It's gotten better for me in just the few days since I've had the preview. It started off barely doing anything for me, and now it has a pretty high success rate. It feels like Cortana is learning my commands, which is pretty cool. Hopefully they are able to update Cortana with all of this usage data from the preview program.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Xbox One Summer Update Preview (Cortana, new Game Library, Win10 app, more)
- Thread starter RoKKeR
- Start date
justgames7604
Member
Cortana doesnt work in australia. Fairly dissapointing.
While Cortana seems to be rather quick, the recognition in Germany is just terrible.
So far I couldn't get any app or game to open. Cortana just opens a bing search for it. I tried open(öffnen), starte(launch), goto(gehe zu) and even play(spiele) but it always brings up the bing search. Only gehe zu Startseite (goto home) works...
Also it doesn't recognize the game title names. Overwatch ends up being rush or something else.
Also inviting someone from my friends list into a party ends up in a bing search. Tried to invite lordofwar and it showed a bing result "starte party mit lotto 4"
I know this is a beta, but this seems to be at least 3 months away from being at least on the same level as the old voice commands...
So far I couldn't get any app or game to open. Cortana just opens a bing search for it. I tried open(öffnen), starte(launch), goto(gehe zu) and even play(spiele) but it always brings up the bing search. Only gehe zu Startseite (goto home) works...
Also it doesn't recognize the game title names. Overwatch ends up being rush or something else.
Also inviting someone from my friends list into a party ends up in a bing search. Tried to invite lordofwar and it showed a bing result "starte party mit lotto 4"
I know this is a beta, but this seems to be at least 3 months away from being at least on the same level as the old voice commands...
BananasWithGuns
Member
Yeah, I agree. It's ridiculously awkward to use. They should at least keep the Xbox command around as an option.
I was viciously looking for settings or options to bring back what I'm used to. Maybe if I learn her command list better, but she's much too slow for my liking and often opens up the browser when I don't want to.
Sigh.
The price of advancement.
Alx
Member
It's going to be worse before it gets better. 
Things are already improving, I don't have the duplicate names bugs any more (at least not today), and I could start many games and apps without any major issue.
It still won't handle "go to Assassin's Creed" for some reason, still does a web search. "Go to Banjo" would lead to a disambiguation question on an empty list, "Go to (Banjo) Kazooie" will start the B&K game but won't ask whether I wanted N&Bolts.
Things are already improving, I don't have the duplicate names bugs any more (at least not today), and I could start many games and apps without any major issue.
It still won't handle "go to Assassin's Creed" for some reason, still does a web search. "Go to Banjo" would lead to a disambiguation question on an empty list, "Go to (Banjo) Kazooie" will start the B&K game but won't ask whether I wanted N&Bolts.
Pegasus Actual
Member
Cortana is trash right now. Record that now lags by an extra 5+ seconds ruining clips. It doesn't respond to time periods even though it hears me perfectly. I want it faster and more accurate than the old command, with more options, and right now it's failing on all points.
It refuses to launch games. I mean, it searched bing for "play Titanfall" (along with all the "play" aliases listed in that linked official forum post elsewhere in the thread). TV still has no improvement, "Xbox watch Fox Sports 2" would take me to Fox Sports 1. "Hey Cortana watch Fox Sports 2" bings "watch Fox Sports 2" for me.
I'd have really thought it would be farther along at this point just based on the fact that the speech recognition part was working fine back in that build 6+ months ago where you could glitch into a version of Cortana that wasn't meant for the public. At least it doesn't steal focus from my games when it does an idiot bing search. Invite to party and send message kind of worked ok, but so far that's the only place I've seen any useful integration.
Aside from the Cortana stuff I haven't noticed a whole lot. The new My Games and Apps is an improvement. Otherwise general responsiveness of the UI while navigating with the controller is pretty much the same as best I can tell.
The OS guys have got some work to do.
It refuses to launch games. I mean, it searched bing for "play Titanfall" (along with all the "play" aliases listed in that linked official forum post elsewhere in the thread). TV still has no improvement, "Xbox watch Fox Sports 2" would take me to Fox Sports 1. "Hey Cortana watch Fox Sports 2" bings "watch Fox Sports 2" for me.
I'd have really thought it would be farther along at this point just based on the fact that the speech recognition part was working fine back in that build 6+ months ago where you could glitch into a version of Cortana that wasn't meant for the public. At least it doesn't steal focus from my games when it does an idiot bing search. Invite to party and send message kind of worked ok, but so far that's the only place I've seen any useful integration.
Aside from the Cortana stuff I haven't noticed a whole lot. The new My Games and Apps is an improvement. Otherwise general responsiveness of the UI while navigating with the controller is pretty much the same as best I can tell.
The OS guys have got some work to do.
