnt try nearly as hard to get any achievements/trophies.

Also agree with the people saying that they shouldnt use Nintendo icons as their accomplishments.
 
I prefer the Steam model. Just ticking them off is fine by me and since the focus is on the images you bother to look at which specific challenges people have done rather than looking at an overall number. Also it allows them to add more at a later date.
 
Or hes lying.

You're joking, right? I'm sorry it's hard to tell on the internet. If not, then he wouldn't have commented at all, it's not like such an influential character would just randomly start lying.

Or.. maybe they follow their own schedule of when to make this information public?

I don't follow what that's got to do with anything? Are you saying that Miyamoto didn't know that Nintendo were working on a new 3DS model and the achievements? That's ridiculous!
 
Top Bottom