I have exactly the same problems with the German version
Same problems with Cortana - even when it hears me and the correct words come up, there's no way to know what it will do. "Launch Mirror's Edge Catalyst" brought me to a Bing search of the same, with articles about its launch. They really should require a "Bing" command before anything outside the system is pulled up.
SlipperyFishes
Banned
I wonder if Microsoft will allow a choice of basic (Xbox On)and advanced (Hey Cortana). I really don't need Cortana
RowdyReverb
Member
Yeah, "Hey Cortana, Pause" is going to have to be twice as quick as it is currently.
Same here (also wrote more on the last page).
For now you can change your region to Austria.
If you don´t buy anything, it doesn´t really matter and Austria still has the old voice commands working perfectly since there is no Cortana there.
SEGAvangelist
Member
It's such a waste of resources. No one asked for this.
Death Metalist
Member
Background music, pls.
Broken Joystick
At least you can talk. Who are you?
EA Access is free from June 12-22, might be something to do with that?
Dynamic themes with ambient music ala PS4 and Wii U please
Turns a dashboard into a homely hub
Berlin_Wall
Member
To my german fellows: is there a list with the common voice Input lines? For example for volume down, turn off and so on
GringoSuave89
Banned
Maybe, it actually surprised me enough to check my email to make sure nobody accessed my account.
LordBaztion
Member
Just got the new update, Cortana it's hard to use, I find hard to make her recognize what I'm saying, it may be because of my latin accent, nevertheless it's an improvement over the older voice recognition, I never could make it work, at least in English, in Spanish it worked fine.
Still, Cortana is difficult to use, it took mea while to senda message to a friend, however it's incredibly cool to send messages without leaving the game.
Still, Cortana is difficult to use, it took mea while to senda message to a friend, however it's incredibly cool to send messages without leaving the game.
Hispanic! At the Disco
Member
It finallly let me register for the new update so I should be added in the next wave. How often are the waves added?
Also I'll do my job when I get it and suggest that;
1. You could choose between basic voice controls or Cortana
And
2. You could create a custom greeting that starts cortana, so you dont have to say "hey", or maybe still be able to say "xbox" or something new altogether. Like activating voice controls when I say "Jarvis"
Also I'll do my job when I get it and suggest that;
1. You could choose between basic voice controls or Cortana
And
2. You could create a custom greeting that starts cortana, so you dont have to say "hey", or maybe still be able to say "xbox" or something new altogether. Like activating voice controls when I say "Jarvis"
You wont seize my vocabulary America!
I don't get why cortana searches bing instead of opening up the app itself. The only way I could get it to work is by saying "Hey Cortana, open the app YouTube" and sometimes it takes me to the store to download the app even though I have it installed already. Jeez they messed up big time with this cortana shit. Absolutely useless right now.
P.S saying open the app is extremely annoying and inconvenient
P.S saying open the app is extremely annoying and inconvenient
This is listed in the known bugs section.
Penguins&PolarBears
Member
So far Cortana in it's current implementation makes the voice experience on Xbox far more frustrating, slower and less reliable. I'm not sure whether this is something they can reasonably fix before the planned Summer release. Here's my experience with Cortana so far:
When I issue commands to Xbox it is causing non-stop searches, chatter, and actions on my nearby Windows 10 phone, PC or tablet. For example "Hey Cortana Go Home," an essential and frequent Xbox command, will initiate GPS navigation on my Windows devices. Asking Cortana to play a song or artist would cause utter chaos as each device begins playing music. Most other commands will cause confusion on nearby Windows devices which then produces a Cortana response that gets picked up by the Xbox causing the Xbox to also get confused. Two possible solutions I can think of is 1.) to add an option to only activate a response when you direct Cortana to a device, "Hey Cortana Go to Xbox, Hey Cortana go to phone, Hey Cortana go to PC." Until you tell her where to listen to you she stays quiet. That would work for me. Option 2.) just let us choose the name of the assistant on each device. I don't know if the marketing department likes that solution, but it would work very well and personalize the digital assistant experience. A third and best solution would be that they make the whole service smarter and use any known inputs to only activate Cortana on the last device you interacted with.
As it stands right now even if I turn off those nearby Windows devices (a poor/unacceptable solution) the experience with Cortana is pure frustration. It's not a matter of words not being recognized as the words that display on screen are generally accurate. The major problem seems to be the cloud processing which is both unreliable and slow. When Cortana's servers become overwhelmed, something which happens way too frequently, the utility of Cortana on all Windows devices grinds to zero. "She" tells you some quip about not communicating with the internet or something silly. I get this response from Cortana about 85% of the time now. This might be mildly annoying when you're looking up facts on a web search, but when you're trying to do basic navigation like open YouTube, get back to the previous screen, or pause a video it becomes unbelievably frustrating. My final problem is more of a complaint towards Cortana itself which is that over the past couple years of using it I see many more features being added, but not more polish or reliability. When Microsoft delayed Cortana on Xbox I thought it was to polish the experience for consumers, but it seems the only focus was to just get a bad Cortana experience functional with headsets. It is obvious that Cortana is more powerful than previous voice controls and can do far more than anything we had previously, but it may also make the voice experience so unreliable and slow to the point of not being useful at all.
Hopefully they can surprise me and improve the speed and connection reliability before launch, but for now I just see this as potentially yet another step backward for Xbox One's utility.
When I issue commands to Xbox it is causing non-stop searches, chatter, and actions on my nearby Windows 10 phone, PC or tablet. For example "Hey Cortana Go Home," an essential and frequent Xbox command, will initiate GPS navigation on my Windows devices. Asking Cortana to play a song or artist would cause utter chaos as each device begins playing music. Most other commands will cause confusion on nearby Windows devices which then produces a Cortana response that gets picked up by the Xbox causing the Xbox to also get confused. Two possible solutions I can think of is 1.) to add an option to only activate a response when you direct Cortana to a device, "Hey Cortana Go to Xbox, Hey Cortana go to phone, Hey Cortana go to PC." Until you tell her where to listen to you she stays quiet. That would work for me. Option 2.) just let us choose the name of the assistant on each device. I don't know if the marketing department likes that solution, but it would work very well and personalize the digital assistant experience. A third and best solution would be that they make the whole service smarter and use any known inputs to only activate Cortana on the last device you interacted with.
As it stands right now even if I turn off those nearby Windows devices (a poor/unacceptable solution) the experience with Cortana is pure frustration. It's not a matter of words not being recognized as the words that display on screen are generally accurate. The major problem seems to be the cloud processing which is both unreliable and slow. When Cortana's servers become overwhelmed, something which happens way too frequently, the utility of Cortana on all Windows devices grinds to zero. "She" tells you some quip about not communicating with the internet or something silly. I get this response from Cortana about 85% of the time now. This might be mildly annoying when you're looking up facts on a web search, but when you're trying to do basic navigation like open YouTube, get back to the previous screen, or pause a video it becomes unbelievably frustrating. My final problem is more of a complaint towards Cortana itself which is that over the past couple years of using it I see many more features being added, but not more polish or reliability. When Microsoft delayed Cortana on Xbox I thought it was to polish the experience for consumers, but it seems the only focus was to just get a bad Cortana experience functional with headsets. It is obvious that Cortana is more powerful than previous voice controls and can do far more than anything we had previously, but it may also make the voice experience so unreliable and slow to the point of not being useful at all.
Hopefully they can surprise me and improve the speed and connection reliability before launch, but for now I just see this as potentially yet another step backward for Xbox One's utility.
First post this feedback via the console
https://twitter.com/majornelson/status/654301730323062784/photo/1
& then on their forums to give them a heads-up & escalate it further...
Cortana doesn't get fixed without the feedback.
https://twitter.com/majornelson/status/654301730323062784/photo/1
& then on their forums to give them a heads-up & escalate it further...
Cortana doesn't get fixed without the feedback.
RowdyReverb
Member
What is the new "Xbox On" command?
"Hey Cortana, Xbox on"
RowdyReverb
Member
Doug Heffernan
Member
Ugh, the new store is so slow... slower now than the 360 store.
The new store is not... good I have put in feedback though.
RowdyReverb
Member
Are you guys getting "I can't connect at the moment" errors from Cortana?
Lots. I submit feedback each time because I want to annoy them with how annoying it not working is.
darkinstinct
...lacks reading comprehension.
That might be because they don't dedicate as many server ressources to the preview version because right now the standard version is stilll more important. Speed can be improved quite easily.
I think my main issue with Cortana right now is speed.
Last night I was watching Netflix and tried to pause via voice command like I always do. Cortana recognized the command perfectly, however, it just sat there, "thinking" without actually pausing the video for more than 10s until it finally decided to work.
The same is happening right now with commands that need to work on the go, like record that and take a screenshot.
Much work ahead until this is in a releasable state.
Last night I was watching Netflix and tried to pause via voice command like I always do. Cortana recognized the command perfectly, however, it just sat there, "thinking" without actually pausing the video for more than 10s until it finally decided to work.
The same is happening right now with commands that need to work on the go, like record that and take a screenshot.
Much work ahead until this is in a releasable state.
muzzymate
Member
I noticed that when my Xbox is in standby mode, if I simply say "Hey Cortona", the Kinect light turns on. It eventually fades off after a few seconds. Probably means nothing, but had a brief thought, what if they do some sort of Amazon Echo thing with the Kinect being the center of it. Of course, the Xbox would need something else to channel the audio output too.
link1201
Member
No, if you wipe everything you'd need to re-enroll using the app associated with your gt. So if it's a clean Xbox it won't get the beta updates unless you re-enroll it.